Iceland Plans a Card Alternative: A2A Lessons for U.S. Merchants
Iceland is building account-to-account payments as a card alternative. See what it means for U.S. merchants and how to test pay-by-bank at checkout.

Photo: Pixabay
On this page 6 sections
- What Happened: Iceland's Central Bank Plans an A2A Option for Merchants
- Why Countries Build a National A2A Payment Scheme
- How A2A Payments Differ From Cards: Cost, Settlement and Chargebacks
- What Iceland Account-to-Account Payments Mean for U.S. Hotels, Tour Operators and Online Stores
- U.S. Options Today: FedNow, RTP and Pay-by-Bank Providers
- A Short Checklist for Testing Pay-by-Bank at Your Checkout
Key takeaways
- Iceland's planned A2A scheme isn't live and has no launch date yet, so Icelandic travelers will keep paying U.S. businesses by card.
- The central bank's main reason is resilience. Payments in Iceland run almost entirely on Visa and Mastercard, and the bank wants a second domestic route.
- A2A skips card interchange, but settlement, refunds and disputes work differently. Ask any U.S. pay-by-bank provider whether it runs on instant rails or ACH.
- Pay-by-bank only pays off if enough customers choose it. In our illustrative example, the store broke even when 2% of orders switched.
Iceland's central bank is preparing a national system for account-to-account (A2A) payments. Shoppers would pay a merchant straight from their bank account, at the counter or online, with no card involved. The plan is meant to sit beside Visa and Mastercard as both a backup and a competitor. For U.S. merchants, Iceland account-to-account payments change nothing at the terminal today, and Icelandic travelers will keep paying you by card. The plan is still worth a close read. It shows why countries keep building their own payment rails, and it gives you a list of things to check before you add pay-by-bank to your own checkout.
What Happened: Iceland's Central Bank Plans an A2A Option for Merchants
On Oct. 30, 2026, Tómas Brynjólfsson, the Central Bank of Iceland's deputy governor for financial stability, spoke at the MoneyLive Nordic Banking conference in Copenhagen. He said the bank was in the final stages of preparing infrastructure for payments over domestic instant credit transfers, as Finextra reported. The Bank for International Settlements published the speech on Nov. 3 under the title "A new payment scheme for Iceland - building a sovereign and secure payment system." The payments trade press has covered it throughout November.
The design splits the work. The central bank would supply the shared rules, technical standards and settlement. Banks and payment companies would build the consumer apps and merchant services, according to TokenPost's summary of the speech. Payments would move in Icelandic krónur, settle in central bank money and give the merchant immediate confirmation. Noire, which follows the scheme from the merchant side, describes a request-to-pay model built on Iceland's existing instant-transfer infrastructure. It also reports that procurement for the core system has started and that no launch date has been set.
Two limits matter. First, the speech framed the scheme as a complement to the international card networks, so cards stay. Second, the scheme is separate from Iceland's planned connection to TIPS, the Eurosystem's instant payment settlement service. TokenPost reports that the TIPS connection is targeted to be ready in the second half of 2028.
None of this is sudden. The central bank proposed an independent domestic payment solution in a February 2023 discussion paper (in Icelandic). A later bill in the Althingi, Iceland's parliament, sought to give the bank authority to build the central A2A infrastructure, according to the parliamentary committee report.
Why Countries Build a National A2A Payment Scheme
Iceland's stated reason is resilience. Payments there are highly digital and run almost entirely through Visa and Mastercard. Cash use is very low. Person-to-person instant transfers are common, but no A2A option for paying merchants has caught on, Payment Expert reported. Brynjólfsson noted that the domestic debit rails that kept payments running during Iceland's 2008 banking collapse "have given way to foreign rails," according to PaymentsJournal. Iceland is an island that depends on a few outside providers and on constant connectivity, so one serious outage could stall everyday commerce.
