PayPal Alternatives for Business: What to Move and Keep
Merchant Education & Growth

PayPal Alternatives for Business: Cutting Fees and Hold Risk

PayPal alternatives for business, explained: move card processing and invoicing to a merchant account and keep PayPal as a checkout button.

Three 500 euro banknotes tucked into the back pocket of blue denim jeans

Photo: Pixabay

On this page 7 sections
  1. The Jobs PayPal Alternatives for Business Need to Cover
  2. Where PayPal Costs More Than It Should
  3. Fund Holds and Limitations: Why a Merchant Account Is Steadier
  4. Card Processing: The PayPal Alternative for an Online Store
  5. An Alternative to PayPal for Invoicing Clients
  6. Keeping the PayPal Button Without Running Everything Through It
  7. How to Leave PayPal Business Processing Without Losing Repeat Buyers

Key takeaways

  • Move card processing and invoicing off PayPal first. The buyer wallet is hard to replace and easy to keep as a button.
  • Divide a full year of PayPal fees by a full year of volume to get your effective rate, then compare quotes against it in dollars.
  • If you want card sales to settle through your own merchant account, turn off the card option under the PayPal button.
  • Subscriptions tied to customers' PayPal accounts generally can't be moved, so either let them run or collect fresh consent.

The best PayPal alternatives for business take over the jobs where PayPal costs the most, which are usually card processing and client invoicing. PayPal stays on your checkout page as one button among several. For most online stores and service firms, that means a merchant account and payment gateway for cards, with invoices sent from your accounting software. Shoppers who like their PayPal wallet can keep using it, but PayPal no longer prices or holds every dollar you take in.

Leaving PayPal completely is rarely the smart goal. The real decisions are which pieces to move first and what to check before you move them.

The Jobs PayPal Alternatives for Business Need to Cover

One PayPal business account does several different jobs, and most competitors handle some of those jobs better than others.

The first job is the buyer wallet. Many consumers keep a card or bank account saved in PayPal, so they can check out by logging in instead of typing a card number. Mobile shoppers like skipping the form. Some international buyers would also rather not hand their card details to a store they don't know. That convenience belongs to the customer who set it up, and no merchant account can recreate it.

The second job is card processing. When a shopper pays by card through PayPal's checkout, PayPal is acting as your processor. Your business sits as a sub-merchant under PayPal's own master account, an arrangement the industry calls a payment facilitator model. Setup is fast because most of the risk review happens after you start selling.

The third job is invoicing. PayPal invoices let a client pay from a PayPal balance or by card, and the fees come from the same flat-rate schedule as everything else.

Card processing and invoicing are commodity services that many providers offer under many pricing models. The wallet is different because your customers picked it for themselves. That difference sets the plan: move the commodity work to a provider that prices it better for your business, and keep the wallet where buyers expect to find it.

Where PayPal Costs More Than It Should

PayPal publishes its own U.S. merchant fee schedule. Those rates are PayPal's pricing, not card network rules. They follow a flat-rate model, which means a percentage of each sale plus a fixed per-transaction fee. Rates differ by payment type, and international sales add a cross-border fee plus a margin on currency conversion. The figures change and vary by product, so check PayPal's current merchant fees page for the rates on your account.

Interchange sits underneath every card sale. It is the fee paid to the cardholder's bank at rates Visa and Mastercard set, and the networks charge their own assessment fees on top. Whoever processes your cards pays those costs. A flat rate folds them and the processor's margin into one number, so a low-cost debit card and a premium rewards card cost you the same percentage. Interchange-plus pricing passes through the actual interchange on each sale and adds a disclosed markup. Our explainer on basis points and what your processor markup really costs shows how to read that kind of quote.

