Unclaimed Property and Virtual Currency in Games
Industry Payment Guides

Unclaimed In-Game Currency: Breakage, Escheat and Shutdown Refunds

How unclaimed property rules may apply to virtual currency in games, plus breakage accounting, expiring balances and shutdown refunds for studios.

Close-up of hands holding a blue game controller with a glowing light bar against a dark background

Photo: Pixabay

On this page 6 sections
  1. Unspent Currency Is Deferred Revenue Until Players Use It
  2. Breakage Accounting for Game Studios
  3. Unclaimed Property Law and Virtual Currency in Games
  4. Expiring In-Game Currency: What Your Terms Can Say
  5. Sunsetting a Game: Notice, Refunds and Disputes
  6. Records to Keep for Breakage and Unclaimed Property Audits

Key takeaways

  • Tag every wallet unit as paid or earned. Only paid currency drives the liability, the breakage estimate and any escheat exposure.
  • Don't book breakage on balances a state could claim. Settle the escheat question with counsel first, or reported revenue can turn back into a liability.
  • If paid currency expires at all, disclose it at purchase and on the receipt, and apply any rule change only to new purchases.
  • In a shutdown, stop currency sales the day you announce, refund only to the original payment method, and keep the merchant account open for late disputes.

Purchased in-game currency that players haven't spent is a liability on a studio's books. It stays a liability until players spend it or the studio can reliably estimate that they never will. Whether a state can claim those balances is the open question in unclaimed property law for virtual currency in games. The answer turns on each state's statute and on whether your currency can ever become cash again. Shutting a game down doesn't erase the balances. It concentrates them, and card disputes follow.

The stakes are highest when you sell currency through your own web store or launcher. In that setup you are the merchant of record. Disputes land on your merchant account, and your ledger is the record an auditor reads. Currency sold through a platform store falls under that platform's refund terms, but the revenue accounting is still yours. Treat everything below as general information, and confirm your treatment with a CPA and with counsel who practices unclaimed property law.

Unspent Currency Is Deferred Revenue Until Players Use It

A player who buys a gem bundle has paid for something you haven't delivered yet. Under U.S. generally accepted accounting principles, that payment sits as deferred revenue, which is a liability, and it moves into revenue as the player spends currency and receives items. Durable items complicate this. Take a skin the player keeps for the life of the account: its revenue may be recognized over the period the player benefits from it. Your auditor will want to see how you estimated that period and what player data backs the estimate.

Most games run two currencies through one wallet. Players earn one by playing. They buy the other. Only the purchased portion carries cash value on your books, so your system has to tag every unit by source from the moment it enters the wallet.

Spend order matters too. If the game burns earned currency first, paid balances sit longer and the liability stays high. If paid currency goes first, deferred revenue converts sooner. Many studios don't know their own spend order, because a designer chose it years ago for gameplay reasons and nobody in finance was consulted. Find out before your accountant asks.

Breakage Accounting for Game Studios

Breakage is purchased currency that players will never spend. Some of it belongs to players who quit, and some sits in accounts players can no longer reach. A good share is dust: leftover gems too few to buy anything in the store. Dust is partly a pricing decision. When bundle sizes don't line up with item prices, nearly every purchase leaves a remainder behind.

Accounting rules let a studio recognize expected breakage as revenue once its redemption history is deep enough to estimate breakage reliably. The breakage doesn't arrive in one lump. It follows the pattern of redemptions.

Here is how that works, using illustrative proportions only, not data from any real studio. Assume your direct store's redemption history supports an estimate that a tenth of purchased currency will never be spent. Assume no state can claim the unspent balances. Partway through the year, players have spent half of the currency you expect them to spend eventually. You recognize those redemptions as revenue. You also recognize half of the expected breakage, because breakage follows the redemption pattern, and that half rides along with the redemptions. The other half of the breakage waits. So does the liability for every gem players still hold.

The assumption studios skip is the second one. When a state can claim unspent balances, those amounts don't belong in breakage revenue at all, because you expect to hand them to the government. Getting this wrong is worse than a timing error. Revenue you already reported can turn back into a liability years later, in the middle of an audit.

Unclaimed Property Law and Virtual Currency in Games

Every state has an unclaimed property law, also called escheat. A business holding money that belongs to someone else, such as an uncashed payroll check, must report it and turn it over to the state after a dormancy period, and the state then holds it for the owner. How these laws treat a game wallet is unsettled. Three issues decide most of your exposure.

The No-Cash-Value Argument

Most game terms describe purchased currency as a limited license with no cash value. That language supports the position that a state has nothing to claim. It is still only a position, and a state administrator reading its own statute can disagree. Some statutes carve out specific kinds of non-cash value. Others say nothing, and silence is not an exemption. If your game has ever let players cash out, or sell currency for money through a sanctioned marketplace, that history weakens the argument considerably.

