Texas Credit Card Surcharge Law: What Merchants Can Do
Local Payment Guides

Texas Credit Card Surcharge Law: Can You Pass on Card Fees?

Texas credit card surcharge law explained: what the ban covers after Rowell, how cash discounts work, and sample signs and invoice language that comply.

Red vintage convertible parked inside a clean auto repair garage with blue tool cabinets, hoses and a roll-up door

Photo: Pixabay

On this page 6 sections
  1. Texas Credit Card Surcharge Law: Finance Code 339.001 and Its New Home
  2. The Rowell Litigation and What It Changed
  3. Is Surcharging Legal in Texas? Surcharge vs. Cash Discount Compared
  4. Card Network Caps and Notice Requirements Still Apply
  5. Card Fees for Texas Contractors, Plumbers and Auto Shops
  6. Sample Signage and Invoice Language for Texas Merchants

Key takeaways

  • Texas moved its surcharge ban from Finance Code §339.001 to Business and Commerce Code §604A.0021 in 2017 and has not repealed it.
  • The Rowell case ended with an injunction that protects the merchants who sued. Secondary sources report that the attorney general treats it as limited to them.
  • Texas's regulator said cash discounts, dual pricing and fees charged the same way on every payment method fall outside the ban, so they are the lower-risk routes.
  • Work out any discount percentage from the posted card price so the sign, invoice and receipt all match. Any surcharge still has to meet Visa's rules (credit only, the lower of your cost or 3%, 30 days' notice) and Mastercard's 4% cap.

Texas credit card surcharge law still says a seller may not add a surcharge when a buyer pays with a credit card instead of cash or a check. The rule began as Texas Finance Code §339.001 and since 2017 has been in the Business and Commerce Code at §604A.0021.

A federal First Amendment challenge, Rowell v. Pettijohn, went to the U.S. Supreme Court and back, but we found no record that the legislature repealed the ban. That makes a cash discount or dual pricing program the lowest-risk way for a Texas business to pass on card costs. Texas's own regulator has said the statute does not prohibit them.

Surcharging carries state-law risk, and card network rules apply whichever route you pick.

This is general information as of November 2026, not legal advice. Confirm your setup with a Texas attorney before you change how you price.

Texas Credit Card Surcharge Law: Finance Code 339.001 and Its New Home

The key sentence reads: "In a sale of goods or services, a seller may not impose a surcharge on a buyer who uses a credit card for an extension of credit instead of cash, a check, or a similar means of payment." That is the text the Fifth Circuit quoted in 2016.

Two things trip up merchants who search for "Texas Finance Code 339.001" today.

First, the section moved. In 2017 the legislature passed SB 560. According to the Senate bill analysis, the bill moved §339.001 to the Business and Commerce Code as §604A.0021 and added a definition of "credit card." It also redefined "surcharge" and took enforcement away from the Office of Consumer Credit Commissioner (OCCC). The attorney general's 2019 Opinion KP-0257 quotes the same ban under its new number, "with limited exceptions." Government bodies that collect fees and taxes fall under separate provisions. That is why a county can be allowed to add a card fee that a private seller can't.

Second, the statute bans a surcharge, not a price difference. A 2018 NACM presentation on credit card fees summarizes the amended definition: a surcharge does not include a discounted price charged to a buyer who pays with cash. Before the move, the OCCC's Advisory Bulletin B15-2 (June 25, 2015) spelled out what that means in practice. A surcharge raises the regular price, and a discount lowers it. Discounts for paying by cash, check or debit card are allowed. So is a convenience or service fee charged the same way on every payment method. The bulletin traces that conclusion to Attorney General Opinion GA-0951 (2012).

One more detail matters if you sell to other businesses. A 2011 OCCC interpretation read the legislative history as aiming the ban at "credit card transactions." The Finance Code defines that term around personal, family or household purposes. Whether that reading survived the 2017 rewrite is a question for your lawyer. Don't build your pricing on it.

The Rowell Litigation and What It Changed

In March 2014 a group of Texas merchants sued the OCCC commissioner and the attorney general in federal court in Austin, arguing that the ban violated the First Amendment. The plaintiffs, among them a landscaper and a self-storage facility, made a simple argument. Texas let them charge card users more than cash payers as long as they called the difference a cash discount, but punished them for calling the same gap a credit card surcharge. That, they said, regulates speech.