Flat-rate pricing tends to cost the most in four situations:

  • Small tickets. Digital downloads and low-priced add-ons feel the fixed per-transaction fee hardest, because it takes a bigger bite out of a smaller sale.
  • Debit-heavy customers. Debit interchange generally runs below rewards credit interchange, yet a flat rate charges you as if every card were expensive.
  • International buyers. Cross-border fees and conversion spreads stack on top of the base rate. See how to receive international payments without giving up a big cut to fees.
  • Large invoices. A percentage fee on a full website build or a quarterly retainer adds up to real money. Clients paying that much are often happy to pay by bank transfer instead.

Work Out Your Effective Rate Before You Compare Quotes

Headline rates are the wrong thing to compare. Pull a full year of PayPal activity reports, add up every fee, and divide by total sales volume. The result is your effective rate. It captures costs a headline rate leaves out: international surcharges, conversion margins, fees on refunded sales and any chargeback fees. A full year also smooths out the seasonal swings a single month would hide.

Next, ask each provider you're considering to price that same statement line by line:

  • Estimated interchange and network fees for your actual card mix
  • The percentage markup and per-transaction fee on top
  • Monthly gateway and account fees
  • Any fee your e-commerce platform charges for using an outside gateway instead of its built-in payments
  • Chargeback fees and any early-termination clause

Compare the totals in dollars. A quote with a lower markup can still lose if its monthly fees are high and your volume is modest. A quote built on in-store interchange will look cheaper than it really is, because card-not-present sales carry higher interchange than cards tapped or dipped at a counter. If the dollar totals come out close, or if PayPal comes out ahead, that's a legitimate answer. Choose on account stability and support.

Fund Holds and Limitations: Why a Merchant Account Is Steadier

Fast approval has a cost. Because PayPal does most of its underwriting after you're live, it watches your activity and steps in when something looks unusual. Its user agreement describes when it may hold payments or limit an account while it reviews that activity, and it's worth reading the current version. The patterns that draw a second look are common in digital products and agency work: a large first invoice from a new account, a sudden jump in volume, preorders, or delivery that happens weeks after payment.

A traditional merchant account does that review before you start selling. The acquiring bank and processor look at your expected monthly volume, average and largest ticket, refund policy, fulfillment timeline and business history. They then set up the account around that profile. Get your banking in order before you apply. Our guide to what processors check on your business bank account lists the documents underwriters ask for.

Holds don't disappear with a merchant account. A processor may require a reserve at approval. The processing agreement also typically spells out when the processor can set or adjust a reserve later, for example if chargebacks rise or volume runs far past what you were approved for. What you gain is predictability.

Your risk is assessed up front against numbers you supplied, and the rules for later changes are written into an agreement you can read before signing. To get the most from that, give honest figures on the application, including your biggest realistic invoice and how long delivery takes. Deposits also land in your business bank account on a batch schedule instead of sitting in a balance you have to transfer out.

Card Processing: The PayPal Alternative for an Online Store

Replacing PayPal as your card processor takes two things. The first is a merchant account, which is your underwritten relationship with an acquiring bank. The second is a payment gateway such as Authorize.net or NMI, which passes card data from your checkout to the processor. The gateway connects to your store through a cart integration for Shopify, WooCommerce, BigCommerce, Magento or a similar platform. MannyPay's online payment processing works with those gateways and carts, and the payment gateway and integration options page shows what connects to what.

Checkout design affects both your security workload and your conversion rate. With a hosted payment page, card data never touches your site, which shrinks your PCI DSS scope. Embedded fields keep the buyer on your own page. Our comparison of hosted payment pages and embedded checkout covers the trade-offs. For riskier orders, 3-D Secure authentication can shift liability for some fraud chargebacks away from you.

Subscription sellers should expect underwriting to look hard at the billing model. Read up on getting approved for recurring billing before you apply.