Which State Gets the Balance

States sort out which of them can claim a balance mainly by the owner's last known address. When the holder has no address on file, the state where the company is incorporated commonly comes next. Confirm the order that applies to you with counsel.

The practical issue is address data. A studio that never collects billing addresses can end up reporting to its home state on balances owned by players everywhere. Unclaimed property audits also reach back many years, and when records are missing, the auditor builds the estimate. You lose control of the number.

Gift Cards and Prepaid Codes

Prepaid cards or codes redeemable for your currency look far more like gift certificates, whether you sell them at retail or in your own store. Federal law sets baseline rules on expiration dates and fees for many gift cards. Several states layer stricter rules on top, and some require cash back for small leftover balances. Track these cards separately from in-wallet currency, and have counsel review them against both federal and state law.

A short engagement with unclaimed property counsel costs little next to an audit finding that covers years of balances. Sales tax raises its own state-by-state questions, covered in whether in-game currency is taxable.

Expiring In-Game Currency: What Your Terms Can Say

Expiration clauses are tempting. They turn a liability into revenue on a schedule you control. They also carry the most risk of anything in this article, because state consumer protection and gift card laws can restrict expiring in-game currency, and app stores set their own limits on currency sold through them. A clause that reads fine in your terms of service can look unfair once a regulator or an issuer's dispute analyst reads it.

The line that matters most separates earned currency from paid currency. A daily login bonus that expires is a gameplay rule. Paid gems that expire look like value taken back. Complaints start there.

If paid currency expires at all, put the expiration on the purchase screen and the receipt, not only in the terms. Warn players by email or in game early enough for them to spend it. Skip inactivity fees on paid balances entirely; a fee that eats a stored balance is the practice gift card laws were written to stop. And when you change expiration rules, apply the change to new purchases only, because rewriting the deal on currency players already bought tends to produce complaints and disputes in the same week.

Your expiration terms and your in-game purchase refund policy have to agree. Dispute reviewers read both.

Sunsetting a Game: Notice, Refunds and Disputes

Shutting down a live game leaves you holding the largest pile of unspent currency you will ever have, and it hands your entire player base a reason to call their bank. Order matters here.

  1. Talk to your processor before you announce. Your acquiring bank is pricing future disputes, not just today's sales, so expect questions about reserves and how you will fund refunds. Studios selling preorders face similar scrutiny, explained in why processors hold game studio funds.
  2. Stop selling currency the day you announce. Selling gems for a game you've said is closing invites disputes you will lose.
  3. Publish a spend-down window and a written refund policy. Tell players when the servers close and what happens to purchased currency left at the end. Some studios refund purchases made within a recent window, while others refund unspent purchased balances or combine both approaches. Send every refund to the original payment method through your processor, since refunds through other channels resemble the money movement in in-game currency laundering schemes.
  4. Keep the merchant account and support inbox open after the servers go dark. Cardholders can dispute a purchase as a service not provided long after the fact. Disputes against a closed account create a negative balance, and the processor will collect it from you.
  5. Settle the escheat question with counsel before you write off leftover balances as revenue.

A refund you issue costs less than a dispute you lose. The lost dispute adds a fee and eats staff time. Worse, it counts toward your dispute ratio, which follows your company to its next game and its next video game merchant account application. Banning players who dispute charges during a shutdown carries its own risks, covered in whether you can ban a player for filing a chargeback.

Records to Keep for Breakage and Unclaimed Property Audits

Your auditor and your dispute team ask for the same underlying data. Build it once.

RecordWhy it matters
Purchase ledger by player, with transaction ID and payment methodTies every paid balance to a real transaction and supports refunds to the original card
Wallet balances split into paid and earned currencyOnly paid currency drives the liability and any escheat exposure
Redemption logs showing what was spent and whenSupports your breakage estimate and proves delivery in disputes
Player country and state of residenceDetermines which state has priority on unclaimed balances
Terms of service version history with acceptance timestampsShows which expiration and refund terms each player agreed to
Breakage methodology and the history behind itLets your auditor test the estimate instead of rejecting it
Shutdown notices, refund logs and dispute outcomesShows players were told and treated consistently

Keep these records for years after a game closes. An unclaimed property audit can arrive long after the last server shuts off.

Start with one report: purchased currency still unspent, broken out by player state. Take it to your CPA and unclaimed property counsel before you book another dollar of breakage. If you're also reviewing how your direct store takes payments, MannyPay works with game and gaming businesses through its high-risk merchant accounts, and a specialist responds to free quote requests within one business day.

About the author

Marcus Bennett

Marcus Bennett is Payments Risk & Compliance Analyst for Beyond the Swipe, covering high-risk processing, chargebacks, rolling reserves, frozen merchant accounts and fraud prevention.

This article is for general educational purposes and is not legal, tax or financial advice. Card network rules and state laws change; confirm current requirements for your business.

Related reading