The case moved through four stages:

  1. District court, 2014–2015. The Western District of Texas dismissed the complaint.
  2. Fifth Circuit, 2016. In Rowell v. Pettijohn, 816 F.3d 73, the court affirmed. It held that the law regulates conduct (prices), not speech.
  3. Supreme Court, 2017. On April 3, 2017, the Court granted review, vacated the Fifth Circuit's decision and sent the case back in light of Expressions Hair Design v. Schneiderman, decided days earlier. In Expressions, the Court held that New York's similar law regulated how merchants communicate prices, and that is speech.
  4. Remand, 2017–2018. On May 25, 2017, the Fifth Circuit sent the case back to the district court. A 2018 article from the law firm Hoover Slovacek reports that the Austin court then found the law restricted speech. The court entered a permanent injunction barring enforcement against the merchants who brought the case.

Most summaries blur what happened next. An injunction protects only the parties to the case. Secondary sources, including Merchant Cost Consulting's roundup of state surcharge laws, report that the Texas attorney general later said the ruling applied only to those plaintiffs and that the statute can still be enforced against everyone else. While researching this article we found no reported enforcement action against a Texas merchant for surcharging since the ruling. We also found no repeal. A lack of enforcement is not permission, and a lawyer suing you or a future attorney general would point to a law that is still on the books.

For a Texas business, the choice comes down to three setups. State law and network rules treat each one differently.

Credit card surchargeCash discount or dual pricingUniform convenience fee
Texas statuteThe text prohibits it; Rowell may not protect merchants who weren't partiesOCCC Bulletin B15-2 says discounts are not surchargesAllowed by Bulletin B15-2 if charged on every payment method
Debit cardsCannot be surcharged under Visa rulesDebit payers can get the discountSame fee for everyone
Network capVisa: lower of your credit cost or 3%; Mastercard: 4%No surcharge cap applies to a discountSeparate network convenience-fee rules
Advance notice30 days to your acquirer (Visa)Check your processor agreementCheck your processor agreement

Here is how the first two options work on a real job. The numbers are illustrative.

Assumptions: a plumbing company's usual price for a water heater replacement is $1,200. Its effective processing cost on credit cards is 2.9%. That figure is illustrative, not a quote; your real rate is on your statement. The customer pays with a Visa credit card.

  • Surcharge model. The invoice shows $1,200 plus a 2.9% surcharge of $34.80, for a total of $1,234.80. Processing at 2.9% on the full amount costs $35.81, so the company nets $1,198.99. The surcharge itself carries a processing fee, so the company comes up about a dollar short. If the customer had paid by debit, the company could not have added any surcharge.
  • Cash discount model. The posted card price is $1,236.00. Customers who pay by cash, check or debit get 2.9% off that posted price, which is $35.84, so they pay $1,200.16. The card payer pays $1,236.00. Processing at 2.9% costs $35.84, and the company nets $1,200.16. The business keeps the same amount whichever way the customer pays.

Note where the percentage comes from. The discount is figured from the posted card price, because that is the price the customer sees. If you advertise "2.9% off," the dollar amount on the invoice and receipt has to equal 2.9% of the price you posted. A common mistake is to work the percentage off the cash price and then advertise it as a discount off the card price. The difference is small, but then your sign promises something your receipt doesn't deliver.

The card customer pays about the same under either model. What changes is the label, and in Texas the label is what the statute targets. That is the main reason a Texas cash discount program or dual pricing is the safer legal choice here. For more on the trade-offs, see our comparison of surcharging vs. cash discount vs. dual pricing.

Card Network Caps and Notice Requirements Still Apply

State law is only one layer. Your processing agreement also binds you to Visa, Mastercard, Discover and American Express rules, and those apply in Texas the same as anywhere else.

Visa's U.S. Merchant Surcharge Q&A lists the requirements for any merchant that surcharges:

  • Notify your acquirer at least 30 days before you start.
  • Surcharge credit cards only. Debit and prepaid cards are excluded.
  • Keep the surcharge at or below your merchant discount rate for that card or 3%, whichever is lower.
  • Disclose it at the point of entry, at the point of sale and on every receipt, both in store and online.
  • Send the amount in a dedicated data field (Field 28), which your processor sets up.

According to an ArentFox Schiff alert, Visa cut its cap from 4% to 3% effective April 15, 2023. The same alert says Mastercard's cap stayed at 4%. It also describes Visa's fines for breaking the rules, which start at $1,000 with a request for a plan to fix the problem and reach $50,000 if violations continue. Mastercard and Discover also expect 30 days' notice, and Mastercard wants to be notified directly. Mastercard's 4% cap does not let you charge 4% on Visa cards. Neither cap lets you charge more than your actual cost.

Cash discount programs fall outside the surcharge cap because nothing is added to the card price. They still need honest posted prices and clear signs, and processors that run them usually set their own disclosure rules. If you do surcharge, our walkthrough on setting up credit card surcharging on your POS covers the terminal side.

Card Fees for Texas Contractors, Plumbers and Auto Shops

Trades get paid differently from a retail counter, and that changes how a card fee program has to work.

