ACH vs. Credit Card Fees: What a $20,000 Invoice Really Costs
Compare ACH vs. credit card fees using Visa's current B2B interchange rates, see when big card payments cost less, and set an ACH threshold for invoices.

Photo: Pixabay
On this page 7 sections
- Why Card Fees Grow With the Invoice and ACH Fees Don't
- ACH vs. Credit Card Fees on a $250, $2,500 and $20,000 Invoice
- Large Card Payments Don't Always Cost 2.70%
- What You Give up for the Cheaper Rail
- When the Card Fee Is Worth Paying
- Set a Dollar Threshold and Steer Payments Above It
- Questions to Ask Before You Add ACH
Key takeaways
- Visa interchange alone on a $20,000 commercial card payment made online or keyed in is $540.10. An ACH debit is priced by your provider and usually doesn't grow with the invoice.
- If a customer has to pay by purchasing card, Level 3 data or Visa's Large Purchase Advantage rates can cut that interchange to about $350 or $190. You only see the lower rate if your pricing passes interchange through to you.
- A debit to a business account that is returned as unauthorized has to come back within two banking days. On consumer accounts the window is 60 days, so B2B ACH settles with much more certainty.
ACH almost always costs less than a credit card on an invoice, and the gap widens as the invoice grows. Card fees are mostly a percentage of the sale. Visa's U.S. interchange table sets interchange of 2.70% + $0.10 on a commercial card paid online or keyed in, before your processor adds a cent. A $20,000 invoice therefore carries $540.10 in interchange alone.
ACH fees are set by your provider, usually as a flat charge per payment or a percentage with a cap, so a large payment costs about what a small one does. That difference in structure settles most ACH vs. credit card fees questions before you compare quotes: steer your largest invoices to bank payment and keep cards for the rest.
Why Card Fees Grow With the Invoice and ACH Fees Don't
A card fee has three layers:
- Interchange: paid to the bank that issued the card, at rates Visa and Mastercard publish.
- Network assessment fees: charged by the card networks.
- Processor markup: your processor's own price.
Interchange is a network rate, and every processor starts from it. The markup is one processor's pricing, and it's the part you can negotiate.
Invoice payments tend to fall into the more expensive interchange categories. Business, corporate and purchasing cards cost more to accept than consumer debit. A payment made on a payment page or keyed into a virtual terminal is card-not-present, and that costs more than a tapped or dipped card. Our explainer on why online and keyed transactions cost more to process covers the reasons.
ACH moves money between bank accounts under operating rules written by Nacha, but Nacha publishes no merchant rate table. What you pay is your bank's or processor's price, and it depends on which direction the payment moves.
An ACH credit is a push: your customer sends the money from their bank, often through an accounts-payable system. Receiving credits is often cheap or free on a business checking account (check your bank's fee schedule). The cost shows up as work instead. You match payments to invoices by hand, and every payer has your account number, so ask your bank about ACH debit blocks on that account.
An ACH debit is a pull. The customer authorizes you to take the payment, and your processor or bank submits it. Providers typically price debits per transaction or as a capped percentage, and many add a monthly fee and a charge for each returned payment. Get all of it in writing, because at low volume the per-payment price alone understates the cost.
ACH vs. Credit Card Fees on a $250, $2,500 and $20,000 Invoice
The card column below uses Visa's published Commercial Card Not Present rate of 2.70% + $0.10. That is interchange only. Assessments and processor markup come on top, so your real card cost will be higher. The ACH column is illustrative: it assumes a provider that charges a flat $0.50 per debit, which is not a quote or a market rate. Replace these figures with the ones on your own statement and ACH proposal.
| Invoice amount | Card interchange at 2.70% + $0.10 | ACH debit at an assumed $0.50 |
|---|---|---|
| $250 | $6.85 | $0.50 |
| $2,500 | $67.60 | $0.50 |
| $20,000 | $540.10 | $0.50 |
On the $250 invoice the gap is a few dollars. On the $20,000 invoice, the card fee can take a real share of the job's profit.
Now look at a full year. Picture a contractor whose dozen largest invoices average $20,000. At the Commercial Card Not Present rate, those twelve payments cost $6,481.20 in interchange. By ACH at the assumed $0.50, they cost $6.00 before any monthly ACH fee. Every smaller invoice could stay on cards and the business would still keep about $6,475 a year, plus the markup it was paying on top. You don't need every customer on ACH, only the ones who pay your biggest invoices.
Large Card Payments Don't Always Cost 2.70%
Many suppliers don't know this. When a customer pays a big invoice with a corporate or purchasing card, the fee can be far lower than the table above suggests, but only if your setup qualifies the transaction.
Two Visa programs matter. The first covers enhanced data. In Visa's April 2026 table, corporate and purchasing card payments that carry full Level 3 line-item data qualify for 1.75% + $0.10, according to weAudit's review of the new schedule. The same review notes that Visa dropped its separate Level 2 rates, so sending only basic Level 2 fields no longer gets a lower rate on Visa commercial cards. If your gateway was set up years ago for Level 2, you may be missing that saving.
The second is Visa's Large Purchase Advantage program. For purchasing cards used card-not-present, Visa's table prices a transaction from $10,000.01 to $25,000 at 0.70% + $49.50, with lower percentages for bigger tiers. The program has its own qualification requirements, so ask your processor whether your transactions qualify.
