GunBroker Payment Processing: Fees and Card Costs
Industry Payment Guides

GunBroker Payment Processing: Who Runs the Card and What You Pay

How GunBroker payment processing works for FFL sellers: why card sales run through your own merchant account, what GunBroker charges, and true cost per sale.

Open cardboard shipping box stuffed with crumpled brown kraft packing paper on a light wood floor

Photo: Pixabay

On this page 8 sections
  1. GunBroker Payment Processing Runs Through Your Merchant Account
  2. What GunBroker Charges Sellers on Top of Card Fees
  3. The True Cost of One GunBroker Sale, Worked Out
  4. Surcharging on GunBroker: The Debit Card Rule Sellers Miss
  5. Money Orders and Cashier's Checks Trade Speed for Safety
  6. Getting Paid and Keeping Clean Books
  7. Non-Paying Bidders and Chargebacks Are Yours to Handle
  8. When Selling on Your Own Site Beats GunBroker

Key takeaways

  • GunBroker doesn't process card payments. Card sales go through your own merchant account and a gateway GunBroker supports, so your processor's rates, deposit timing and chargeback rules apply.
  • Because the money moves through your account, you pay card fees on the sales tax too, even though GunBroker later collects that tax from you.
  • Under GunBroker's policy you can't surcharge debit cards. Describing your checkout as "credit cards only" doesn't count as blocking them.
  • Your card cost is the same whether you sell on GunBroker or on your own site. So the real comparison is GunBroker's fees against what it costs you to bring in a buyer yourself.

GunBroker doesn't process card payments for sellers. When a buyer pays by card, the charge runs through your own merchant account. On GunBroker's Immediate Checkout, that happens through a gateway you connect. Buyers can also pay you directly by any other method you accept. GunBroker charges its own seller fees separately. That makes GunBroker payment processing two separate bills: the marketplace's fees and your processor's fees. You negotiate one of them, and you handle every refund and chargeback yourself.

GunBroker Payment Processing Runs Through Your Merchant Account

GunBroker's accepted payment methods page for sellers is direct about this. To take cards, you need a merchant account and an established relationship with a payment processor, and you're responsible for collecting payment from the buyer. The buyer-side help page says the same thing in reverse: buyers don't pay GunBroker for items. Even when a buyer pays through GunBroker Checkout, the transaction is processed by the seller's payment provider.

Listings come in two kinds:

  • Immediate Checkout lets the buyer pay by card as soon as the listing ends. This requires a merchant account tied to a gateway GunBroker supports. Its supported gateways page lists Authorize.net, Elavon, Fluid Pay, Fortis and NMI as preferred, plus several others. Money goes to your bank account through your gateway. If the buyer has a payment question or needs a refund, they contact you.
  • Standard Checkout means the buyer reviews your accepted methods and payment instructions, then pays you by one of them. GunBroker's seller guide says the buyer must complete payment within five days of the listing closing.

GunBroker's help center also says that when a card fails at checkout, support can't see why. GunBroker has no access to your processor and can't resubmit the charge, so declines are between you, the buyer and your processor. Some third-party guides describe a built-in GunBroker payment service. Go by what your own seller account and GunBroker's current help pages say.

Your processor also has to be willing to underwrite firearms. Many mainstream providers won't, which is why so many gun stores get declined for merchant accounts.

What GunBroker Charges Sellers on Top of Card Fees

A basic listing is free. When an item sells, GunBroker charges a final value fee based on the price it sold for. Here is the current schedule from its seller guide:

CategoryFinal value fee
Guns, gun parts, optics, ammunition, reloading, NFA items, collectible firearms, militaria6% up to $400; 4% on the portion from $400 to $15,000; 3% from $15,000 to $20,000; 2% over $20,000
All other categories8% up to $15,000; 3% from $15,000 to $20,000; 2% over $20,000

Other charges stack on top:

  • FFL Transfer Processing Fee. The same guide lists $5.00 per transfer for FFL sellers and $7.00 for non-FFL sellers. You need your license number registered on your account to be billed at the FFL rate.
  • Optional services such as featured placement. These are charged upfront and aren't refunded, whether or not the item sells.
  • Top Seller discounts. GunBroker says eligible Top Sellers may qualify for discounted final value fees.

