Clover vs. Square: Fees, Hardware and Contract Terms Compared
Clover vs Square compared on published fees, hardware prices and contracts, with a worked example showing the monthly volume where each one costs less.
On this page 7 sections
- Square Sells Direct, While Clover Has Many Sellers
- Clover vs Square Fees at Published Rates
- Worked Example: The Volume Where Clover Starts Costing Less
- Hardware Prices, Lock-In and the Lease Trap
- Software, Apps and Contract Terms
- Which System Fits Retail, Restaurants and Salons
- Get These Answers in Writing Before You Sign
Key takeaways
- With a $25 average ticket, Square Free costs less than Clover.com's Retail Growth plan until in-person sales reach about $17,000 a month. Against Square Plus, the break-even point is about $9,000.
- Clover charges 10¢ per sale and Square charges 15¢. Small tickets push the break-even point down to about $10,600 at $10, and large tickets push it up to about $22,200 at $60.
- A reseller's Clover quote should beat Clover.com's published 2.3% + 10¢ plus software. If it doesn't, it has to win on service or terms.
- Buying a device outright on Clover.com doesn't require a contract term. Promotions, hardware subscriptions and reseller leases can still lock you in for years.
Square usually costs less for a small business with light card volume. Its Free plan charges 2.6% + 15¢ for each in-person sale and has no monthly fee. Clover usually pulls ahead once in-person sales reach somewhere between about $9,000 and $17,000 a month, because Clover.com's Retail Growth plan charges 2.3% + 10¢ per sale for an $84.95 monthly software fee. The complication in clover vs square is that banks and independent sales organizations (ISOs) also sell Clover on their own terms. The Clover price you pay depends on who sells it to you.
MannyPay resells Clover, so read this comparison with that in mind. It shows where Square comes out ahead too. Every rate below is that company's own pricing, not a Visa or Mastercard rule. Both companies change their plans, so check current terms before you sign anything.
Square Sells Direct, While Clover Has Many Sellers
Square sells its hardware, software and processing itself, at prices it publishes. It works as a payment facilitator: your business processes as a sub-merchant under Square's own master account. That is why you can sign up online and take a card the same day. The tradeoff is that most of the scrutiny comes after you start selling. A sudden jump in volume or an unusually large ticket can trigger a review, and funds can be held while it runs.
Clover is Fiserv's small-business POS line, according to Payment Processing Guide's Clover review. Fiserv sells Clover on Clover.com at published prices. Banks and ISOs resell the same devices and set their own processing rates, software prices and contract terms. Orbix Payments' breakdown of Clover.com pricing points out that the prices Clover shows apply only on clover.com. When you buy Clover through an ISO or a bank, you usually get your own merchant account, underwritten before approval. Setup is slower, but the account is built around the business type and volume you disclosed. A busy season you told the underwriter about doesn't come as a surprise.
| Square | Clover from Clover.com | Clover from a bank or ISO | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who sets processing rates | Square, published | Fiserv, published | The reseller |
| Pricing model | Flat rate by plan | Flat rate by plan | Flat, tiered or interchange-plus |
| Monthly software | $0, $49 or $149 per location | Varies by plan; Retail Growth is $84.95 | Set by the reseller |
| Hardware works with | Square processing only | Fiserv processing only | Fiserv processing only |
Clover vs Square Fees at Published Rates
Square's rates come from Square's POS pricing page. Square's keyed rate comes from KORONA POS's Square fee breakdown. Clover's rates come from QuickSync's line-by-line check of Clover.com pricing and Payment Processing Guide.
| How the card is taken | Square Free ($0/mo) | Square Plus ($49/mo) | Square Premium ($149/mo) | Clover.com |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tap, dip or swipe | 2.6% + 15¢ | 2.5% + 15¢ | 2.4% + 15¢ | 2.3% to 2.6% + 10¢, by plan |
| Online | 3.3% + 30¢ | 2.9% + 30¢ | 2.9% + 30¢ | 3.5% + 10¢ (card typed in) |
| Keyed or card on file | 3.5% + 15¢ | 3.5% + 15¢ | 3.5% + 15¢ | 3.5% + 10¢ |
On Clover.com, the 2.3% in-person rate comes with the Retail Growth and Restaurant Growth plans, and the Starter plan carries 2.6%. Square's monthly plan fees apply to each location. Square doesn't price by card type, so a basic debit card costs you the same as a premium rewards card. That makes the bill easy to predict. It also means your cheap cards subsidize your expensive ones. According to Square's online store plans page, sellers who process more than $250,000 a year can ask whether they qualify for custom pricing.
