Xsolla vs Stripe for Game Web Shops: Fees, Tax and Risk
Industry Payment Guides

Xsolla vs. Stripe vs. Paddle: Who Should Run Your Game Web Shop?

Xsolla vs Stripe for a game web shop: published fees, a worked cost example on currency packs, and who handles sales tax, VAT and chargebacks for you.

Person with short copper-colored hair wearing a black gaming headset, facing a monitor with a blue screen at a white desk

Photo: Pixabay

On this page 6 sections
  1. Merchant of Record vs. Direct Processing for Game Sales
  2. What Each Provider Publishes About Fees
  3. Xsolla vs. Stripe Fees on Three Currency Packs
  4. Tax and Fraud: The Work Inside an MoR Fee
  5. Acceptable Use Decides Before Price Does
  6. Choosing by Studio Size and Player Map

Key takeaways

  • At Stripe's published U.S. rates, direct processing costs less than Paddle's 5% + 50¢ for U.S. players at all three pack prices tested, but only if your dispute rate stays well under about 1.2% to 1.5%.
  • Stripe adds 1.5% for international cards and 1% for currency conversion. For foreign players paying in their own currency, those charges alone can make direct processing cost more than a merchant of record.
  • Paddle's published pricing says products under $10 need custom pricing, and Xsolla's 5% excludes payment channel costs. Get written quotes before you compare small packs.
  • Stripe Tax Basic calculates and collects tax. Registration and filing come with Tax Complete, which starts at $90 a month on a one-year contract.

The Xsolla vs. Stripe choice for a game web shop comes down to who acts as the legal seller. Xsolla is a merchant of record (MoR). It sells to the player in its own name and takes on tax collection and much of the dispute work, and its fee is higher to pay for that. In Stripe's standard setup, your studio stays the seller: per-sale processing costs less, but tax filings and chargebacks are your job. Paddle is the other MoR studios usually compare. It was built for software sellers, so check whether it fits game monetization before you look at price.

The reason studios set up web shops at all is the platform commission, which runs many times higher than card processing. Rulings against app store anti-steering rules have made web checkout more realistic for mobile games. Our coverage of South Korea's fines against Apple and Google over app payments gives one example. A direct store also gives you purchase history, an email list and web-only bundles. The cost is the platform's back-office work, and choosing a provider means deciding how much of that work to pay someone else to do.

Merchant of Record vs. Direct Processing for Game Sales

When a player buys a gem pack through an MoR, the MoR is the one selling the gems, and it pays you as its supplier. With direct processing, your studio is the seller. The processor moves the money and charges you for the service.

QuestionMerchant of record (Xsolla, Paddle)Direct processing (Stripe standard, or a merchant account)
Legal sellerThe MoRYour studio
Sales tax and VAT registrationGenerally the MoRYou, even if software calculates it
ChargebacksReceived by the MoR under its termsReceived by you
Fraud lossesMostly absorbed by the MoR, within its termsAbsorbed by you
Pricing shapeOne bundled feeA lower processing fee, plus tools and losses you pay for separately
Cardholder statementOften the MoR's nameYour business name

Studios tend to misread two rows of this table. First, an MoR does not make fraud stop being your problem. It pools the risk and prices it into the fee, but it watches your dispute and fraud rates the way any acquirer does. If carders find your shop, the MoR can hold your funds or close the account. Second, the statement descriptor causes more trouble than studios expect. A parent who sees an unfamiliar company name on a card statement is more likely to dispute the charge than to email you for a refund. Ask the MoR exactly what text appears on the statement, then use that name in your receipt emails and on your checkout page.

Stripe also offers its own MoR option now. Stripe's published pricing, as summarized by Checkout Page's 2026 Stripe fee breakdown, lists Managed Payments at an extra 3.5% per transaction, with Stripe acting as merchant of record. Before you count on it, confirm with Stripe that in-game currency qualifies.

What Each Provider Publishes About Fees

Here are the rates available publicly at the time of writing. Confirm current terms before you sign anything.