He summed up the strategy this way: "resilience requires multiple viable payment routes." The bank is adding smaller safeguards too. Under an arrangement with Icelandic card issuers and acquirers, cards issued in Iceland can be used offline for purchases of up to ISK 50,000 per card starting July 1, 2026, the Central Bank of Iceland announced on June 3, 2026.
In other countries the motives mix resilience with cost. In Europe, more than 30 banks and financial institutions back Wero, a pan-European digital wallet built on instant account-to-account rails that moves money between accounts without going through card networks such as Visa and Mastercard, according to Primer. Meanwhile, card fees are still being fought in UK courts, as our coverage of the £5bn UK fee claim against Visa and Mastercard explains. These efforts share one goal: a payment route governed by a central bank or a group of banks, and priced outside card interchange.
How A2A Payments Differ From Cards: Cost, Settlement and Chargebacks
From the merchant's side of the counter, the two compare like this.
| Card payment | A2A or pay-by-bank | |
|---|---|---|
| What sets the base cost | Interchange and network fees set by Visa, Mastercard and the other networks, plus your processor's markup | The scheme's rules and your provider's pricing; no card interchange |
| When the money arrives | Batched and deposited on your processor's schedule | Within seconds on instant rails; ACH-based products take longer |
| Customer disputes | Chargebacks under card network rules | Whatever the scheme and provider terms say; the merchant usually sends refunds |
| Foreign visitors | Any card on a network you accept | Usually only customers of participating domestic banks |
Cost gets the most attention. Interchange is the largest part of what card acceptance costs, so removing it is the main appeal of A2A for regulators and large merchants. That doesn't make acceptance free. Someone has to run the rails and the checkout software, and providers charge for it per transaction, as a percentage, as a monthly fee, or as a mix of these. Iceland hasn't published merchant pricing for its scheme.
Disputes cut both ways. Card customers can contest a charge through their issuer within time limits set by network rules (see how long a customer has to file a chargeback). In a push payment, the customer approves the transfer inside their own banking app, which leaves less room for stolen-card fraud. On the other hand, some shoppers will be reluctant to give up card-style protection when they pay in advance for things like tours, event packages and lodging deposits. As of Nov. 15, 2026, we haven't seen published dispute rules for Iceland's scheme. Those rules are the detail to watch.
Reconciliation changes too. A2A payments arrive as individual bank credits, each with a payment reference, rather than as one processor batch. Your month-end process will need to match deposits to sales in a new format.
What Iceland Account-to-Account Payments Mean for U.S. Hotels, Tour Operators and Online Stores
In the near term, nothing changes. The Iceland domestic payment system is built for krónur, it isn't live yet, and it is designed to run alongside cards. Icelandic guests and online shoppers will keep paying U.S. businesses with Icelandic-issued Visa and Mastercard cards. Iceland's own legislative record raised the issue. One consultation comment on the bill warned that if a domestic solution replaced card infrastructure, tourism could suffer because foreign visitors would struggle to use it (government bill, in Icelandic).
For a U.S. hotel, tour operator or store that sells to Icelandic customers, the practical work is about cards:
- Know your foreign-card costs. Cards issued outside the U.S. typically trigger network cross-border fees that domestic cards don't. Our explainer on cross-border fees on foreign-issued cards shows who pays each charge.
- Secure card-not-present bookings. For hotels and lodging businesses and tour and travel sellers, disputes often start with deposits taken online weeks before arrival. 3-D Secure authentication lets you verify the cardholder when the issuer asks for it.
- Decide how you price currency. If you quote in dollars, the guest's bank handles the conversion. MannyPay's international payment processing includes multi-currency acceptance and a review of USD or local-currency settlement for businesses that need it.
The longer-term lesson is about habits. As national A2A schemes spread, more visitors will be used to paying from a bank app at home. Cross-border purchases still run on cards.
U.S. Options Today: FedNow, RTP and Pay-by-Bank Providers
The United States has two instant interbank rails. In 2020 the Federal Reserve published service details for the FedNow Service, a 24x7x365 real-time gross settlement service for instant payments, and asked for public comment, according to the Federal Register notice. The Clearing House launched the RTP network in 2017. Its payments clear and settle individually in real time with immediate finality, according to The Clearing House. You can't simply switch either one on at checkout. Banks connect to the rails, and whether you can use them at checkout depends on banks and providers building consumer products on top.
