Extend vs. Mulberry vs. Clyde: What Your Store Keeps on Each Plan
Extend vs. Mulberry, plus Clyde under Cover Genius: compare revenue share, chargeback exposure, refunds and payout timing in net dollars before you sign.

Photo: Pixabay
On this page 8 sections
- Extend vs. Mulberry on the Points Each Publishes
- Clyde Now Runs Through Cover Genius
- Who Charges the Card Decides Who Gets the Chargeback
- Compare Protection Plan Offers in Net Dollars
- Returns and Cancellations Leave Money Outstanding
- Book the Provider's Share as a Payable
- When Selling Your Own Service Contracts Makes Sense
- Questions to Get in Writing Before You Sign
Key takeaways
- Before you compare a checkout-model revenue share with a provider-charged commission, subtract your effective processing rate from the share.
- When plans run through your own checkout, chargebacks from denied claims count toward your dispute ratio, not the provider's.
- Clyde's assets have belonged to Cover Genius since March 2023, so confirm which company signs your agreement and services plans sold under the Clyde name.
On paper, Extend vs. Mulberry is close to a tie. Both cost nothing to start. Both pay your store a share of every protection plan it sells. Neither publishes that share in the materials we reviewed, because it's set in your merchant agreement. What changes your net is how each deal works: whose checkout charges the customer for the plan, when your cut reaches you, and who takes the chargeback when a customer's claim is denied. Clyde, the third provider in this comparison, sold its assets to Cover Genius in March 2023. If you're talking to Clyde today, you're really talking to Cover Genius.
Extend vs. Mulberry on the Points Each Publishes
Extend says it charges no startup fees and runs on a revenue share model, with a cut of every plan sold on your Shopify store going to you. Mulberry's developer documentation describes a similar setup: you earn a commission on every plan sold, and Mulberry handles the contracts, claims and service behind each one. Here is what each provider says publicly.
| Extend | Mulberry | |
|---|---|---|
| Cost to start | No startup fees | Free to install on Shopify; the listing says Mulberry may bill some charges separately from your Shopify invoice |
| How you earn | Revenue share per plan | Commission per plan |
| Where plans are offered | Online checkout, in store, by email, by phone and in your mobile app | Product pages, checkout, after the purchase and in store |
| Claims | Filed through Extend's chatbot, Extend support or your own support team; resolved by repair or a replacement from the original merchant | Handled by Mulberry through a claims portal |
| Shopify details | Post-Purchase Solutions app reads your orders, products and customer data; a widget adds plans to draft orders | Works with Shopify Checkout, Shopify POS and Shopify Admin, plus email and SMS tools such as Klaviyo and Attentive |
Sources: Extend's vendor profile on G2, Shopify setup guide and draft orders guide; Mulberry's Shopify App Store listing and docs.
Two rows need a follow-up question. Mulberry's listing mentions separate charges, so ask Mulberry to put in writing what, if anything, it could bill you. Extend resolves some approved claims with a replacement from the original merchant, which may mean a replacement order from your own store. Ask what price that order is placed at. Depending on the answer, it's either extra revenue or a hit to your margin.
The draft-order widget matters if your team sells by phone. Once staff type in card numbers during calls, more of your business falls under PCI DSS requirements. Our guide to taking warranty payments by phone safely covers the controls that keep that work manageable.
Clyde Now Runs Through Cover Genius
Cover Genius makes the XCover protection product. On March 14, 2023, it announced that it had completed an asset acquisition of Clyde Technologies, a U.S. provider of protection plans that run inside a store's checkout. The stated goal was to reach more medium-sized online merchants. At the time, the company said it expected no impact on servicing and sales for Clyde's merchant partners.
If you're evaluating Clyde now, check the paperwork. Confirm which company signs your agreement, who the obligor and claims administrator are, and who services plans that customers bought under the Clyde name. If you signed with Clyde before Cover Genius acquired its assets in March 2023, pull your agreement and read the assignment clause. It controls whether and how your contract moved to the buyer.
Who Charges the Card Decides Who Gets the Chargeback
Several parties stand behind every plan on a receipt. The obligor is the company legally bound to honor the contract. In many states, a reimbursement insurance policy backs the obligor's promises. A claims administrator decides claims and arranges repairs or replacements. Your store sells the plan and, depending on the setup, may also collect the money.
That last part varies, and it's the biggest difference in risk between offers. In the first setup, the plan is a line in your normal checkout. Your merchant account charges the customer the full plan price, and you later pay the provider everything except your share. In the second, the provider sells the plan after the purchase through its own emails and pages. It may charge the customer directly and pay you a commission. Extend and Mulberry both advertise post-purchase offers, so one provider can run both setups on your store. Ask which one applies to each sales channel you turn on.
The merchant of record is the business whose merchant account submits the charge. Its name appears on the cardholder's statement, and the card networks hold it responsible. In the checkout setup, that's you. Say a customer's claim is denied and they dispute the plan charge with their bank. The chargeback lands on your account and counts toward your dispute ratio with your processor, but the evidence you need sits with the claims administrator. Our guide to extended warranty chargebacks from denied claims covers the evidence that tends to win those cases. Before you sign, get answers to these:
- How fast can the provider send claim records and plan terms while your dispute deadline is running?
- Does the provider reimburse plan chargebacks you lose, and under what conditions?
- Does the plan confirmation show the provider's claims contact, so customers call the provider before their bank?
- If you forward a dispute, who writes the response?
Compare Protection Plan Offers in Net Dollars
A revenue share and a commission can't be compared directly. When the plan runs through your checkout, you pay card fees on the whole plan price. When the provider charges the card, you don't. Here's how to compare the two fairly.