Here is the same $20,000 invoice on a Visa purchasing card under each rate, interchange only:
| How the $20,000 card payment qualifies | Interchange |
|---|---|
| Commercial Card Not Present, no enhanced data (2.70% + $0.10) | $540.10 |
| Level 3 data, Commercial Product 3 (1.75% + $0.10) | $350.10 |
| Large Purchase Advantage, $10,000.01 to $25,000 (0.70% + $49.50) | $189.50 |
ACH is still cheaper. But if a large customer will only pay by purchasing card, the gap between $540 and $190 is worth a call to your processor. You only see the lower rate if your pricing passes interchange through. On a flat-rate or tiered plan, the processor may keep the difference. Our guide to accepting virtual card payments in B2B covers the workflow on the supplier side.
What You Give up for the Cheaper Rail
Card batches commonly fund within a business day or two. Standard ACH usually takes longer to reach usable funds, and same-day ACH costs extra. Our comparison of same-day ACH vs. standard ACH shows when the faster option pays for itself. New ACH merchants should also expect holds or per-payment limits while they build a track record.
A debit can also come back after the money lands. Under Nacha rules, most returns, including insufficient funds and closed accounts, must be sent back within two banking days of settlement, as Plaid's return-code guide summarizes. On a consumer account, a claim that a debit was unauthorized can come back up to 60 calendar days later. On a business account, an unauthorized return must come back within the two-banking-day window, per Ramp's list of return codes. That works in favor of B2B billing. Once a debit to a company account clears that short window, it is far less likely to be reversed than a card payment, which stays open to disputes much longer.
Nacha also monitors the businesses that originate debits. Its return-rate thresholds, as Ramp summarizes them, are 0.5% for unauthorized returns and 3% for administrative returns such as invalid or closed accounts. Clean authorizations and verified account details keep you under both.
Plan for payment redirection fraud. In this scheme, a criminal emails your customer, poses as you and sends "updated" bank details. Tell customers in writing that you never change bank instructions by email alone. Ask them to confirm any change by calling a number they already have for you.
When the Card Fee Is Worth Paying
Turning off cards would cost most invoiced businesses customers. On small invoices, a few dollars of fee saves a reminder email and days of waiting. A card deposit from a new client puts money in hand before you've collected bank details. Some large companies' accounts-payable teams pay only by purchasing or virtual card, and then your alternative is a slower check. Take the card and set it up to qualify for the lower rates above.
Speed can also matter more than margin. Paying a card fee to collect an overdue invoice today may cost less than weeks of chasing, or less than selling the invoice to a factor. Compare it against the costs in our breakdown of invoice factoring and its alternatives.
Set a Dollar Threshold and Steer Payments Above It
Steering works best when it's in your terms before the work starts.
- Find your threshold. Sort last year's invoices by amount and add up the card fees in each size range. The amount where fees start cutting into job margin is your threshold.
- Write it into the contract. Add a clause that makes invoices above that amount payable by ACH or wire, with cards accepted below it. That gives you a rule to point to. See our piece on setting Net 30 terms customers honor.
- List bank payment first. Put ACH above cards on the invoice and payment page.
- Show the price difference openly. Cash discount pricing and dual pricing show a lower price for paying without a card. Surcharging adds a fee to card payments where permitted. Network rules govern it, and some states restrict it further. Read our rundown of Visa and Mastercard surcharge rules, and confirm your state's rules with a qualified professional first.
- Collect authorization once for recurring work. For retainers and monthly contracts, have the client sign an ACH authorization at onboarding and debit on schedule. Nacha rules require proper authorization for debits, so use your provider's language rather than drafting your own.
Questions to Ask Before You Add ACH
You can run cards through a processor and ACH through your bank. The drawback is that deposits arrive from two systems and you reconcile them by hand. Sending one invoice or payment link with both options is simpler. For a fuller comparison, see our guide on choosing a B2B payment provider or your bank for invoices. Ask any provider:
- How is ACH priced, and what are the monthly and return fees?
- When are ACH funds available, and do new accounts face holds or limits?
- Can the customer choose bank or card on the same payment page?
- Is card pricing interchange-plus, so Level 3 and large-purchase rates reach you?
- Does it sync with your accounting software?
MannyPay provides card processing, payment gateways including Authorize.net and NMI, QuickBooks integration, and cash discount, dual pricing and surcharging programs where permitted. Ask about bank-payment options when you request pricing.
Before you talk to anyone, do step one above. The card fees you paid on last year's largest invoices are what an ACH threshold is worth to your business. Then request a free quote from MannyPay with that number in hand, and a specialist will respond within one business day.
Sources
- Visa USA Interchange Reimbursement Fees
- Level 3 Credit Card Processing: 2026 Guide for B2B (weAudit)
- Interchange Fees Explained: Rates, Tables & How to Pay Less (IntelliPay)
- Visa Enhanced Data / Level 2 and Level 3 Data Interchange (CardFellow)
- ACH Return Codes: Full R01 to R85 List & What to Do (Ramp)
- ACH Return Codes: A Complete Guide for Businesses (Plaid)
This article is for general educational purposes and is not legal, tax or financial advice. Card network rules and state laws change; confirm current requirements for your business.


