Paying Client Taxes on Their Behalf: Risks for CPAs
Industry Payment Guides

Paying Clients' Taxes on Their Behalf: Risks for CPA Firms

Paying client taxes on their behalf can leave a CPA firm with commingled funds and chargeback losses. See safer ways to offer the same service.

Black calculator with red buttons resting on a printed financial report showing a pie chart with percentages

Photo: Pixabay

On this page 7 sections
  1. Why Clients Ask Their CPA to Just Pay the IRS
  2. Paying Client Taxes on Their Behalf: A Worked Example
  3. Client Funds at an Accounting Firm: The Commingling Problem
  4. Money Transmission Risk When an Accountant Holds Client Money
  5. Safer Paths: Client-Initiated Payments to the IRS and States
  6. Scheduling Payments Without Touching the Money
  7. Engagement Letter Language on Tax Payment Responsibility

Key takeaways

  • A client's tax payment run through your merchant account counts as your card sales and may break the terms your account was approved under.
  • If the client charges back after you've remitted, the government keeps the money and your firm absorbs the full loss plus the chargeback fee.
  • You can still offer full service by scheduling payments from the client's own account and billing that setup work as a separate line item.
  • Before the next estimate deadline, add a sentence to your engagement letter saying the firm does not accept or remit tax payments.

Paying client taxes on their behalf exposes a CPA firm to more risk than most partners expect. It usually goes like this: the firm charges the client's card through its own merchant account, then pays the IRS from the firm's bank account. That one favor puts client money in your operating account and runs a transaction your merchant agreement probably doesn't allow. It can also raise money transmission questions. If the client disputes the charge after the IRS has the money, the firm eats the loss.

You can give clients the same convenience without that exposure. Schedule the payment so it moves straight from the client's own account to the taxing authority, and bill your time for setting it up.

Why Clients Ask Their CPA to Just Pay the IRS

These requests usually come a few days before a deadline. A client has an estimate due while they're traveling, and they already trust you with their numbers. Some want card rewards on a large charge. Others want a few more weeks of float before the money leaves checking. Business owners sometimes ask the firm to take over payroll tax deposits entirely.

Saying yes feels like good service and costs nothing that day. The costs show up later, usually after the deadline has passed and nobody remembers agreeing to it.

Paying Client Taxes on Their Behalf: A Worked Example

This scenario is illustrative. It uses no real client and no real rates, so plug in your own numbers. Here are the assumptions:

  • A client owes a five-figure federal estimated payment.
  • Your firm charges the client's credit card for the full amount through the merchant account you use for your own invoices.
  • Your effective processing rate is whatever your last statement shows: total fees divided by total card volume.
  • That tax payment is many times larger than your typical invoice.

Two formulas tell most of the story. Your cost on the day of the charge is the tax payment multiplied by your effective rate. Your exposure if the charge is disputed is the entire tax payment plus your processor's chargeback fee.

  • Processing cost. On a five-figure payment, even a low processing rate produces a fee in the hundreds of dollars. The IRS still needs the full amount, so the firm covers the gap unless it bills the client for it. Adding a fee to a pass-through payment brings up surcharge and disclosure questions of its own.
  • Your books. The charge counts toward your firm's card sales, which your processor reports to the IRS. Someone will have to explain why money that was never revenue shows up as sales.
  • Processor risk review. A single ticket far above your normal invoice size breaks your usual pattern, and processors flag that kind of spike. A hold in the middle of tax season is the worst time to have one. Our guide to keeping your processor from holding funds during tax season volume spikes explains how those reviews start.
  • Dispute exposure. Weeks later, the client disputes the charge. Maybe they don't recognize the descriptor, or maybe the relationship went bad. Either way, the card issuer pulls the money back from your account. Because the IRS has already credited the client's tax account, it has no reason to send anything to you. Your firm is out the full payment plus the chargeback fee.

Your merchant agreement is a separate problem. The account was approved for selling your services under a specific merchant category code, as our explainer on how professional service MCCs set your fees describes. Merchant agreements commonly prohibit submitting transactions for anyone else's goods or services, and a charge that pays a client's tax bill fits that description. A processor may treat it as processing for a third party, which can lead to a hold or a terminated account. Read your agreement and ask your processor before you assume it's allowed.

Client Funds at an Accounting Firm: The Commingling Problem

Most accounting firms aren't set up to hold client money, even overnight. Professional conduct rules and your state board of accountancy may say how a CPA must handle client funds, so check what applies in your state before you take custody of anything.

Even where those rules are light, there's a practical problem. Once a client's tax payment lands in your operating account, it sits alongside payroll and rent. Paying it out the same afternoon doesn't fully fix that. A levy or an overdraft on the firm's account can reach dollars that belong to the client, and your records would then have to prove which dollars were the client's and when they left.

