Helcim vs Square: Fees Compared at Four Monthly Volumes
Comparisons & Buying Guides

Helcim vs. Square: Which Costs Less at Your Volume and Card Mix?

Helcim vs Square fees worked out on published rates from $10K to $150K a month, plus the ticket sizes and card mixes where Square's flat rate still wins.

Illustration of a smiling woman carrying colorful shopping bags past a boutique with a striped awning and mannequins

Photo: Pixabay

On this page 8 sections
  1. Helcim vs. Square Rates on Their Own Pricing Pages
  2. Card Type Sets Your Wholesale Cost
  3. What a Month Costs at Four Volume Levels
  4. Small Tickets Are Where Square's Flat Rate Holds Up
  5. Invoices and Keyed Payments Change the Math
  6. When a Paid Square Plan Pays for Itself
  7. Costs That Don't Show up in the Rate
  8. Run the Comparison on Your Own Statement

Key takeaways

  • On a $50 in-person ticket, Square Free costs 2.90%. In our illustrative card mixes, Helcim costs between 1.80% and 2.62%.
  • Square costs less below about $7 a ticket with an everyday card mix, and up to about $12.50 when most cards are premium rewards.
  • One premium rewards card can cost a few cents more on Helcim, so judge interchange-plus on a full month of mixed cards.
  • Square Plus pays for itself at $49,000 a month in person per location, or at about $12,250 a month online.

On their published rates, Helcim costs less than Square for most businesses that take mid-sized tickets in person. In the worked example below, a store selling $50 tickets pays an effective 2.90% on Square's free plan and between 1.80% and 2.62% on Helcim, depending on volume and card mix. Small tickets are the exception. In our math, Square's flat rate costs the same or less below about $7 with an everyday card mix, and up to about $12.50 when most cards are premium rewards. On any single premium rewards card, Helcim can also cost a few cents more.

Every rate here comes from the companies' and Visa's published tables. Both providers change prices, so check the linked pages before you decide.

Helcim vs. Square Rates on Their Own Pricing Pages

Square charges a flat rate that depends on its plan and on how the card is taken. Helcim charges interchange-plus: the card's wholesale cost passed through at cost, plus a markup that steps down as your monthly card volume grows.

Sale typeSquare Free ($0/mo)Square Plus ($49/mo per location)Square Premium ($149/mo per location)Helcim, first tier ($0–$50K/mo)
Tap, dip or swipe2.6% + 15¢2.5% + 15¢2.4% + 15¢Interchange + 0.40% + 8¢
Online or invoice3.3% + 30¢2.9% + 30¢2.9% + 30¢Interchange + 0.50% + 25¢
Keyed or card on file3.5% + 15¢3.5% + 15¢3.5% + 15¢Interchange + 0.50% + 25¢

Square's plan rates come from its point-of-sale pricing page and its online store plans page. The keyed rate comes from its fees help article, which also lists an extra 1.5% on cards issued outside the U.S. Square charges the same rate on Visa, Mastercard, American Express and Discover. Its pricing page invites businesses processing more than $250,000 a year to ask about custom pricing.

Helcim's pricing page lists five tiers based on monthly card volume. The in-person markup drops to 0.35% + 7¢ between $50,000 and $100,000, then to 0.25% + 7¢ up to $500,000, 0.20% + 6¢ up to $1 million and 0.15% + 6¢ up to $5 million. Keyed and online markups fall from 0.50% + 25¢ to 0.15% + 15¢ across the same tiers. Helcim's own processor comparison guide says it charges no monthly fees.

The markup is the only part of an interchange-plus bill a processor controls. Our guide to basis points and what your processing markup really costs shows how to read it.

Card Type Sets Your Wholesale Cost

Interchange is the fee the card networks set and the customer's issuing bank collects. It is a network rule, not a processor's price. Visa's U.S. interchange reimbursement fee table shows how wide the spread is for an ordinary in-store sale:

  • Regulated debit (cards from banks covered by the federal cap on debit fees): 0.05% + $0.21.
  • Exempt debit in the CPS/Retail category: 0.80% + $0.15.
  • Standard credit, CPS/Retail: 1.51% + $0.10, per Helcim's summary of Visa's credit rates.
  • Traditional rewards credit: 1.65% + $0.10.
  • Signature Preferred and Infinite credit: 2.10% + $0.10.

Keyed sales cost more. The same summary lists Visa's keyed CPS/Retail credit at 1.90% + $0.10 and keyed Signature Preferred at 2.52% + $0.10. Mastercard, American Express and Discover publish their own tables, so your blended cost depends on which cards your customers carry.

Square prices a $50 regulated debit tap and a $50 Visa Infinite tap identically. On interchange-plus, the debit sale costs a fraction as much, and that gap drives everything below. For the wider version of this choice, see interchange-plus vs. flat-rate pricing and which one costs less.