Buyers pay their own fee. GunBroker's fee page describes a 1% Compliance Fee charged to buyers when they purchase. That doesn't show up on your fee lines, but it does raise what the buyer pays compared with buying from your own site.

GunBroker collects what you owe through the payment methods on file, and a bank account must be one of them. Charges add up over the month and appear on your monthly statement. Sales tax works the same way. In states with marketplace facilitator laws, GunBroker calculates the tax and sends it to the state, but it collects that amount from the seller through the seller's account. The buyer pays you the tax with the item, and GunBroker then takes it back from you.

The True Cost of One GunBroker Sale, Worked Out

Here are two illustrative sales. The GunBroker fees come from the schedule above. Everything else is an assumption: card processing at 3% + $0.30, $40 shipping that exactly covers your label, a 7% sales tax on the item price only, and the $5 FFL Transfer Processing Fee applying to both sales.

Used handgunNew rifle
Sale price$800$1,500
Your margin before selling costs$120$300
Buyer pays (item + shipping + tax)$896.00$1,645.00
Final value fee$40.00$68.00
FFL Transfer Processing Fee$5.00$5.00
Card processing on the full amount$27.18$49.65
Total selling cost$72.18$122.65
Margin left$47.82$177.35
Share of margin consumed60%41%

Two things stand out. First, low-ticket used guns take the hardest hit, because the 6% tier and the flat fees weigh more on a small margin. Second, you're paying card fees on money that isn't yours. The buyer's tax runs through your merchant account before GunBroker collects it, so in this example you paid $1.68 to process the handgun's $56 in tax and $3.15 on the rifle's.

Your processing rate is the one number in this stack you can negotiate. Learn how to find yours on a statement in our guide to what a fair processing rate looks like for a gun store.

Surcharging on GunBroker: The Debit Card Rule Sellers Miss

GunBroker's seller payment policy says any credit card surcharge has to meet legal and card network limits, along with notice, price and receipt disclosure requirements. It also clears up two common mistakes. A debit card is still a debit card when the buyer runs it as credit, skips the PIN or agrees to a disclosed fee, and none of those makes a debit surcharge allowed.

Writing "credit cards only" in your listing also doesn't replace actually blocking debit cards. Calling the charge a "processing," "handling" or "convenience" fee doesn't get around the policy either, and GunBroker may ask for proof of compliance and restrict checkout access if you don't comply. Before you add anything, confirm current network rules and your state's law with your processor or counsel.

If surcharging is allowed for a sale, work out how many buyers you can afford to lose. Keep the illustrative numbers above and assume a 3% surcharge applies to the buyer's full payment. On the handgun, the surcharge adds $26.88 and your card fee rises $0.81, so net per sale goes from $47.82 to $73.89. You'd come out behind only if more than about 35% of buyers walked away.

On the rifle, net goes from $177.35 to $225.22, so the break-even drops to about 21%. Debit buyers can't be surcharged, so your real gain is smaller than either figure. On a marketplace where buyers sort identical guns by price, a surcharge makes most sense on thin-margin used guns and is riskier on high-margin new ones.

For your own counter and website, MannyPay offers surcharging where permitted and dual pricing.

Money Orders and Cashier's Checks Trade Speed for Safety

Paper has no processing fee and no chargeback right, but it's slow. Some bidders won't wait for the mail, so a listing that takes only money orders gives them up. Counterfeit cashier's checks are a known scam. Your bank may make deposited funds available before it has actually collected them from the issuing bank. If the check later bounces, the deposit is reversed after the gun has already shipped. Ask your bank to confirm the funds are collected, not just available, before you ship.