  • Stripe (standard U.S. pricing): 2.9% + 30¢ for a domestic online card payment. International cards add 1.5%, and currency conversion adds 1% when it applies, according to Swipesum's guide to Stripe fees. Stripe's own pricing page charges $15 for each dispute you receive, plus another $15 if you respond to a dispute manually. You get the second fee back only if you win.
  • Stripe add-ons: Stripe Tax Basic costs 0.5% per transaction where you're registered. Tax Complete adds registration and filing and starts at $90 a month on a one-year contract, per this breakdown of Stripe Tax plans. Paid Radar fraud plans start at $0.05 per screened transaction on a pay-as-you-go basis, according to Chargeflow's summary of Radar pricing.
  • Xsolla: 5% of the transaction plus the cost of the payment channel, with no setup fee, according to coverage from Yes Press and Noda. Xsolla doesn't publish the channel cost, so you can only learn your real all-in rate from a quote.
  • Paddle: 5% + 50¢ per checkout transaction with no monthly fee, per Creem's review of Paddle pricing. Paddle's pricing page also says products under $10 need custom pricing, as noted in Flozic's Paddle review. Many gem packs fall under that line.

Gaming volume is often priced individually, so treat these as starting points, not your rates.

Xsolla vs. Stripe Fees on Three Currency Packs

This example is illustrative. It uses the published rates above and these assumptions:

  • All buyers are U.S. players paying with U.S. cards in dollars. Tax is added on top of the pack price.
  • Stripe direct: 2.9% + 30¢ processing, 0.5% for Stripe Tax Basic and $0.05 per sale for a paid Radar plan.
  • Disputes: 0.5% of direct sales get disputed. You don't contest them, so each one costs the $15 dispute fee plus the lost sale.
  • Stripe Managed Payments: standard processing plus 3.5%. Dispute costs under Managed Payments are not modeled.
  • Paddle: 5% + 50¢. Packs under $10 would actually be quoted custom.
  • Xsolla: only the 5% portion is shown, because the channel cost isn't published.
  • Staff time and outside tax filing help are excluded.
Cost per sale (illustrative)$4.99 pack$19.99 pack$99.99 pack
Stripe direct, processing only$0.44 (8.9%)$0.88 (4.4%)$3.20 (3.2%)
Stripe direct, all modeled costs$0.62 (12.4%)$1.20 (6.0%)$4.32 (4.3%)
Stripe Managed Payments$0.62 (12.4%)$1.58 (7.9%)$6.70 (6.7%)
Paddle$0.75 (15.0%)$1.50 (7.5%)$5.50 (5.5%)
Xsolla, 5% before channel cost$0.25 + channel$1.00 + channel$5.00 + channel

Here is how the $19.99 row adds up: $0.88 in processing, about $0.10 for tax software, $0.05 for screening and about $0.17 in expected dispute cost (0.5% of $15 plus $19.99) come to $1.20.

Processing alone isn't comparable to an MoR's fee, because the MoR fee covers work you would otherwise pay for. Even with that work counted, direct processing wins for U.S. players in this model. The margin depends on your dispute rate. On the $19.99 pack, direct processing costs the same as Paddle at a dispute rate of about 1.34%. A studio with a dispute rate that high would face card network monitoring before the fee gap mattered.

Fixed fees take the biggest share of small packs. At $4.99, the 30¢ or 50¢ per-sale charge makes up most of the cost under every model. If your best-selling pack is your cheapest one, ask for small-ticket pricing, or think about starting your pack ladder at a higher price. Our breakdown of microtransaction processing fee math for game studios covers this in more depth.

Where the Comparison Flips: Foreign Players

Change one assumption: the player has a non-U.S. card and pays in their own currency. Stripe's 1.5% international card fee and 1% conversion fee add 2.5% to the direct cost. The $19.99 pack goes from $1.20 to about $1.70, above Paddle's $1.50. The $99.99 pack goes from $4.32 to about $6.82, also above Paddle's $5.50. Ask each MoR how it handles currency conversion too, since a conversion spread would raise its cost as well. The point is that a studio with mostly U.S. players and a studio with mostly foreign players can reach opposite answers from the same rate cards.

Payment methods outside the U.S. matter as much as fees. Depending on the market, players may use bank transfers, local e-wallets, carrier billing or prepaid vouchers. Xsolla built its method coverage around markets where players spend money. Stripe supports a broad catalog, but you're the merchant on each method, and some methods have their own onboarding requirements. Rank your top player countries by revenue. For each one, confirm the local methods players use, local-currency price display and which currency you'll be paid out in. If you go direct, MannyPay's international payment processing includes multi-currency acceptance and a review of settlement currency.

