Credit Card Processing Fees: What's Normal and What's Too High
Learn what normal credit card processing fees look like by card type and channel, how to find your real markup, and the signs you're overpaying.
Photo: Pixabay
On this page 7 sections
- The Three Layers of Every Credit Card Processing Fee
- Typical Credit Card Processing Rates by Card Type
- Why Online and Keyed Sales Cost More Than Tapped Ones
- Merchant Processing Fees You Should Expect Monthly and per Transaction
- Average Credit Card Processing Fees Are the Wrong Benchmark
- Warning Signs You're Overpaying
- Run the Markup Math on Your Last Statement
Credit card processing fees are normal when your processor's markup is small and clearly stated, and when your total cost fits the cards you take and how you take them. They're too high when the markup is hidden or creeping up, or when you pay fees that don't match any real network charge. No single percentage counts as normal for every business. Most of what you pay is set by the card networks and card-issuing banks and depends on the card and the channel, so the quickest way to judge any rate is to split it into its parts.
The Three Layers of Every Credit Card Processing Fee
Every card sale carries up to three kinds of cost.
Interchange goes to the bank that issued the customer's card. Visa and Mastercard publish interchange tables with hundreds of categories. A given sale's rate depends mostly on the card and how it was accepted, though your merchant category code and how it affects fees also play a part, along with the data sent with the transaction. Our explainer on how interchange fees are set covers the mechanics.
Card brand fees go to the network itself. They include assessments on your volume plus smaller per-transaction and program fees. These are smaller than interchange, and you can't negotiate them. Our guide to card brand assessments, FANF and network fees has the detail.
The processor's markup is everything else. It covers the percentage and per-item fee your processor adds, plus account charges such as monthly or gateway fees.
Interchange and card brand fees are set by the card networks and issuers, and on interchange-plus pricing they should pass through to you at cost. Your processor's markup is one company's pricing, and it's the only layer you can shop. On flat-rate and tiered plans, all three layers are blended into fewer numbers, which is why those statements are harder to judge.
Typical Credit Card Processing Rates by Card Type
Card type moves your interchange cost more than any other factor outside your control. From cheapest to most expensive, the general order looks like this:
- Regulated debit. Federal rules cap interchange on debit cards issued by large banks, so these are usually the cheapest cards you accept.
- Unregulated debit and prepaid. Debit cards from smaller banks and credit unions fall outside the federal cap and cost more.
- Standard consumer credit. These are basic credit cards with modest rewards or none.
- Rewards and premium credit. Higher interchange funds the cardholder's points and perks, and the merchant pays that cost.
- Business and corporate cards. These are usually the most expensive Visa and Mastercard categories. On some business-card sales, sending enhanced invoice data can qualify the sale for a lower rate.
American Express sets its own pricing. Most small merchants accept Amex through their regular processor at Amex-specific rates, so check the Amex lines on your statement directly instead of assuming they match Visa. Cards issued outside the U.S. add cross-border fees on top. Our piece on cross-border vs. foreign transaction fees explains who pays which one.
In practice, a restaurant whose diners carry premium rewards cards and a corner retailer whose customers mostly tap debit can sign the same processor contract and get very different statements.
Why Online and Keyed Sales Cost More Than Tapped Ones
How the card reaches you matters almost as much as what kind of card it is. Networks price by fraud risk, and a card that's physically present is harder to fake.
In-person chip and tap sales get the lowest interchange in nearly every category. Retail stores that run most sales through a chip-and-tap terminal sit at the low end for their card mix.
Online sales are card-not-present, so they carry higher interchange across the board. E-commerce stores usually pay a gateway fee too, and many pay for fraud-screening tools. Both belong in the total when you compare costs.
Keyed sales, where staff type the card number into a terminal or virtual terminal, are priced like online orders even when the customer is standing at the counter. Professional services firms that take payments over the phone or from emailed invoices see this every month. Missing data such as the billing ZIP code can push a keyed sale into a pricier category. For the full breakdown, see why keyed and online sales cost more than card-present.
Restaurants have a quirk of their own. Tips are added after the card is authorized, and bar tabs are often opened with a preauthorization. Both are normal network processes. A tip adjustment far beyond the original authorization can cause problems, though, so make sure your POS handles tip adjustments the way your processor expects.