A common mistake is reading "Clover's rates" in a review and assuming they apply to every Clover merchant. They are Clover.com's prices. A reseller can quote interchange-plus, which passes through the card networks' actual interchange and assessment costs and adds a disclosed markup, so you can see what the seller earns. It can also quote tiered pricing, which sorts cards into buckets like "qualified" and "non-qualified" and hides the markup inside them. Two merchants with the same Clover Flex can pay very different amounts. Our guide to reading a merchant statement line by line shows how to tell which pricing model you're on.
Worked Example: The Volume Where Clover Starts Costing Less
Take a retail shop where every sale is tapped or dipped in person. Here are the assumptions:
- The average ticket is $25 (illustrative). That makes $10,000 a month 400 sales and $40,000 a month 1,600 sales.
- Square and Clover.com are priced at the published rates above. Clover.com's software is the $84.95 Retail Growth plan. Hardware is left out.
- Reseller A is an illustrative interchange-plus quote. Network costs average 1.8% of volume (your real figure depends on your card mix), the markup is 0.25% + 10¢ per sale, software is $84.95, and account fees are $15 a month.
- Reseller B is an illustrative flat-rate quote of 2.9% + 10¢, with software at $84.95.
| Monthly in-person sales | Square Free | Square Plus | Clover.com | Reseller A | Reseller B |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $10,000 | $320.00 | $359.00 | $354.95 | $344.95 | $414.95 |
| $40,000 | $1,280.00 | $1,289.00 | $1,164.95 | $1,079.95 | $1,404.95 |
At $10,000 a month, Square Free costs least. With a $25 ticket, its rate works out to 3.2% of sales once the 15¢ is counted, against 2.7% for Clover.com, so the half-point gap covers the $84.95 software fee only at about $17,000 a month. Square Free is a fair comparison only if its features cover your needs. Square says advanced inventory, loyalty and staff management come with Plus, in Square's announcement of its unified plans. Measured against Plus, Clover.com breaks even at about $9,000 a month.
At $40,000, Clover.com saves $124.05 a month compared with Square Plus. A good reseller quote saves another $85. Reseller B runs the same hardware and costs $115.95 more than Square Plus. The device didn't change. The seller did.
Ticket size moves these crossovers because Clover's per-sale fee is 5¢ lower. If you redo the Square Free comparison with a $10 average ticket, the crossover drops to about $10,600 a month. With a $60 ticket, it rises to about $22,200. Coffee shops and convenience stores feel the 5¢. Furniture stores barely notice it.
To test a quote of your own, add the per-sale fee divided by your average ticket to the percentage rate. That gives you an all-in rate for each option. Then divide the difference in monthly fixed fees by the gap between the two all-in rates. The result is the monthly volume where the two cost the same. If a reseller's all-in rate isn't below Clover.com's published price, the quote has to earn its keep some other way, such as through service, funding speed or contract terms. For where these lines fall at other volumes, see the best credit card processing by sales volume.
Cost programs change the math again. Cash discount and dual pricing programs give cash-paying customers a lower price. Surcharging adds a fee to card payments, and both card network rules and state law govern it. Treat this as general information and confirm with a qualified professional before you set one up. MannyPay offers zero cost processing for eligible merchants. Whoever sells you a system, confirm that the device and software plan support the program you want.
Hardware Prices, Lock-In and the Lease Trap
According to Square's Register page, Square sells Register for $899 (or $44 a month for 24 months), Handheld for $399 and Terminal for $299. Fit Small Business's Square hardware comparison lists the contactless and chip reader at $59. On Clover.com, according to QuickSync, Flex costs $749, Mini $849 and Station Duo $1,899. Retailpresso's review of Clover's pricing pages notes that buying a device outright on Clover.com doesn't require a term. It also notes that Clover's $450 statement credit requires a three-year contract and that hardware subscriptions can't be cancelled during their term.