Tax and Fraud: The Work Inside an MoR Fee

Tax is where an MoR earns most of its fee. In the U.S., whether in-game currency is taxable depends on how each state treats digital goods, and each state sets its own economic nexus threshold for remote sellers. Many countries, including EU member states and the UK, tax digital sales to consumers based on where the buyer lives. A studio selling worldwide can therefore owe registrations in many places at the same time.

An MoR registers and remits in its own name. Stripe Tax Basic calculates and collects, but the filing and the liability stay with you unless you pay for Tax Complete or an outside filer. Our piece on sales tax for in-game currency and digital items covers the U.S. rules. This is general information, so confirm your own obligations with a qualified tax professional.

In-game currency is delivered instantly and moves easily between accounts, which is why criminals use it for turning stolen cards into cash. With direct processing, every fraud chargeback lands on you and counts toward the dispute ratios that card network monitoring programs track. 3-D Secure authentication can shift liability for many fraud disputes to the card issuer, at the cost of some checkout friction. Our guide to 3-D Secure liability shift for online stores explains how to weigh that friction. Friendly fraud, such as a child using a parent's card, happens with every provider. Our playbook on winning "my kid bought gems" chargebacks lists the evidence issuers want to see.

Acceptable Use Decides Before Price Does

Each provider's acceptable use policy can rule out your monetization model before fees come into it. Xsolla writes its terms with virtual currency in mind. Paddle's terms center on software and subscriptions. Stripe has its own restricted-business list. Read the current version of each against your exact model, and get written answers to these questions before you write integration code:

  1. Is selling virtual currency and consumable items permitted?
  2. Are randomized rewards allowed, and must you publish odds? Our article on loot boxes and payment processor account risk explains why this question decides many approvals.
  3. Can players trade items, or convert currency back to cash? Cash-out features can raise money transmission questions under state and federal law, so get legal advice before you build one.
  4. Does your model involve account sales or key resales?
  5. What age and parental-consent rules apply to your audience?

Describe your game accurately during onboarding. Splitting sales across accounts or relabeling currency to get through underwriting leads to closed accounts and can put a business on the card networks' terminated-merchant list. If the honest description doesn't fit a provider, choose another provider. MannyPay offers high-risk merchant accounts for businesses that general processors decline, and our guide to getting a video game merchant account approved lists what underwriters review.

Choosing by Studio Size and Player Map

A small studio with a global audience usually does better with a merchant of record. Registering for tax in many countries and staffing dispute response would cost more than the fee gap, and foreign-card surcharges shrink that gap further. A mid-size studio with mostly U.S. players and a low dispute rate is the case where direct processing pays, as the worked example shows. Expect underwriting to ask about your fraud controls and possibly to set a reserve.

Our article on why processors hold game studio funds explains how reserves are set. A mobile studio steering players to the web should test checkout speed on a phone before comparing fees. A larger studio can split the work: an MoR for hard international markets and a direct account for domestic volume. That only makes sense once the savings cover the extra reconciliation work.

Your next step: pull last quarter's sales by player country and by pack price, then rerun the table above with real quotes, your actual dispute rate and your share of foreign cards. To get a direct-processing quote to set beside an MoR offer, start with MannyPay's payment processing for gaming businesses. A specialist responds to free quote requests within one business day.

Sources

  1. Stripe: Pricing & Fees
  2. Swipesum: Stripe Fees 2026: Card, ACH & International
  3. Checkout Page: Stripe Fees 2026, Every Rate and What a $100 Sale Nets You
  4. Lilach Bullock: Stripe Tax, Basic vs Complete Pricing and What It Covers
  5. Chargeflow: Stripe Radar Chargeback Prevention, Pricing & Rules
  6. Yes Press: The Checkout Company Trying to Give Game Makers Their Store Back (Xsolla)
  7. Noda: Xsolla vs Stripe, Which Is Better for Gaming Payments?
  8. Flozic: Paddle Review 2026, Pricing, Pros and Cons
  9. Creem: Paddle Pricing, the Real Cost After Fees

About the author

Marcus Bennett

Marcus Bennett is Payments Risk & Compliance Analyst for Beyond the Swipe, covering high-risk processing, chargebacks, rolling reserves, frozen merchant accounts and fraud prevention.

This article is for general educational purposes and is not legal, tax or financial advice. Card network rules and state laws change; confirm current requirements for your business.

Related reading