Merchant Processing Fees You Should Expect Monthly and per Transaction
Beyond the percentage, a normal fee schedule usually includes some of the following. Each should be named in your agreement, explained in plain terms and stable from month to month.
- Per-transaction fee on top of the percentage, which hits hardest at small-ticket businesses like coffee shops and bars
- Monthly account or statement fee
- Gateway fee if you sell online or use a virtual terminal
- PCI compliance program fee, plus a separate non-compliance fee if you skip your annual validation
- Chargeback fee each time a customer disputes a sale
- Equipment, either bought outright or rented
Many schedules also include batch fees or a monthly minimum, and some carry an annual fee or an early termination fee. None of these is automatically improper, but each one is a point to negotiate. Our walkthrough of how to read a merchant statement line by line shows where each fee appears.
Average Credit Card Processing Fees Are the Wrong Benchmark
Merchants usually start with their effective rate: total processing fees for the month divided by total card volume. It's a useful health check. Comparing it with someone else's "average credit card processing fees" tells you little, though, because the pass-through layers depend on your card mix and channels.
Picture two shops that run the same monthly card volume and sign the same processor contract. Shop A sells in person, and most of its customers tap debit cards. Shop B sells online to customers who mostly carry rewards cards. Their markup costs come out identical. Shop B's interchange bill is much larger, so its effective rate is noticeably higher, and all of that gap comes from its card mix and channel. Shop A could even be on a worse contract and still post the lower effective rate.
So the benchmark that matters is your markup. You can find it on any interchange-plus statement:
- Add up every processing fee charged for the month.
- Subtract the interchange and card brand fees, which appear as separate lines.
- Divide what's left by your card volume to get your markup as a percentage.
- Divide that same amount by your transaction count to get your markup per sale.
Read those two markup figures alongside your account fees, and you have the numbers to compare across quotes. If your statement doesn't separate interchange, you can't complete step two, and that tells you something about your pricing on its own. Our guide to calculating credit card processing fees on any sale walks through the arithmetic in more detail.
How the Pricing Model Changes What "Normal" Means
Interchange-plus pricing lists pass-through costs separately, so you can read the markup straight off the statement. A fair interchange-plus deal applies the same markup percentage and per-item fee to every card type.
Flat-rate pricing bundles all three layers into one number. That keeps things simple, but you pay the same rate on cheap debit as on expensive rewards cards. If most of your sales come from low-cost cards, a flat rate can sit well above your actual pass-through cost.
Tiered pricing sorts sales into buckets the processor defines, with labels like "qualified" at the cheap end and "non-qualified" at the expensive end. Because the processor decides which sales land where, the markup is hard to see. If you're on a tiered plan, test it against an interchange-plus quote using a full month of your own statements. Our side-by-side of interchange-plus, flat-rate and tiered pricing shows how each plays out.
Warning Signs You're Overpaying
Any one of these is worth a call to your processor:
- Your effective rate rose while your sales mix and volume held steady.
- A large share of your sales lands in the non-qualified or mid-qualified bucket on a tiered statement.
- Fees with official-sounding names like "network" or "regulatory" don't match any charge from the card brands. Ask which network fee each one passes through.
- You're charged a PCI non-compliance fee month after month. Completing your annual validation usually removes it.
- Interchange never appears as its own line, so you can't calculate your markup.
- An early termination fee or liquidated damages clause turns up in your agreement that nobody mentioned, or you're locked into a multi-year lease on a basic terminal.
A rate increase can be legitimate, for example when the networks revise interchange. Our article on why credit card processing fees go up helps you sort network changes from processor markup. If the problems run deeper, our list of red flags to spot before signing with a processor covers contract terms to watch.
Run the Markup Math on Your Last Statement
Pull one recent statement and work through the four steps above. Then get at least one competing quote and line them up using our method for comparing merchant processing quotes side by side.
If you'd rather shift some of the cost to customers who pay by card, programs such as dual pricing and cash discount are legitimate options. They come with network and state rules, so read up on what's legal for credit card surcharges first and confirm specifics with a qualified professional. To see how your current costs compare, request a free quote from MannyPay. A specialist will respond within one business day.
This article is for general educational purposes and is not legal, tax or financial advice. Card network rules and state laws change; confirm current requirements for your business.