Keyed and invoice payments. A plumber who takes a card number over the phone or types it into a virtual terminal pays card-not-present rates, which are higher than the rates for a tapped card. Our breakdown of what keyed transactions cost and why processors watch them explains why that matters for your effective rate. Base any discount or surcharge on your average rate across all the ways you take cards, not your cheapest one. A surcharge still can't go past the network cap.

Telling debit from credit. Visa forbids surcharging debit. A field tech can't tell a debit card from a credit card by looking at it, and neither can a customer typing into a payment link. Any surcharge program needs software that reads the card's BIN (the first digits of the card number) and adds the fee only to credit cards. A cash discount avoids the problem, because every card pays the posted price.

The invoice is the point of entry. On a job billed after the work is done, the customer first sees your payment terms on the estimate or invoice. Put the card price, the discount and the accepted payment methods there, not just on the payment page. Our guide to contractor invoicing for deposits, draws and card fees shows where those lines go.

Auto repair. The customer often pays hours after drop-off, at pickup. That makes the repair order they sign at drop-off the natural place to disclose card pricing. Repeat it on the counter sign and the final invoice.

Retail stores. Shelf tags and register screens do most of the work. Under dual pricing, both prices show. Under a cash discount, the tag shows the card price and a counter sign explains the discount.

Commercial customers. If you invoice general contractors or property managers, read our guide to passing card fees on B2B invoices. Ask your lawyer about the consumer-purpose question above before you treat those invoices differently.

Sample Signage and Invoice Language for Texas Merchants

These are starting points. Every sample below uses the illustrative 2.9% discount from the worked example, figured off the posted card price. If your cost is different, change the percentage everywhere at once so the signs, invoices and receipts agree. Have your attorney and processor review the final wording.

Cash discount, door or counter sign:

Our posted prices are our card prices. Pay with cash, check or debit card and receive 2.9% off the posted price at checkout.

Dual pricing, shelf tag or menu:

Cash/Debit $48.55 · Card $50.00

Cash discount, invoice line items:

Invoice lineAmount
Invoice total (card price)$1,236.00
2.9% discount for payment by cash, check, debit or ACH−$35.84
Total if paid by cash, check, debit or ACH$1,200.16

Online checkout or payment link:

Prices shown are card prices. Pay by bank transfer or debit card to receive 2.9% off the price shown.

Receipt line, cash discount:

Cash discount applied (2.9%): −$35.84

If your attorney approves surcharging: Visa's Q&A requires you to disclose the fee as a merchant fee on credit cards only. The notice has to appear at the point of entry (your door or first checkout page), at the point of sale and on every receipt. "Surcharge" is the exact word the Texas statute uses, so this is the wording to clear with your lawyer first.

Start by pulling your last three processing statements, working out what you actually pay on credit cards and using that number to set your discount. MannyPay offers cash discount, dual pricing and zero cost processing programs, plus surcharging where permitted. A specialist answers free quote requests within one business day. After that, watch two things: whether the Texas Legislature rewrites §604A.0021, and whether the attorney general ever enforces it against a merchant who wasn't a Rowell plaintiff.

Sources

  1. Texas OCCC Advisory Bulletin B15-2: Credit Card Surcharge Alternatives (June 25, 2015)
  2. Texas OCCC Interpretation 2011-01
  3. Rowell v. Pettijohn, No. 15-50168 (5th Cir. 2016)
  4. Rowell v. Pettijohn, On Remand From the Supreme Court (5th Cir. May 25, 2017)
  5. Supreme Court Remands Texas Credit Card Surcharge Case (Lexology/InfoBytes)
  6. Bill Analysis, SB 560, 85th Texas Legislature
  7. Texas Attorney General Opinion KP-0257 (June 14, 2019)
  8. NACM: Credit Card Surcharging and Other Fees (Aug. 21, 2018)
  9. Hoover Slovacek: The Court Says Yes (Oct. 2018)
  10. Merchant Cost Consulting: Credit Card Surcharge Laws by State
  11. Visa: U.S. Merchant Surcharge Q and A
  12. ArentFox Schiff: Visa Reduces Its Merchant Surcharge Cap to 3% Effective April 15, 2023
  13. Tagada: Credit Card Surcharge Rules, Caps and State Laws (Mastercard notice requirement)
  14. FedLaws: Card Network Surcharge Rules (Discover notice requirement)

About the author

Adrian Reyes

Adrian Reyes is Senior Payments & Fintech Editor for Beyond the Swipe, covering credit card processing, merchant accounts, payment technology and processing fees.

This article is for general educational purposes and is not legal, tax or financial advice. Card network rules and state laws change; confirm current requirements for your business.

Related reading