NYDFS Issues New Crypto Ad Guidance: A Marketing Checklist
NYDFS virtual currency advertising guidance sets a May 10, 2027 deadline. Use this checklist to fix crypto ads, influencer posts and disclosures.

Photo: Pixabay
On this page 7 sections
- What the NYDFS Virtual Currency Advertising Guidance Requires
- Who the BitLicense Marketing Rules Reach Beyond the Licensee
- Claims That Draw Scrutiny: Returns, Safety, Insurance and "Free"
- Influencers and Affiliates: The Licensed Firm Answers for Its Promoters
- Merchants Promoting Crypto Checkout or Rewards: Where the Risk Starts
- Why Crypto Ad Compliance Problems Become Payment Account Problems
- Virtual Currency Advertising Requirements: A Pre-Campaign Checklist
Key takeaways
- Licensed firms have until May 10, 2027, to update their ad policies. The 200.18 rules on the legend, keeping records for seven years and banning deceptive ads already cover ads that are running now.
- Content a partner posts on a licensed firm's behalf counts as the firm's marketing, even if it's labeled "education." Expect pre-approval and takedown terms in affiliate contracts.
- A "no fee" claim has to account for spreads and network costs. Meeting the FTC's paid-endorsement disclosure rules doesn't meet DFS's accuracy standard.
- A merchant that buys or holds crypto to pay customer rewards may be doing licensable activity. Check with counsel before launch.
On November 12, 2026, the New York State Department of Financial Services (DFS) told licensed crypto firms to back up every advertising claim, name the regulated company behind each promotion, vet the influencers and affiliates who market for them, and put all of it through a formal review process. The NYDFS virtual currency advertising guidance gives firms until May 10, 2027, to update their policies. It doesn't create a new ban. It explains how DFS expects firms to meet an advertising rule in force since 2015, and DFS will check those policies in exams.
If you hold a BitLicense, this is a compliance project with a deadline. If you're a merchant, affiliate or creator promoting a licensed firm's crypto checkout, card or rewards to New Yorkers, expect that firm to start reading your posts before they go live.
What the NYDFS Virtual Currency Advertising Guidance Requires
The industry letter, Guidance on Advertising and Marketing, is signed by Acting Superintendent Kaitlin Asrow. It goes to two groups: companies licensed under 23 NYCRR Part 200 (BitLicensees) and limited purpose trust companies chartered under the New York Banking Law to do virtual currency business. DFS calls them virtual currency entities, or VCEs.
The DFS announcement sorts its expectations into three areas. Content must be evidence-based and verifiable, with no exaggerated or false statements about performance or regulatory status, and the ad must clearly identify the VCE offering the product. Disclosures must be clear, prominent and easy for a general audience to understand. Governance means a review process for marketing, named people responsible for it, due diligence on third-party promoters, and quick action against misuse of the firm's name or brand. Firms must review their policies at least once a year and keep records for DFS, including the evidence behind each factual claim and a copy of every approval.
The rule underneath, 23 NYCRR 200.18, already asks a lot. A licensee's ads in New York or aimed at New Yorkers must carry its name and the legend "Licensed to engage in Virtual Currency Business Activity by the New York State Department of Financial Services." Ad materials must be kept for at least seven years, including website captures of material changes. Ads must meet federal and state disclosure laws. And neither the licensee nor "any person or entity acting on its behalf" may make false, misleading or deceptive representations or omissions. Promoters should read that last phrase twice.
Who the BitLicense Marketing Rules Reach Beyond the Licensee
The letter applies to VCEs directly and reaches everyone else through them. DFS defines covered "Materials" as content produced or distributed by a VCE or on its behalf that could reasonably be seen as promoting its virtual currency products. The label doesn't matter (the letter gives "call to action," "fee comparison" and "education" as examples), and neither does the channel.
So a sponsored "explainer" video that ends with a referral link is marketing, and the exchange paying for it owns the content. A post that an affiliate, influencer or co-marketing merchant publishes on the firm's behalf counts as the firm's material, which means the firm will want to approve it.