What Switching Between PayPal Competitors Changes

Several well-known all-in-one processors use the same payment facilitator model with flat-rate pricing. Moving from PayPal to one of them can make sense for features or developer tools. The structure stays the same, though: fast onboarding with review after the fact, and one blended rate. If pricing and holds are why you're leaving, also get a quote for a dedicated merchant account. Our breakdown of Stripe fees beyond the headline rate shows how to read any flat-rate offer.

An Alternative to PayPal for Invoicing Clients

Agencies and consultants mostly get paid by invoice, so their replacement setup looks different from an e-commerce checkout.

A virtual terminal for keyed card payments lets you enter a client's card from any browser when they call in with payment details. Keyed sales count as card-not-present, so they are priced like online orders rather than like a card tapped at a counter. For most invoices, a cleaner setup is to send them from your accounting software with a payment link tied to your gateway. Depending on the software, each payment can then post back to the right invoice, instead of you matching PayPal deposits to open invoices by hand every month. MannyPay offers a QuickBooks integration, so ask how it fits your invoicing workflow before you switch.

Large invoices are where card fees hurt most, so offer ACH bank transfer alongside cards. Our comparison of ACH and credit card fees on invoices shows where the savings start. Some B2B firms also add a surcharge on card payments where permitted. Card network rules and state law both apply to surcharging. This is general information, not legal advice, so confirm the requirements for every state you bill into before adding a fee.

MannyPay's merchant platform is growing to include text-to-pay and payment links. Invoice links from your accounting software can do this job today. Studios and freelance designers can find setup details on our payment processing page for web design firms.

Keeping the PayPal Button Without Running Everything Through It

Most carts can show PayPal as its own payment method beside card fields that route to your gateway. Buyers who want their wallet click the button. Everyone else types in a card, and that sale settles through your merchant account. Four details decide whether this split works:

  • Wallet payments stay on PayPal's terms. PayPal-branded payments are still priced under PayPal's fee schedule and remain subject to its user agreement, including its hold and limitation provisions.
  • Disputes run in two places. Wallet disputes go through PayPal's resolution process, while card chargebacks come through your processor. Keep records for both.
  • The card option under the PayPal button is easy to miss. Some PayPal checkout integrations show a debit or credit card button beneath the PayPal button, and that option processes the card through PayPal. If you want card sales on your merchant account, turn it off in your PayPal button settings.
  • Your order split is worth checking after the first month. Once you see how much volume still arrives through the wallet, you know how much of your revenue still depends on PayPal's terms.

How to Leave PayPal Business Processing Without Losing Repeat Buyers

  1. Export a full year of PayPal reports. Pull total volume, fees, refunds, disputes and the split between wallet and card payments. That last figure shows how much volume can move.
  2. Apply before you need to. Underwriting takes time, and the middle of a PayPal limitation is the worst moment to start. Use these questions to ask a merchant service provider when you compare offers.
  3. Run both systems in parallel. Route cards to the new gateway while the PayPal button stays live. Test refunds and receipts before you change anything else.
  4. Treat subscriptions as a separate project. Subscriptions that customers set up through their own PayPal accounts live inside those accounts, and you generally can't transfer them to another processor. You can let them keep running in PayPal, or you can invite customers to re-subscribe with a card at renewal. Fresh sign-ups need fresh consent and disclosures that meet the automatic renewal laws in your customers' states. Check the specifics with a qualified attorney.
  5. Keep the PayPal account open. Leave enough of a balance there to cover refunds and disputes on past PayPal sales until the dispute window closes. Then update any old invoice templates and email footers that still point to PayPal.

Start with step one this week. Once you know your effective rate, request a free processing quote and include the statement. A MannyPay specialist responds within one business day, and you'll be comparing your real cost against a real offer.

About the author

Isabella Cruz

Isabella Cruz is Business Growth & Commerce Editor for Beyond the Swipe, writing for small businesses, restaurants, retailers, entertainment venues and e-commerce sellers.

This article is for general educational purposes and is not legal, tax or financial advice. Card network rules and state laws change; confirm current requirements for your business.

Related reading