Debt Settlement Dedicated Accounts: How and When Fees Get Paid Out
How a debt settlement dedicated account works under the TSR: who owns the funds, when your fee can be paid, and the seven-business-day refund rule.

Photo: Pixabay
On this page 7 sections
Key takeaways
- An offer letter or a client's verbal yes doesn't earn a fee. The client's first payment to that creditor has to clear before your fee leaves the account.
- Pick the proportional or percentage-of-savings formula before enrollment. Under either one, a client who cancels gets back everything except fees you have already earned on settled debts.
- Treat the seven business days as a firm deadline. A refund held up by your own fee dispute is still late.
- The 2024 TSR amendments raised record retention from two years to five, so keep fee and refund files at least that long.
A debt settlement dedicated account is a bank account that your client owns. It is held at an insured financial institution and run by an administrator that has no ownership or affiliate ties to your company. Your fee for a debt can come out of the account only after two things happen: the debt is settled under an agreement the client signed, and the client has made at least one payment under that agreement. If the client quits, they get back everything in the account except fees you have already earned, within seven business days.
Those conditions come from the Federal Trade Commission's Telemarketing Sales Rule (TSR) at 16 CFR 310.4(a)(5). Paragraph (a)(5)(i) bars sellers and telemarketers of debt relief services from asking for or collecting any fee before they deliver results. Paragraph (a)(5)(ii) makes one exception. You may require clients to set aside money for your fee and for creditor payments in a dedicated account, as long as five conditions hold. If any condition fails, the money set aside for your fee is an advance fee the rule bans, no matter what your contracts call the account. The ban and the account conditions took effect on October 27, 2010, according to the FTC's announcement.
The Rule Covers Inbound Calls From Your Ads
Many operators assume the TSR applies only to outbound cold calls. The rule normally exempts calls that consumers make in response to general media advertising. The FTC's 2010 final rule removed that exemption for debt relief, and it also left debt relief out of the direct mail exemption. A Venable analysis of the final rule says the advance fee ban reaches almost every debt relief provider that sells by inbound or outbound phone calls, including calls from lead generators and online advertising. In practice, the full rule covers a client who calls after seeing your TV spot, search ad or mailer.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Read the rule text and the FTC's debt relief guide for business. Then have a lawyer who knows FTC and state debt relief law confirm your setup.
How a Debt Settlement Dedicated Account Works
In a typical program, the client enrolls unsecured debts and stops paying those creditors. Each month they deposit an amount sized to their budget, and the balance grows while your negotiators work the debts one at a time. When a creditor agrees to terms and the client signs, the account pays the settlement as a lump sum or in installments.
The money belongs to the client from the first deposit. The account can hold funds for your fees, but you only earn a claim on them as each debt settles. Treat the account as the client's savings, not as a reserve for revenue you expect later. The FTC's guide says the administrator may charge the client a reasonable fee. The administrator may not send any client funds to you, directly or indirectly, until you have settled or changed the terms of at least one debt and met the rule's other requirements.
Many operators still call it a debt settlement escrow account. The name doesn't matter, but the structure does. A trust account titled to your company fails the independence condition, and so does an account run by an administrator you own or are affiliated with. The paperwork's label doesn't change that.
The Five Dedicated Account Conditions
Section 310.4(a)(5)(ii) lists five conditions, and the exception applies only if all five hold. Get each one confirmed in writing before you sign with a provider.
- Insured institution. The funds must be held at an insured financial institution. Check the institution's deposit insurance yourself instead of taking the provider's word for it.
- Client ownership. The client owns the funds and receives any interest the account earns. The FTC's guide adds that the client controls the funds and can withdraw them at any time, so clients should be able to see their balance without asking you.
- Independent administrator. Your company cannot own or control the administrator or be affiliated with it in any way. If the same people own part of both businesses, you fail this test.
- No referral money. The administrator may not pay or accept money for referrals of business involving your company. A revenue-share side letter or a "marketing fee" can break the exception by itself.
- Penalty-free exit. The client can leave your service at any time without penalty. Within seven business days of asking, they must receive everything in the account except fees you earned under the rule.
The disclosure section, 16 CFR 310.3, adds a related duty. Before a client enrolls, if you ask them to fund an account, you must tell them three things: they own the funds, they can leave your service at any time without penalty, and if they leave they get back everything except fees earned in compliance with the rule. The disclosure requirement doesn't mention the seven-business-day deadline, which appears in 310.4. Including it anyway gives clients and staff a clear target.
The TSR is federal law. Many states also license debt settlement firms, cap their fees or add account rules of their own, so a setup that passes the TSR can still fail in some states. Our piece on how state regulators are filling the gap as the CFPB pulls back explains why that state exposure keeps growing.
When Your Fee Can Leave the Account
Section 310.4(a)(5)(i) sets two triggers for every fee. First, you must have renegotiated, settled, reduced or otherwise changed the terms of at least one debt under an agreement the client signed. Second, the client must have made at least one payment to that creditor or debt collector under that agreement.
The second trigger is the one operators misread most often. A creditor's offer letter doesn't earn you a fee, and neither does a client's verbal yes. The client's first settlement payment has to go out before your fee does.
