Not as Described Chargeback: Evidence That Holds Up
Chargebacks, Fraud & Security

Not as Described Chargebacks: How to Defend Product Disputes

Learn how a not as described chargeback works under Visa and Mastercard rules, when to take the return, and what evidence wins the dispute.

Black and white photo of two men arm wrestling across a wooden table over crumpled US dollar bills

Photo: Pixabay

On this page 8 sections
  1. How Visa and Mastercard Code a Not as Described Chargeback
  2. Visa's Return Requirement for 13.3 Disputes
  3. Refusing the Return Counts Against You
  4. Your Product Page Is Exhibit One
  5. Custom and Opened Items Need Signed Specs
  6. Fight or Take It Back: The Break-Even Win Rate
  7. What Goes in the Response File
  8. Fix the Listings Behind Repeat Disputes

Key takeaways

  • Under Visa 13.3, the cardholder must return the item or try to first, and refusing a return counts as an attempt.
  • A disclosed final-sale or no-refund policy doesn't defeat a claim that the item didn't match its description.
  • Fight only when your expected win rate beats (merchandise cost + chargeback fee − return shipping) ÷ sale price.
  • Once a return arrives, refund it quickly. Visa gives you a 15-day window before the dispute can move forward.

A not as described chargeback is a card dispute where the customer admits making the purchase but says the item was materially different from what you advertised, or arrived defective. You win it with evidence you created before the sale: a listing that matches what you shipped and a return policy the buyer saw at checkout. You also need a record of whether the customer tried to send the item back. Under Visa's rules that last point carries real weight, because the cardholder is expected to return the goods, or at least try to, before the bank can file.

How Visa and Mastercard Code a Not as Described Chargeback

Every dispute notice carries a network reason code. For product complaints, these are the ones you'll see:

NetworkReason codeWhat the cardholder claims
Visa13.3 Not as Described or Defective Merchandise/ServicesThe item differed materially from its description, or arrived defective or damaged
Visa13.4 Counterfeit MerchandiseThe item was identified as counterfeit
Mastercard4853 Cardholder DisputeA broad code; a sub-condition names the specific complaint

Visa's Dispute Management Guidelines for Merchants treat 13.3 as a consumer dispute and set out how merchants can respond to it. Mastercard groups product complaints differently. Its 4853 code is a broad cardholder-dispute bucket, and Chargeflow's summary of Mastercard's codes notes it also covers counterfeit goods and unprocessed credits. Not-as-described or defective goods form one subcategory within 4853, so check which sub-condition the notice names before you gather evidence.

These disputes can arrive long after delivery. Cardholders typically have 120 days from the transaction date to file a 13.3. For counterfeit claims, the 120-day clock can instead start when the customer received the item or was told it was fake, up to 540 days after the transaction was processed. Keep the full order file, listing snapshots included, for at least that long.

Each claim type calls for different proof. Your listing answers a not-as-described claim. Defective claims turn on inspection notes and photos taken before shipping, with your warranty terms behind them. For counterfeit claims, you'll need supplier invoices and authentication documents. Fraud tools won't help with any of these. 3-D Secure authentication answers "I didn't make this purchase," and a product dispute starts from the opposite position.

Visa's Return Requirement for 13.3 Disputes

Since October 19, 2024, cardholders must return or attempt to return merchandise before filing a 13.3 dispute. If the item can't go back, Visa requires a valid reason, and it has to be documented. This is a Visa network rule, not a policy your processor chose. It works in your favor when the customer skipped you and went straight to the bank.

When that happens, say so plainly in your response. Visa's merchant guide advises telling the issuer that you never received the returned merchandise and that the cardholder never attempted a return. Attach your return policy along with proof it appeared before payment, such as a checkout screenshot or a logged checkbox acceptance.

The rule also covers what happens after a return. Once the item comes back, the issuer has to pause the dispute for 15 days after the return date so you have time to receive the goods and refund the customer. Use that window. If the item arrives and no refund goes out, the case usually turns into a different dispute, which we cover in credit not processed chargebacks and refund disputes.

Mastercard sets its own conditions for 4853 claims. Before you build a response around the customer's failure to return the item, confirm the current requirement with your processor.

Refusing the Return Counts Against You

Many merchants believe a posted final-sale or no-refund policy protects them. It does protect you against buyer's remorse. Against a not-as-described claim, it usually doesn't.

Under Visa's rules, refusing the return or withholding a return label counts as the customer's attempt to return. So does telling the customer not to send the item back. PayKings' review of the card rules adds that failing to give clear return instructions has the same effect, and that a disclosed no-refund policy isn't on Visa's list of reasons a 13.3 dispute is invalid. Refusing the return can also let the issuer file without waiting.

In practice, a final-sale dress listed as silk that arrives as polyester is a dispute you'll probably lose, and the email where you said "no returns on sale items" becomes the customer's evidence. When a buyer says an item doesn't match the listing, treat that as a description complaint, whatever your change-of-mind policy says. Issue a numbered return authorization (an RMA) with written instructions and a trackable shipping method. If the customer ignores it and calls the bank anyway, the unused RMA goes into your file.

The same discipline applies in person. Print the policy on receipts or post it at the register. On the receipt itself, note any item the customer inspected or bought "as is." State and local laws can also govern how refund policies must be displayed, so confirm the rules where you operate with a qualified professional.

Your Product Page Is Exhibit One

The issuer puts the customer's complaint next to what you published. Vague listings lose because the customer's description of the problem is more specific than yours. Save a dated PDF of each listing whenever you edit it, unless your platform keeps a version history.