What a Month Costs at Four Volume Levels

This example is illustrative. These are its assumptions:

  • Every sale is $50, tapped or dipped in person.
  • Square is on the Free plan at 2.6% + 15¢.
  • Helcim's markup is the published in-person tier for each volume, and the whole month is priced at that tier. Ask Helcim how it applies tiers before relying on this.
  • Every card is priced at Visa's in-store rate for its type, using the rates listed above.
  • "Everyday mix": 40% regulated debit, 30% standard credit, 30% traditional rewards.
  • "Rewards-heavy mix": 15% regulated debit, 25% traditional rewards, 60% Signature Preferred or Infinite.
  • An illustrative 0.15% is added to the Helcim side for card network assessment fees, which interchange-plus pricing passes through on top of interchange. Real network fees vary by brand.
Monthly volumeSalesHelcim in-person markupSquare FreeHelcim, everyday mixHelcim, rewards-heavy mix
$10,0002000.40% + 8¢$290 (2.90%)$196.60 (1.97%)$262.30 (2.62%)
$40,0008000.40% + 8¢$1,160 (2.90%)$786.40 (1.97%)$1,049.20 (2.62%)
$75,0001,5000.35% + 7¢$2,175 (2.90%)$1,422.00 (1.90%)$1,914.75 (2.55%)
$150,0003,0000.25% + 7¢$4,350 (2.90%)$2,694.00 (1.80%)$3,679.50 (2.45%)

Here is the $40,000 row worked through. On Square, each $50 sale costs $1.30 (2.6%) plus $0.15, or $1.45. Across 800 sales that is $1,160.

On Helcim with the everyday mix, start with interchange. A regulated debit sale costs $0.235, a standard credit sale $0.855 and a traditional rewards sale $0.925. Weighted 40/30/30, that averages $0.628 a sale. Add $0.075 for the 0.15% network allowance and $0.28 for Helcim's markup ($0.20 plus $0.08). The total is $0.983 a sale, or $786.40 for the month. That is $373.60 less than Square.

Square's effective rate never moves, because nothing in a flat rate responds to growth or a cheaper card mix. Helcim's falls with each lower tier, and even the rewards-heavy mix beats Square at every volume here.

A Single Premium Card Can Cost More on Helcim

Run one $50 Visa Signature Preferred tap through both models. On Helcim, interchange is $1.15, the network allowance is $0.075 and the markup is $0.28, for $1.505. Square charges $1.45. On that card alone, the flat rate wins by about 5 cents.

The same $50 on a regulated debit card costs $0.59 on Helcim against Square's $1.45. A flat rate is priced so that cheap cards pay for expensive ones. Interchange-plus comes out ahead across a month of mixed cards, so judge it on a full statement rather than one transaction.

Small Tickets Are Where Square's Flat Rate Holds Up

Many owners assume the fixed fee alone settles the small-ticket question. It doesn't. Square's 15-cent fixed fee is always lower than Helcim's fixed cost on a regulated debit sale, which is 29 cents: Visa's 21 cents of interchange plus Helcim's 8-cent markup. That holds whether the sale is $6 or $600. What decides the winner is how fast Helcim's lower percentage earns back that head start as the ticket grows.

Blended across the everyday mix, Helcim's fixed cost averages 22.4 cents a sale against Square's 15, a 7.4-cent gap. Its percentage is 1.518% (interchange, network allowance and markup) against Square's 2.6%, so Helcim saves about 1.08 cents on every dollar of ticket. It pulls even at about $6.85. Under the rewards-heavy mix, the fixed gap is smaller (19.65 cents against 15), but the percentage gap shrinks much more, to 0.37 points (2.23% against 2.6%). Helcim needs a ticket of about $12.55 to catch up.

Using the same assumptions, here is the per-sale cost at Helcim's first tier:

TicketSquare FreeHelcim, everyday mixHelcim, rewards-heavy mix
$630.6¢31.5¢33.0¢
$835.8¢34.5¢37.5¢
$1246.2¢40.6¢46.4¢
$1451.4¢43.7¢50.9¢
$2067.0¢52.8¢64.2¢

So the crossover depends on who pays you. A coffee counter whose customers mostly tap debit and standard cards may pay the same or less on Square below about $7. A shop with a similar ticket but a premium-card crowd stays roughly even with Square up to about $12.50. In both cases the margins are fractions of a cent per sale, so other costs and features should decide it. From about $13 up, interchange-plus pulls ahead under both mixes, and the gap widens with ticket size. A $100 regulated debit sale costs $0.89 on Helcim and $2.75 on Square.

Visa's table also has lower small-ticket categories for some exempt debit cards, which this example leaves out. A real statement may therefore look a little better for interchange-plus at small tickets.