Businesses that hold client money as a routine part of their work build separate structures for it. Law firms keep trust accounts. Insurance agencies keep premium trust accounts with their own reconciliation routines, as our article on how insurance agencies keep premium trust accounts whole when taking cards shows. That is a lot of overhead to take on for a convenience favor.

A dedicated client funds account is possible. It comes with recordkeeping and reconciliation work you would own every month, and your state board may have its own requirements. Confirm those before you open one.

Money Transmission Risk When an Accountant Holds Client Money

Federal and state money transmission rules apply to businesses that move other people's money. Whether a CPA firm's occasional accommodation falls under them depends on the facts. State licensing laws differ from one another, so an arrangement that is fine in one state may not be fine in the next.

Payroll companies that collect and remit client tax deposits deal with these questions as a core part of their business, usually with licensing counsel involved. A small firm doing it as a favor has usually never looked at them. This is general information, not legal advice. If your firm has been accepting and remitting client funds, talk to a qualified attorney about your state's rules.

Then there's the client relationship. If a remittance arrives late or gets applied to the wrong period, the client finds out first, through a notice from the taxing authority. Their next call is to you, and the call after that may go to your professional liability carrier.

Safer Paths: Client-Initiated Payments to the IRS and States

Each option below moves money from the client's account straight to the government. Enrollment steps and fees change, so confirm current terms on IRS.gov or your state revenue department's site before you build a workflow around any of them.

Bank payments through federal systems. The IRS offers ways for individuals and businesses to pay directly from their own bank accounts, including an enrollment-based system many businesses use for federal tax deposits, where payments are debited on a date the taxpayer schedules. Your job is setup and scheduling, and the client's bank account stays the only source of funds.

Card payments made by the client. IRS.gov lists the ways to pay by debit or credit card. Processors that handle those payments generally charge the cardholder a fee, so the client can decide whether their rewards outweigh it. Because the transaction is in the client's name, any dispute stays between the client and their card issuer.

State payments. State revenue departments run their own payment portals. At the state level the principle doesn't change: the client's account pays the state directly.

PathWhose account the money touchesWho carries dispute and remittance risk
Firm charges the client's card, then remitsClient's, then the firm'sThe firm
Client pays by card through an IRS-listed optionClient's onlyClient and their card issuer
Client pays from a bank account through an IRS or state systemClient's onlyClient
Withdrawal authorized with the e-filed returnClient's onlyClient

Scheduling Payments Without Touching the Money

A client who asks you to "handle the payment" usually wants two things. They don't want to think about it, and they want proof it happened. You can give them both while the money stays in their account.

  1. Set up the withdrawal when you e-file. An e-filed return can generally include the client's authorization to withdraw a balance due from their bank account on a date they choose. The client confirms the account and date when they sign. Check IRS.gov for the current rules.
  2. Schedule the year's estimates in one sitting. Book a short screen-share before the first estimate is due. While you guide them, the client enters their own bank details in the payment system and schedules each payment. Don't collect or store their login credentials or bank details. The same habit protects card data, as our guide to PCI compliance for law and accounting firms explains.
  3. File the confirmation numbers. Store each confirmation in the client file and send the client a calendar of dates and amounts.
  4. Remind before each debit. A note a few days ahead gives the client time to make sure the account has enough money in it.
  5. Bill the scheduling work. List payment scheduling as its own line item on your invoice and collect that fee through your own merchant account. That is a normal transaction for your own services. Our breakdown of what accounting firms should pay for card processing can help you set the price.

To the client, this still feels full-service. Your firm keeps the schedule and the confirmations, and the client's bank keeps the money.

Engagement Letter Language on Tax Payment Responsibility

Put the policy in writing so nobody at the firm has to improvise when a client calls on deadline day. The clause below is illustrative, not legal advice. Have your attorney and your professional liability carrier review the language you actually use.

Client will pay all taxes, estimates, penalties and interest directly to the applicable taxing authorities. On request, the Firm will provide payment amounts and due dates and, if engaged, will help Client schedule electronic payments from Client's own accounts. Under no circumstances will the Firm accept or remit tax payments on Client's behalf or hold Client funds for that purpose. Confirming that sufficient funds are available on each scheduled payment date remains Client's responsibility.

Put the scheduling fee and your own payment terms in the same letter. Our guide to engagement letter payment terms that prevent fee disputes covers that part.

This week, ask your staff whether anyone has ever run a client's tax payment through the firm's merchant account. If someone has, review those transactions with counsel and your carrier, then adopt the written policy before the next estimate deadline. For the money your firm should be collecting, which is your own fees, see how MannyPay handles payment processing for professional services firms, or request a free quote for your firm's processing and a MannyPay specialist will respond within one business day.

About the author

Isabella Cruz

Isabella Cruz is Business Growth & Commerce Editor for Beyond the Swipe, writing for small businesses, restaurants, retailers, entertainment venues and e-commerce sellers.

This article is for general educational purposes and is not legal, tax or financial advice. Card network rules and state laws change; confirm current requirements for your business.

Related reading