What belongs on the page depends on what you sell:

  • Apparel: measure the actual garment instead of relying on a generic size chart, and copy fabric content exactly as the care label reads. Fit notes such as "runs small; size up if between sizes" head off complaints, and natural-light photos cut down on color disputes.
  • Furniture: list seat height and depth next to overall dimensions, along with the doorway clearance a delivery needs. Name the fabric or finish code and say whether the piece arrives assembled. Label any image that's a render.
  • Jewelry: state metal type and purity next to stone weight. Say whether the stone is natural or lab-grown and disclose any treatments. Give the grading report number where one exists, and add a photo on a hand or beside a ruler, since close-ups distort scale. Jewelry and diamond sellers should match each grading report to the specific piece shipped.
  • General e-commerce: publish model numbers and compatibility limits. Then spell out what's in the box and what isn't.

Generic disclaimers carry little weight. "Colors may vary by monitor" won't beat a customer who says a navy sofa arrived teal. A line like "reads blue-gray in daylight and closer to slate under warm bulbs; swatches available on request" gives the issuer something to weigh, especially when you can show the customer never asked for a swatch.

Custom and Opened Items Need Signed Specs

Custom work holds up when the customer approved the specs in writing. For a custom upholstered chair, keep the signed order showing the fabric code and dimensions. If the buyer approved a drawing, file that with it. Custom rings need the approved CAD render and the confirmed stone details. In both cases, save the approval email with its date and the customer's reply. Our guide to taking credit card deposits for custom orders shows how to structure approvals so they survive a dispute.

Pierced earrings and mattresses often can't be resold once opened, and sealed electronics lose value when the seal breaks. Put those limits on the listing itself, not only on a policy page linked from the footer.

Fight or Take It Back: The Break-Even Win Rate

Measure each outcome against never having made the sale. Taking the return costs you shipping both ways plus the processing fee, which usually isn't refunded (here's why you rarely get processing fees back on a refund). Winning keeps the sale price, but you still carry the merchandise cost and the chargeback fee on top of the outbound shipping and processing you paid at the start. Losing costs everything a win costs, and you give up the sale price too.

You pay outbound shipping and processing in every scenario, so they cancel out. What's left is the win rate you need before fighting beats taking the item back:

Break-even win rate = (merchandise cost + chargeback fee − return shipping) ÷ sale price

The formula assumes an accepted return comes back in resellable condition and that you don't recover the item after a lost dispute.

Illustrative example (assumed numbers, not real data): a boutique sells a dress for $180 that cost it $60. Its processing agreement charges a $25 chargeback fee, and a prepaid return label would cost $8. Chargeback fees are set by your processor, not by the networks, so check your own agreement. The break-even is ($60 + $25 − $8) ÷ $180 = $77 ÷ $180, or about 43%. Fighting pays only if you expect to win more than 43% of the time.

Two factors move that threshold in opposite directions. If you get the item back in sellable condition even after losing, the merchandise cost drops out and the break-even falls. If the customer asked to return the item and you refused, Visa treats that as their return attempt, so your odds are probably well below the threshold. Every dispute also counts toward the chargeback ratio your processor and the networks monitor, and every response takes staff time.

That gives you a working rule. When a customer asks to return a mid-priced item they say doesn't match the listing, take it back. Save your fights for customers who never contacted you, or for cases where your documentation clearly matches what shipped.

What Goes in the Response File

Your processor's deadline is the one that counts, and it can be shorter than the network's. Check the notice and start the day it arrives.

  1. A dated snapshot of the product page as it looked at the time of purchase.
  2. The order confirmation, showing the options selected and the checkout acceptance of your policy.
  3. Your return policy, with proof it appeared before payment.
  4. Every message with the customer, including any RMA they never used.
  5. Shipping and delivery records, plus photos of the item and its packaging taken before shipment.
  6. Inspection notes and warranty terms when the claim is a defect. Include any repair or replacement you offered.
  7. Supplier invoices and authentication certificates tied to the specific item when the claim is counterfeit.
  8. Signed specs and approved proofs for custom work, with the approval emails attached.
  9. A one-page cover letter that answers each point of the complaint and refers to each exhibit.

If the issuer rejects your first response, the case can go to a second round, which is explained in what pre-arbitration means for merchants. Shopify sellers should also follow the platform's own steps in how to respond to Shopify chargebacks.

Fix the Listings Behind Repeat Disputes

Pull your last few months of disputes and return requests and sort them by product. Complaints tend to cluster on a handful of listings, and fixing those pays off faster than rewriting the whole catalog. Replace supplier stock photos with photos of the item you actually ship. Add the measurement or spec that customers keep asking about. Photograph high-value orders before sealing the box, and for furniture deliveries, record the item's condition at the door and get a signature.

Then make your return request form easier to find than the dispute button in your customer's banking app. Apparel and home goods sellers will always see some product complaints, and every one that reaches you first is one that never reaches the issuer. If your dispute rate is climbing or your processor has flagged your account, request a free quote from MannyPay. A specialist will respond within one business day to review your setup.

Sources

  1. Visa Dispute Management Guidelines for Merchants
  2. Chargebacks911: Visa Reason Code 13.3
  3. Altopay: Visa Reason Code 13.3
  4. PayKings: No-Refund Policy Rules: What Visa and Mastercard Require
  5. Kount: Visa Reason Code 13.4 Counterfeit Merchandise
  6. Charge Alerts: Understanding Visa Not As Described Chargebacks
  7. Chargeflow: Mastercard Chargeback Reason Codes
  8. Altopay: Mastercard Reason Code 4853 Not as Described/Defective

About the author

Marcus Bennett

Marcus Bennett is Payments Risk & Compliance Analyst for Beyond the Swipe, covering high-risk processing, chargebacks, rolling reserves, frozen merchant accounts and fraud prevention.

This article is for general educational purposes and is not legal, tax or financial advice. Card network rules and state laws change; confirm current requirements for your business.

Related reading