You can't move either system to another processor. Square hardware runs on Square, and Clover devices board to Fiserv, as BMC POS's Clover review notes. Switching between Clover resellers is a separate issue. The device usually has to be released from your old account before a new seller can set it up, so ask before assuming it comes with you.
Some resellers bundle Clover with a third-party equipment lease. These leases are typically non-cancellable and keep billing after the merchant account closes. As an illustration, a 48-month lease at $69 a month comes to $3,312 for a Mini that Clover.com sells for $849. Before you sign anything with "lease" on it, run the numbers in terminal lease vs. buy over four years.
Software, Apps and Contract Terms
Square bills Plus and Premium per location. Paid plans add POS modes built for quick-service restaurants, bars, salons and retailers, and Premium adds 24/7 phone support and advanced reporting. No reseller sits in between to mark those prices up. On Clover, the seller sets or marks up the software plan. Paid apps from the Clover App Market, for jobs like loyalty or scheduling, bill monthly through your account. Our Clover POS review of devices, plans and hidden costs lists the line items to total up.
Square's Free plan has no monthly fee, and TransferFees' Square fee summary reports no cancellation fee on it. Hardware financing has its own terms. Clover agreements from resellers range from month-to-month to multi-year terms that renew automatically and charge an early termination fee. The worst ones add liquidated damages based on the processing you would have done through the end of the term. For the full tradeoff, see month-to-month vs. long-term processing contracts. Export your item library and customer list from your current system now, while nothing depends on it, because sales history doesn't always transfer cleanly.
Which System Fits Retail, Restaurants and Salons
A low rate won't make up for a system that slows your staff during the rush. Check fit before you compare price.
Retail: Catalog Depth and Steady Volume
A shoe store tracks every size and color, and a gift shop needs barcode counts that match the stockroom. Ask whether purchase orders and vendor management are included in the plan you're quoted or sold as an add-on. A retailer with steady in-person volume sits on the side of the worked example where a well-priced Clover quote wins. See our retail processing setups.
Restaurants and Bars: Speed at Peak
Servers need pay-at-table and tip adjustments after the guest signs. Bars keep tabs open all night, and kitchen tickets have to reach the line without a runner. On Clover, that usually means a countertop Clover Duo paired with Clover Flex 4G handhelds. Ask either provider how tips are adjusted after a batch closes. More on our restaurant and bar processing page.
Salons and Spas: Booking First
Salons need calendars for each stylist, deposits or a card on file so the no-show policy holds up, and tips that split when two people serve one client. Square includes appointment tools in its own plans. On Clover, booking may mean an App Market app, so price the app along with the plan. See processing for salons and spas.
Get These Answers in Writing Before You Sign
- What is my pricing model, and what exactly is the markup over interchange?
- Which monthly fees apply (PCI, statement, account), and what does each cost?
- What does software cost per location and per device, and can it rise during the term?
- Do I own the hardware outright? If it's leased, what is the total over the full term?
- How long is the contract, does it auto-renew, and what does leaving early cost?
- Will this hardware work if I switch providers?
- When are funds deposited, and under what conditions can they be held?
Square answers most of these on its public pages. For Clover, the answers are in your seller's agreement, which means choosing the reseller is the real decision. If you want a Clover quote to compare line by line against your Square statement, request a free quote from MannyPay and attach a recent statement. A specialist responds within one business day.
Sources
- Square POS Software Pricing & Plans
- Square Processing Fees, Plans, and Software Pricing
- Square Simplifies Commerce Software with New Unified Plans & Pricing
- Square Online Store Pricing & Plans
- Square Register
- Fit Small Business: Square Hardware Comparison
- KORONA POS: Square Transaction Fees by Plan
- TransferFees: Square Fee Calculator
- QuickSync: Clover Fees and Pricing
- Retailpresso: Clover Pricing 2026
- Payment Processing Guide: Clover Review
- Orbix Payments: How Much Does Clover Cost?
- BMC POS: Clover POS Review
This article is for general educational purposes and is not legal, tax or financial advice. Card network rules and state laws change; confirm current requirements for your business.