When debts settle one at a time, the fee also has to follow one of two formulas. Under the proportional method, the fee for each settled debt is the same share of your total fee as that debt is of the total enrolled debt, with both measured at enrollment. Under the percentage-of-savings method, you charge a percentage of the amount saved. The rule defines savings as the amount owed at enrollment minus the amount actually paid to settle the debt. Your percentage has to stay the same for every debt.
Worked Example: One Client, Two Formulas
All figures here are illustrative. They are not typical or recommended fees, and state law may cap fees below these amounts.
Assume a client enrolls four debts totaling $20,000, and the program agreement sets a total fee of $4,000 under the proportional method.
| Debt | Balance at Enrollment | Share of Enrolled Debt | Fee Earned When Settled |
|---|---|---|---|
| Card A | $8,000 | 40% | $1,600 |
| Card B | $6,000 | 30% | $1,200 |
| Store card | $4,000 | 20% | $800 |
| Medical bill | $2,000 | 10% | $400 |
| Total | $20,000 | 100% | $4,000 |
Card B settles first, for $3,000. Once the client's first payment to Card B leaves the dedicated account, you can be paid $1,200. Taking more than $1,200 on that first settlement would pay you ahead of the results you've delivered, and the proportional method forbids that.
Now put the same client on an illustrative fee of 25% of savings. The client saves $3,000 on Card B ($6,000 minus $3,000), so your fee on Card B is $750. You must then charge the same 25% on every other debt in the program.
Your fee formula is a decision you make when you write the contract. A proportional fee is fixed by the enrollment balances, so Card B earns you $1,200 whether it settles for $3,000 or $5,000. A savings fee moves with results, so a weak $5,000 settlement earns only $250. Because the savings method doesn't allow different percentages for different debts, choose your formula before enrollment and apply it the same way to every debt.
Refunds and the Seven-Business-Day Clock
A client can leave at any point, so your records need to show exactly which fees you have earned. Continuing the example, say the client cancels with $2,900 in the account. You have earned the Card B fee but haven't been paid it yet, and no administrator fees or settlement installments are pending. Under the proportional contract, you receive $1,200 and the client gets $1,700. Under the 25% savings contract, you receive $750 and the client gets $2,150. Either way, the refund is due within seven business days of the request. You earn nothing on the three debts that never settled.
Cancellations usually go wrong in one of two ways. In the first, a monthly draft still runs after the client has quit, and their bank may treat it as unauthorized. Our guide to Nacha rules and ACH return rates for credit repair fees covers that kind of return. In the second, you and the client still disagree about the fee calculation when the deadline arrives. To avoid both, date-stamp each withdrawal request, notify the administrator that day, stop scheduled drafts immediately and settle fee questions within the seven-day window. A refund delayed by your own internal dispute is still a late refund.
Records to Keep Ready for Your Bank and Processor
Underwriters treat debt settlement as high risk, and the TSR gives them reason to look closely. Under 16 CFR 310.3(b), someone who gives substantial assistance to a seller also violates the rule if they know the seller is breaking the TSR, or if they deliberately avoid knowing it. Our coverage of the FTC's knowledge standard for payment processors explains why processors now ask for more proof.
The FTC's 2024 TSR amendments raised the retention period for records covered by 16 CFR 310.5 from two years to five. The amendments took effect May 16, 2024, but compliance with the expanded recordkeeping provision in 310.5(a)(2) wasn't required until October 15, 2024. The National Consumer Law Center's summary also gives October 15, 2024 as the effective date for the expanded records and the five-year retention period. Keeping your fee and refund files for at least five years is a sensible default. Keep this file ready to hand over the same day it's requested:
- Each client's account agreement naming the client as owner and identifying the insured institution, plus the pre-enrollment disclosures the client received
- A signed statement from the provider covering ownership, affiliations and referral payments
- Each client's debt balances at enrollment and, for every settled debt, the signed agreement, proof the first payment cleared and your fee calculation
- A withdrawal log showing the request date, the notice to the administrator, the refund amount and the refund date
What to Audit This Week
Pull five recent fee disbursements and five recent cancellations. Check each disbursement against its signed settlement agreement, the cleared first payment and the fee formula in the client's contract. For each cancellation, count the business days from request to refund. Any gap you find now is one a regulator or underwriter would find later.
If you're setting up or moving processing for a debt relief business, start with our overview of high-risk merchant accounts, then request a free processing quote. A MannyPay specialist responds within one business day, and approval depends on underwriting.
Sources
- eCFR, 16 CFR Part 310: Telemarketing Sales Rule
- FTC, Debt Relief Services & the Telemarketing Sales Rule: A Guide for Business
- FTC press release, Debt Relief Companies Prohibited From Collecting Advance Fees Under FTC Rule That Takes Effect October 27, 2010
- Federal Register, Telemarketing Sales Rule final rule (August 10, 2010)
- Venable, FTC Issues Final Rules for Debt Relief Services
- Federal Register, Telemarketing Sales Rule amendments (April 16, 2024)
- National Consumer Law Center, Nine New or Revised FTC Rules Released in 2024
This article is for general educational purposes and is not legal, tax or financial advice. Card network rules and state laws change; confirm current requirements for your business.