A shop that simply accepts crypto through a licensed processor is generally not a VCE. That changes once the business starts handling the coins itself. DFS's licensing page lists activities that require a BitLicense. They include receiving virtual currency to transmit it, holding it in custody for others, and buying and selling it as a customer business. If a rewards program has you buying crypto and holding it for customers, talk to counsel before launch. Our explainer on the New York BitLicense and taking customer payments covers where that line sits.
Claims That Draw Scrutiny: Returns, Safety, Insurance and "Free"
Returns. A hypothetical "Earn up to 8%" is a performance claim. The firm needs evidence on file, and the conditions behind the top rate (lockups, tiers, variable rates) belong next to the number, not in a footer.
Fees. The Block reported that DFS warned against claiming no trading fees while leaving out other costs. In crypto the cost often sits in the spread (the gap between the customer's price and the market price) or in network and conversion charges. A "zero-fee" headline over a wide spread is the pattern DFS describes. We covered the merchant side of this in what happens when a free bitcoin payments promo ends.
Regulatory status. The legend states one fact: the firm holds a license. It doesn't mean New York endorses a coin or guarantees the company, so "state-approved" or "backed by New York" overstates regulatory status.
Insurance. The parts of the guidance we reviewed don't single out insurance. But a claim about insurance is a claim about safety and status, so the evidence standard applies. Federal deposit insurance protects deposits at insured banks, and holding crypto doesn't make it a bank deposit. If a custodian carries a theft policy, say what it covers and who holds it, or leave it out.
Our editors wrote the examples below to show the pattern. They're illustrative and don't come from DFS.
| Risky phrasing | Problem | Safer direction |
|---|---|---|
| "Trade crypto with zero fees" | Leaves out spread and network costs | "No commission; prices include a spread. See fee schedule." |
| "Earn 8% on your bitcoin" | Rate without conditions | State the range, the conditions and that rates change |
| "Licensed and approved by New York" | Overstates what a license means | Use the exact 200.18 legend, nothing more |
| "Your crypto is fully insured" | Unsupported safety claim | Name the policy type, insurer and limits, or drop it |
Influencers and Affiliates: The Licensed Firm Answers for Its Promoters
DFS expects VCEs to run due diligence on third-party promoters and watch for brand misuse. Coincub's coverage also highlights paid testimonials that hide compensation. The licensed firm answers for what its paid promoters say.
A federal rule set also applies to every brand and creator, crypto or not. Under the FTC's Endorsement Guides (16 CFR Part 255), a material connection between an endorser and a marketer must be disclosed clearly and conspicuously. That includes payment, free products, or a family or business relationship. FTC staff have told brands the disclosure belongs above the "more" button, and that marketers should brief endorsers and monitor their posts.
That gives a crypto influencer campaign aimed at New York two tests to pass. The FTC asks whether the audience knows the creator is paid. DFS asks whether what the creator says is true, supported, properly disclosed and approved by the licensed firm. Passing the first doesn't cover the second.
Affiliates should expect contract changes before May 10, 2027: pre-approved scripts, required disclosures, takedown rights and record requests. That's our reading of how firms will meet the due diligence expectation, not text from the letter. Brand monitoring cuts both ways, too. A firm hunting impostors will flag look-alike landing pages and "official" handles run by affiliates first.
Merchants Promoting Crypto Checkout or Rewards: Where the Risk Starts
A line like "We accept bitcoin and USDC through [Provider]" is low risk. The risk rises when your marketing describes the provider's product, promises rewards paid in crypto, runs co-branded campaigns or earns a bounty for each wallet signup. At that point you may be producing content on a licensed firm's behalf.
Worked example (illustrative). Assume an online apparel store that ships to New York and accepts crypto through a BitLicensed payment provider. Its draft banner reads: "Pay with crypto: no fees, plus 5% back in bitcoin." A review would flag three things:
- "No fees" for whom? The store may pay the provider little, but the shopper can still pay a network fee or a conversion spread. The claim leaves out costs.