Invoices and Keyed Payments Change the Math

Contractors and consultants take few in-person taps. Clients pay by emailed invoice or a card read over the phone, often with business or premium cards. On its Free plan, Square charges 3.3% + 30¢ for invoices and 3.5% + 15¢ for keyed or card-on-file payments. Helcim's keyed and online markup starts at 0.50% + 25¢, on top of card-not-present interchange, which runs higher than in-store rates. Our breakdown of why keyed and online sales cost more explains why.

Take an illustrative $1,500 invoice. It uses Visa's keyed rates as a stand-in for card-not-present interchange and the same 0.15% network allowance:

  • Standard Visa credit on Helcim: $28.60 interchange, $2.25 network allowance and $7.75 markup, for $38.60.
  • Signature Preferred on Helcim: $37.90 interchange plus the same allowance and markup, for $47.90.
  • Square Free: $49.80 paid through an invoice, or $52.65 if keyed.
  • Square Plus: $43.80 through an invoice.

At large tickets the percentage drives everything, and premium cards close most of the gap. A firm whose clients mostly pay with premium cards could find Square Plus competitive on invoices once enough volume absorbs the $49 fee. Some business cards also qualify for lower interchange when the payment carries extra order data such as the tax amount or line items. Only pass-through pricing hands that saving to you, so ask whether the gateway sends the data.

When a Paid Square Plan Pays for Itself

If you stay with Square, the plan math is simple division. Square Plus cuts the in-person rate by 0.1 point for $49 a month per location, so it breaks even at $49,000 of monthly in-person volume per location. Premium cuts 0.2 point for $149 and breaks even against Free at $74,500. Moving from Plus to Premium pays only above $100,000 a month in person. Online sales tip the math faster. Plus takes 0.4 point off Square Free's online and invoice rate, so about $12,250 of monthly online volume covers the fee by itself.

In our $150,000 example, Premium brings Square to $4,199 a month, still above Helcim's rewards-heavy $3,679.50. At that volume you also clear Square's $250,000-a-year threshold for custom pricing, so get a quote before treating its published rate as final.

Costs That Don't Show up in the Rate

Square's hardware, POS apps and add-ons run from one dashboard, and many owners have built their day around it. Helcim sells its own readers and software. Both feature sets change often, so test what you depend on: inventory variants, gift cards, counter returns, card-on-file billing and the sync to your accounting software. Readers built for one platform generally won't run on another. Stored customer cards may not move either, unless the new provider accepts a PCI-compliant data transfer from the old one.

Ask each provider whether you get your own merchant ID or process as a sub-merchant under its master account. Our guide to merchant accounts vs. payment aggregators explains why that matters for holds. Under either setup, a volume spike or rising chargebacks can trigger a hold, so read when to tell your payment processor about business changes before a seasonal surge.

A third route is a dedicated merchant account paired with POS systems for retail counters or a virtual terminal for keyed and invoiced payments. If you want to offset card costs instead of just trimming them, look at dual pricing programs, which show a cash price and a card price.

Run the Comparison on Your Own Statement

  1. Pull three months of statements. Note card volume, number of sales and the share taken in person, keyed and online.
  2. Work out your average ticket. Test Square's flat rate seriously if your ticket is under about $7 and most customers pay with debit or standard cards, or under about $12.50 if most pay with premium rewards cards.
  3. Estimate your card mix: debit versus credit, and how much of the credit is rewards or business cards. Square statements don't show interchange, so use sales reports or ask an interchange-plus provider to model a few months of your transactions.
  4. Price each channel at current published rates, add every monthly fee and compare totals using our method for comparing merchant processing quotes side by side.
  5. If you switch, get the new account approved first, run a live sale and a refund, and confirm the deposit lands. Keep the old account open until its refunds are done and its chargeback window has closed.

Start with step one this week. If you want a third quote to set against Helcim and Square, request a free processing quote and a MannyPay specialist will respond within one business day. Get every rate and contract term in writing before you move.

Sources

  1. Square Point of Sale Pricing & Plans
  2. Square Online Store Pricing & Plans
  3. Square: Learn About Square Fees
  4. Square Pricing
  5. Helcim Pricing
  6. Helcim: Interchange Plus Pricing
  7. Helcim: Cheapest Credit Card Processors for U.S. and Canadian Businesses
  8. Helcim: Visa Interchange Rates USA
  9. Visa USA Interchange Reimbursement Fees

About the author

Daniel Foster

Daniel Foster is Product & Payments Technology Editor for Beyond the Swipe, covering POS systems, payment gateways, virtual terminals, mobile payments and integrations.

This article is for general educational purposes and is not legal, tax or financial advice. Card network rules and state laws change; confirm current requirements for your business.

Related reading