Illustrative example. None of these numbers are any provider's terms. A customer buys a TV and adds a $60 protection plan in the same order. Offer A runs through your checkout and lets you keep 30% of the plan price. Under Offer B, the provider charges the customer's card after the purchase and pays you a 27% commission. Your effective processing rate is 2.9%. Because the plan and the TV go through as one card charge, the plan adds no extra per-transaction fee.
Under Offer A, you keep $18 and owe the provider $42. Your processor charges 2.9% on the full $60, or $1.74, so you net $16.26. That $1.74 equals about 9.7% of your $18, because you paid card fees on $42 that was never yours. Under Offer B, you receive $16.20 and pay no card fees on the plan.
The shortcut: subtract your effective rate from a checkout-model share before comparing it with a commission from a provider that charges the card itself. In this example, 30% minus 2.9% is 27.1%, so Offer A beats Offer B by six cents a plan. Offer B, though, keeps plan disputes off your account and leaves you owing the provider nothing. For many stores, that's worth more than six cents.
To find your effective rate, take a recent processing statement and divide your total fees by your total card volume. If fees make up a large part of the gap, a compliant program such as zero cost processing can change the math. Confirm how it treats plan line items before you count on it. Our guide to whether warranty companies can charge convenience fees or surcharges covers when passing card costs to customers works.
Returns and Cancellations Leave Money Outstanding
Go back to the illustrative sale. Three weeks later, the customer returns the TV, the plan is canceled with it, and you refund the whole order to the card. Whether your processor returns the percentage fee on the original sale depends on your agreement. If it doesn't, you lose the $1.74 along with the fee on the TV. The provider owes you a $42 credit, which usually arrives on its schedule, often as a line on the next invoice. Your customer has their money back today. You wait for yours.
Customers who cancel only the plan create a second problem. Many state service contract laws give buyers a period to cancel for a full refund, then a prorated refund after that, sometimes minus a fee. The details differ by state. Our article on service contract free-look periods and refund timing shows how those rules lead to disputes. Ask each provider who calculates the refund and who issues it. Also ask whether the provider takes back your whole share or only a prorated part.
Book the Provider's Share as a Payable
In the checkout setup, timing starts in your favor. The full plan price settles with the order on your normal funding schedule, and you pay the provider later. That money you're holding is a debt, and your books should show it as one. Record the provider's portion as a payable, and ask your accountant whether any part of the full plan price counts as revenue under your agreement. Each month, match every plan line item to the provider's invoice. Mismatches usually come from orders that were edited or partly refunded before shipping.
Your processor's 1099-K will report plan sales at the full amount, since they're part of your card volume. Our piece on why 1099-K gross sales look too high explains the same problem when money passes through your account on its way to someone else. When the provider charges the card, you don't hold its money and don't owe it a payable. Instead, ask how often commissions pay, what each statement shows, and whether you lose the commission when a plan is canceled.
When Selling Your Own Service Contracts Makes Sense
Some larger sellers skip the platforms to keep the full margin. That means becoming the service contract provider yourself or hiring a licensed obligor and claims administrator. Many states require providers to register and show financial backing, often a reimbursement insurance policy, and processors will ask for proof. See our guide to the service contract provider licenses processors want. If you plan to market auto warranties with purchased leads, read our guide to the compliance risks of buying auto warranty leads. This is general information, so confirm your state's rules with a qualified attorney.
Your payment setup changes too. Processors often underwrite a store that sells its own contracts as a warranty merchant, and many treat that category as high risk. Expect close review of your refund terms and dispute history. You may also face a reserve, meaning the processor holds back part of your sales to cover future chargebacks. Our articles on why extended warranty merchant accounts get declined and extended warranty fees, reserves and holds cover both. If you bill your own plans in installments, see our guide to handling missed warranty payments, grace periods and reinstatement.
Running your own program pays off only when three things are true. You sell enough plans to cover administration and insurance costs. Your products fail at rates you can predict well enough to price. And your claims handling keeps denials from turning into chargebacks. If any of those is uncertain, a platform's smaller share costs less than the risk you'd take on.
Questions to Get in Writing Before You Sign
| Question | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| What share or commission do I get, and is it fixed or tiered? | Sets your net per plan |
| Who charges the card in each channel? | Decides who gets disputes and who pays card fees |
| Do you reimburse plan chargebacks I lose? | Decides whether dispute losses stay on your books |
| How fast do you credit canceled or returned plans? | Sets how long refunded money is out of your pocket |
| What is the billing or payout cycle, and what can you bill me for? | Drives reconciliation and cash flow |
| At what price do you buy replacement products from my store? | Makes approved claims either revenue or a margin hit |
Send this list to Extend, Mulberry and Cover Genius. Put every answer through the net-dollar shortcut above before you compare. If you later decide to sell service contracts under your own name, that will mean a new underwriting review. MannyPay offers high-risk merchant accounts, and a MannyPay specialist responds to free quote requests within one business day.
Sources
- Looking to Grow Your Shopify Store? Modern Product Protection Can Help (Extend)
- Extend Reviews 2026: Details, Pricing, & Features (G2 vendor profile)
- Getting Started with Extend with Shopify (Extend docs)
- Selling Warranties Using Shopify Draft Orders (Extend docs)
- Introduction to Mulberry (Mulberry docs)
- Mulberry Product Protection (Shopify App Store)
- Cover Genius Acquires Clyde, Deepening Footprint in $121B Global Warranty Industry (Cover Genius press release, March 14, 2023)
This article is for general educational purposes and is not legal, tax or financial advice. Card network rules and state laws change; confirm current requirements for your business.


