Stripe Alternatives: Pick One Based on Why You're Leaving
Compare Stripe alternatives by why you're leaving: fees at scale, a closed account or billing needs. See the math and how to move saved cards safely.
On this page 6 sections
- How Stripe's Model Explains Why Merchants Leave
- Cost at Scale: When an Interchange-Plus Stripe Alternative Is Cheaper
- Closed Accounts and Restricted Industries Need Underwritten Merchant Accounts
- Stripe Competitors With Comparable APIs and Plugins
- Moving Saved Cards Out of Stripe Without Losing Subscribers
- Running Stripe Alongside a Second Processor
Key takeaways
- With Stripe's 2.9% + 30¢ against an illustrative interchange-plus price, a $100,000-a-month store saves about $765 a month, but a $10,000-a-month store saves only about $45.
- Shopify charges a third-party gateway fee of 0.2% to 2% depending on the plan. In the illustrative example, that fee wipes out the savings on every plan.
- If you use Stripe Billing, add its 0.7% pay-as-you-go fee to your effective rate before you compare quotes.
- Stripe only exports cards to a PCI DSS Level 1 processor. The file doesn't include subscriptions, payment history or cards saved through Link.
The best Stripe alternatives depend on why you're leaving. If Stripe's standard 2.9% + 30¢ per domestic card sale has gotten expensive as you grew, an interchange-plus merchant account paired with a gateway such as Authorize.net or NMI will usually cost less. If Stripe closed your account or won't support what you sell, you need a merchant account that a bank underwrites before you go live. And if Stripe Billing and saved cards are what hold you there, plan the card migration before you sign with anyone.
Most comparison pages rank processors as if every merchant had the same problem. A SaaS company with steady recurring revenue and a supplement brand that just got a closure email need very different things, so start with your reason.
| Why you're leaving | Replacement path | Check this first |
|---|---|---|
| Cost at scale | Interchange-plus merchant account plus a gateway | Your current effective rate and contract terms |
| Account closed or industry restricted | Underwritten merchant account, high-risk acquirer if needed | Reserve terms and MATCH status |
| Developer or platform fit | Gateway with a full API and plugins for your cart | Card import support and recurring billing |
| Marketplace payouts to sellers | A payment facilitator platform built for split payouts | Who holds seller funds |
How Stripe's Model Explains Why Merchants Leave
Stripe is a payment facilitator. It signs merchants up under its own relationships with acquiring banks and lets you take payments within minutes. Much of the risk review happens after money starts moving. That model makes Stripe easy to start with, and it also explains the three reasons people go looking for something else.
Cost usually comes first for a growing store. A facilitator charges one blended price with the convenience built in. That feels cheap at low volume and expensive once card sales reach six figures a month.
Closures push out a different group. Because review comes after you're live, a sudden jump in volume or a run of disputes can trigger a hold or a termination with little warning. If disputes are the issue, check where you stand against the card networks' chargeback ratio thresholds before you apply anywhere new, because the next underwriter will ask.
Industry restrictions account for the rest. Stripe publishes a Prohibited and Restricted Businesses list in two tiers: businesses it won't serve at all, and businesses it serves only in some cases or with prior approval. That list is Stripe's policy, shaped by its risk appetite and its partner banks. It is not a Visa or Mastercard rule, and many businesses on it can be approved for card processing elsewhere through proper underwriting.
Cost at Scale: When an Interchange-Plus Stripe Alternative Is Cheaper
Every card sale carries interchange, a fee the card networks set and the cardholder's bank collects. Network assessment fees sit on top of interchange, and the processor's markup sits on top of both. Some of this is set by law. Federal rules cap interchange on debit cards issued by large banks, which is why those cards cost less to accept than credit cards. The rest comes from network rate tables and one processor's pricing, and only the processor's part is negotiable.
Stripe's published U.S. pricing blends all of it into 2.9% + 30¢ per successful domestic card transaction. On top of that, it adds 0.5% for manually entered cards, 1.5% for international cards and 1% when currency conversion is required. Disputes cost $15 each in the U.S. Since June 17, 2025, Stripe also charges a second $15 if you contest a dispute and lose, as Signifyd reported. All of these are Stripe's own prices, so ask each alternative for its equivalent fees, line by line.
A Worked Example at Two Volumes
The interchange-plus figures below are illustrative, not a quote from MannyPay or anyone else. The assumptions: an online store does $100,000 a month in domestic card sales at a $50 average ticket, which is 2,000 transactions. Under interchange-plus, pass-through costs and markup together average 2.3% + $0.20 per sale, plus $35 a month in gateway and account fees.
| Monthly volume | Stripe standard (2.9% + 30¢) | Interchange-plus (illustrative) | Monthly difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| $100,000 (2,000 sales) | $3,500 | $2,735 | $765 |
| $10,000 (200 sales) | $350 | $305 | $45 |
At $100,000 a month, switching saves about $9,180 a year under these assumptions. At $10,000 a month, it saves $540 a year, and a single early-termination fee or annual compliance fee could erase most of that.
Three things move your own crossover point. Small tickets make the per-transaction fee weigh more. Premium rewards and corporate cards carry higher interchange, which narrows the gap. Keyed and international sales widen it, because Stripe adds its surcharges to those. To get your effective rate, pull three months of Stripe reports and divide total fees by total volume. Then measure every quote against that number. Ask Stripe, too, whether your volume qualifies for custom pricing. A better offer from Stripe is a fine outcome.
SaaS: Count Stripe Billing Separately
If you run subscriptions on Stripe Billing, your real cost is higher than the card rate. Stripe's pay-as-you-go Billing plan charges 0.7% of Billing volume on top of processing, according to a breakdown of Stripe's U.S. pricing page as of October 2026. For the example store's $100,000, that's another $700 a month. Leaving Stripe removes that fee, but whatever replaces it, whether a gateway's recurring billing module or a separate billing platform, has its own price. Compare the two on total cost.