Getting Paid and Keeping Clean Books

Card payments land on your processor's deposit schedule, not GunBroker's. GunBroker's fees and the sales tax come out of your bank account through its billing. Record each sale at the gross amount the buyer paid. Then book the tax as a liability cleared by GunBroker's collection, and book the final value fee, FFL Transfer Processing Fee and card fee as separate expenses. Match each processor deposit to GunBroker item numbers, so a monthly statement can be tied back to individual sales.

Since the card money moves through your merchant account, any Form 1099-K for those sales would generally come from your processor, and it reports gross amounts. Your fee detail explains the gap between that figure and your profit. This is general information, not tax advice, so confirm reporting with your accountant. Disposition records follow their own federal rules, and a gun store POS that ties the bound book and serial numbers to the sale keeps payment and paperwork on one transaction.

Non-Paying Bidders and Chargebacks Are Yours to Handle

When a winning bidder never pays, you can file a Non-Paying Bidder report. The buyer can dispute it while the report is active, which is typically three days. Then request a credit for the final value fee plus the cost to relist with the same optional services. GunBroker's fee page says credit requests must be made within 45 days of the listing's close. Putting a clear payment deadline in your terms makes the report easier to support.

Chargebacks go through your processor, because it was your processor that ran the card. Ship only after the card payment has settled, not just been authorized. Ship to the buyer's FFL, never to the buyer's home, as Flxpoint's GunBroker selling guide describes the marketplace flow. Verify the receiving dealer's license, use tracking with signature confirmation, and keep proof of delivery to the FFL. Federal and state law and carrier policy all apply to interstate shipments, so confirm the specifics with ATF guidance or counsel. If the buyer is denied at pickup, follow our guide to refunding a NICS-denied buyer the right way.

When Selling on Your Own Site Beats GunBroker

Your card cost is the same in both channels, because GunBroker uses your merchant account. That makes the decision simpler than it looks. Compare GunBroker's fees for an item with what it would cost you to bring that same buyer to your own checkout. In the illustrative example, GunBroker charged $45 to sell the handgun and $73 to sell the rifle, before the buyer's own fee.

If advertising and site costs to win that buyer run higher than that, GunBroker is cheaper. GunBroker's reach and bidding usually win for one-off used guns, collectibles and consignments, where finding the price is part of the job. Your own site usually wins for new inventory and repeat customers. There you also control pricing and can offer a cash discount program. Our guide to selling guns online with an FFL-ready checkout covers that build.

Before your next listing, pull last quarter's GunBroker statements and your processor statements and work out the full cost of each sale. If your card rate turns out to be the biggest number you can change, MannyPay works with firearms dealers and FFLs through high-risk merchant accounts and supports the Authorize.net gateway and the NMI gateway, both on GunBroker's preferred list. Request a free processing quote and a specialist will respond within one business day.

Sources

  1. GunBroker Support: Sellers – Accepted Payment Method Options
  2. GunBroker Support: Immediate Checkout – Supported Payment Gateways
  3. GunBroker Support: Paying for the Item You Purchased or Won
  4. GunBroker Support: Payment Failed During Checkout
  5. GunBroker Support: How to Sell on GunBroker.com: A Complete Guide for Sellers
  6. GunBroker Support: Fees for Using GunBroker.com
  7. GunBroker: Fees for Using GunBroker.com (fee page describing the buyer Compliance Fee)
  8. GunBroker Support: Bank Account and Payment Method Requirements for Selling
  9. GunBroker Support: Sales Tax for Sellers
  10. GunBroker Support: Disputing a Non-Paying Bidder Report
  11. Flxpoint: How to Sell on GunBroker (FFL shipping step)

About the author

Marcus Bennett

Marcus Bennett is Payments Risk & Compliance Analyst for Beyond the Swipe, covering high-risk processing, chargebacks, rolling reserves, frozen merchant accounts and fraud prevention.

This article is for general educational purposes and is not legal, tax or financial advice. Card network rules and state laws change; confirm current requirements for your business.

Related reading