Most "pay by bank" buttons U.S. shoppers see today work differently. The shopper links a bank account through an open-banking connection, and the provider pulls the funds over ACH. Because this skips card interchange, it can cost less than cards, especially on large tickets. It also settles more slowly, and ACH debits can be returned after the fact. Some providers now push payments over instant rails instead. Ask which one you are buying. Confirm current transaction limits and bank coverage with the provider, because both change.
Bank-backed wallets are a separate category. Paze runs on the customer's cards, so it carries card economics.
A Worked Example: When Pay-by-Bank Pays for Itself
Among alternatives to card payments for merchants, adoption matters more to the math than the per-transaction fee. These numbers are illustrative, not quotes from any provider:
- An online store processes 1,000 orders a month at an average of $250.
- Assumed all-in card cost: 2.9% + $0.30, or $7.55 per order.
- Assumed pay-by-bank fee: 1% capped at $5, or $2.50 per order, plus a $100 monthly platform fee.
Each order that moves from card to bank saves $5.05. If 5% of customers switch (50 orders), the store saves $252.50 a month, or $152.50 after the platform fee. If only 1% switch (10 orders), it saves $50.50 and ends up $49.50 behind once the fee is paid. The store breaks even at 20 switched orders, or 2% of volume. Before you sign anything, rerun the numbers with your own statement rate, your average ticket and a real quote.
A Short Checklist for Testing Pay-by-Bank at Your Checkout
- Pick the orders where it fits. Large tickets, repeat buyers, B2B invoices and deposits gain the most. A $15 impulse buy gains little.
- Get the full price in writing. That means per-transaction fees, monthly minimums, setup costs and charges for returned payments.
- Ask which rail it uses. Instant push and ACH pull settle on different timelines and carry different return risk.
- Read the refund and dispute terms. Know who handles a customer's claim and how quickly you can send a refund.
- Check the plumbing. Confirm the button works with your online payment gateway and that deposits post cleanly to your accounting software.
- Offer it beside cards for 60 to 90 days. Track adoption, abandoned checkouts and support tickets, then compare the results with the break-even math above.
Before you price an alternative, pull last quarter's processing statements and work out your effective card rate. That number tells you whether pay-by-bank is worth testing. If you want a second set of eyes on it, request a free quote and a MannyPay specialist will respond within one business day. In Iceland, watch for two things: the scheme's published dispute rules and a launch date. They will show how much card-style protection a central bank will give shoppers when merchants aren't paying card-level fees.
Sources
- Finextra: Iceland prepares for domestic account-to-account payments infrastructure
- BIS Central bankers' speeches: A new payment scheme for Iceland (Tómas Brynjólfsson, Oct. 30, 2026)
- TokenPost: Iceland Central Bank Outlines Domestic Account-to-Account Payment Plan
- Noire: Iceland A2A Scheme for Merchant Payment Choice
- Payment Expert: Iceland to develop A2A payment backup to Visa and Mastercard
- PaymentsJournal: Iceland Considers Its Own A2A Payments System
- Central Bank of Iceland: Special Publication No. 16, Independent Domestic Retail Payment Solution (Feb. 17, 2023)
- Central Bank of Iceland: Card Payments Without Connectivity (June 3, 2026)
- Althingi: Committee report with amendments, Central Bank of Iceland bill, 154th session (doc. 1731)
- Althingi: Government bill, Central Bank of Iceland, 154th session (doc. 991)
- Primer: Wero payment method explained, the new European wallet
- Federal Register: Service Details on Federal Reserve Actions To Support Interbank Settlement of Instant Payments (Aug. 11, 2020)
- The Clearing House: Real Time Payments (RTP network)
This article is for general educational purposes and is not legal, tax or financial advice. Card network rules and state laws change; confirm current requirements for your business.