- "5% back in bitcoin" leaves open who funds the reward, who holds the bitcoin and what happens when its value drops. If the store buys and holds bitcoin for customers, the licensing question above applies.
- The ad doesn't name the provider, so the licensed firm isn't identified.
A safer version: "Pay with crypto through [Provider]. Network or conversion costs may apply; see [Provider]'s fee page. Get a reward worth 5% of your order, credited in bitcoin by [Provider]. Bitcoin's value changes, so your reward may be worth less later." The store sends this to the provider's marketing review and keeps the approval email. It shouldn't add the DFS legend in its own name, because the store holds no license.
Why Crypto Ad Compliance Problems Become Payment Account Problems
Processors underwrite a business based on what it sells and how it sells it. Your website, offers and ads are part of that file at onboarding and afterward. Crypto-related businesses are commonly treated as high risk, so their marketing gets a closer look than a typical e-commerce store would.
Misleading claims show up in payment data. A shopper who was promised "no fees" and then finds a spread files a "not as described" dispute. Complaints pile up. If a licensed partner drops a noncompliant affiliate, a merchant can lose its crypto checkout overnight. Any of these can lead a processor to impose a reserve, tighten limits or close the account.
The file DFS wants (substantiation, approvals, partner due diligence, dated captures of every ad) is also what a careful underwriter asks for. If you run a crypto-adjacent business and need a processor that underwrites high-risk merchant accounts, bring that file to the application. Before you sign with a crypto payment partner, read how to vet a crypto payment partner.
Virtual Currency Advertising Requirements: A Pre-Campaign Checklist
The items that come from 200.18 or the letter apply directly to licensed firms. For merchants and affiliates, they preview what your licensed partner will likely require. This is general information, not legal advice; confirm specifics with counsel who knows DFS rules.
- Confirm which company holds the license and make sure the ad names it.
- If you're the licensee, use the exact 200.18 legend without embellishment.
- File evidence for every factual claim (rates, fees, speed, security) before launch.
- Put the costs a "no fee" claim leaves out right beside it.
- Show the conditions for any rate or reward next to the number.
- Cut "approved," "backed" or "insured" language you can't document.
- Get written approval from the person named in the policy, and keep it.
- Require paid creators to disclose the relationship in the post itself.
- Capture every ad and material website change with a date, and keep the captures at least seven years.
- Ask your processor whether the campaign changes your underwriting file.
Run items 1 through 3 on the ads already running, not just the next campaign. The May 10, 2027, date applies to policies, but 200.18 has applied to live ads since 2015. Then watch DFS industry letters and enforcement actions for the first case that applies this guidance to an influencer or affiliate. It will show how far "on its behalf" reaches. When you're ready to review your processing setup, a MannyPay specialist responds to free quote requests within one business day.
Sources
- NYDFS Industry Letter, November 12, 2026: Guidance on Advertising and Marketing
- NYDFS Industry Letters index (Virtual Currency)
- NYDFS Virtual Currency Business Licensing
- 23 NYCRR § 200.18, Advertising and Marketing (Cornell LII)
- NYDFS issues virtual currency advertising guidance (Finextra, DFS press release)
- New York State DFS issues new guidance regarding crypto advertising (FX News Group)
- New York sets May deadline for crypto firms to update advertising policies (FingerLakes1)
- NYDFS sets fresh advertising standards for crypto firms (The Block)
- New York Regulator Sets May 2027 Deadline for Crypto Advertising Rules (Coincub)
- New York DFS Sets May 10, 2027, Deadline for Crypto Marketing Policies (TokenPost)
- FTC Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials, 16 CFR Part 255 (2023)
- FTC staff letter to brands on influencer disclosures
This article is for general educational purposes and is not legal, tax or financial advice. Card network rules and state laws change; confirm current requirements for your business.