Shopify Stores: Why Leaving Rarely Saves Money
Shopify charges its own transaction fee when you use a third-party gateway instead of Shopify Payments. That fee is Shopify's platform pricing, not a network rule, and it changes the math. The table uses the same illustrative store and the plan rates in this 2026 Shopify fee breakdown:
| Shopify plan | Shopify Payments rate | Shopify Payments cost | Third-party fee | Interchange-plus plus Shopify fee |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Basic | 2.9% + 30¢ | $3,500 | 2.0% | $4,735 |
| Grow | 2.7% + 30¢ | $3,300 | 1.0% | $3,735 |
| Advanced | 2.5% + 30¢ | $3,100 | 0.6% | $3,335 |
| Plus | from 2.15% + 30¢ | $2,750 | 0.2% | $2,935 |
Under these assumptions, the Shopify store pays more on every plan when it moves to an outside gateway. For Shopify merchants, a third-party gateway usually makes sense for acceptance, not price: Shopify Payments won't support the product, or it closed the account. Check the current rates for your plan before you decide.
Closed Accounts and Restricted Industries Need Underwritten Merchant Accounts
A dedicated merchant account flips the facilitator model around. The acquiring bank reviews your business before your first sale, and you get your own merchant ID with terms set up front. Underwriting asks for more paperwork. Expect to provide past processing statements and to have your website reviewed, including your refund policy and billing descriptor. Some banks also want financials. In return you get stability, because a bank that knowingly approved your business model is far less likely to be surprised by it later.
Sellers in categories such as CBD or vape should look for a high-risk merchant account from a provider whose acquiring banks accept their category. Expect a rolling reserve, where the bank holds back a share of each day's sales for a set period, and closer monitoring of your chargeback ratio. Underwriters read your marketing claims, too. For many of these products, legality varies by state and under federal law, and banks check it before approving.
Apply honestly. Describe exactly what you sell, use the merchant category code that fits it, and disclose past terminations. If a previous processor put you on the MATCH list, read up on MATCH list reason codes first, because some codes are much easier to explain than others. Miscoding a business or running sales through someone else's account doesn't solve anything. It moves the closure to a worse moment and can add a MATCH entry.
Stripe Competitors With Comparable APIs and Plugins
Stripe's API is the benchmark developers compare everything to, and fairly so. Established gateways still cover what most online stores and SaaS products need. Authorize.net and NMI both offer APIs with hosted payment fields that keep card data off your servers, which keeps your PCI DSS scope small. Both also provide a customer vault for stored cards and webhook notifications for payment events.
Cart integrations matter as much as the API. A WooCommerce gateway plugin can usually connect a store without custom code, and Magento and BigCommerce have similar plugins. If you're also rethinking checkout design, compare a hosted payment page against an embedded checkout before you rebuild.
Marketplaces are the real exception. If you collect payments and pay out to third-party sellers the way Stripe Connect does, a standard merchant account won't handle that on its own. Paying out money that belongs to other people raises seller-verification and money-transmission questions. Keep a facilitator platform for that flow, or get written confirmation that your new provider supports split payouts.
Moving Saved Cards Out of Stripe Without Losing Subscribers
This step decides whether a switch goes smoothly or turns into a churn event. Stripe's migration documentation covers exporting card data to another processor. The file moves encrypted between the two companies, and you never handle raw card numbers.
- Confirm the receiving side qualifies. According to Payment Review's summary of processor export policies, Stripe only transfers card data to a PCI DSS Level 1 processor. It asks for that processor's Attestation of Compliance or its listing on Visa's Global Registry of Service Providers, plus a PGP encryption key of at least 4,096 bits. Ask your new gateway whether its vault accepts Stripe imports.
- Know what the file contains. Stripe's export carries card details, customer email addresses and any metadata you attached. It doesn't include payment history or subscriptions, and it leaves out cards saved through Link, Stripe's one-click checkout.
- Expect some customers to re-enter cards. Cards stored in wallets such as Google Pay are tokenized by the wallet, not the processor. That's why Stripe's own import guide says it can't migrate them. Plan a card-update campaign for wallet and Link customers.
- Keep the ID mapping. The import should return a file that maps each old Stripe customer and card ID to a new token. Your app and billing system depend on it.
- Rebuild subscriptions from your own records. Recreate billing dates, prices, trials and discounts. Then make sure no customer gets billed by both systems on cutover day.
- Test with a small batch. Run a few low-value renewals through the new vault before you move everyone. To catch cards that customers updated after the export, request a second file or send a card-update link.
Processor-to-processor transfers can take anywhere from a few days to several weeks, so don't announce a cutover date until the file has arrived. Once it has, ask whether the new setup supports account updater services and network tokenization for fewer failed renewals. Set up retries along the lines of our guide to dunning management for failed subscription payments. Tell your underwriter up front that you bill on a recurring basis. Recurring billing has its own approval requirements, which we cover in getting a subscription merchant account approved.
Keep the Stripe account open after you stop taking new sales. Refunds and disputes on old charges still run through Stripe, and dispute windows can stay open for months.
Running Stripe Alongside a Second Processor
You don't have to switch all at once. Many merchants add a second processor and route specific traffic to it, such as one product line or all new customers, while existing subscribers stay where they are. A second account also gives you a fallback if one provider has an outage or freezes funds. Our piece on payment orchestration with more than one processor covers how routing works and when the extra complexity pays off.
Two rules keep a dual setup legitimate. First, each account must be approved for exactly what runs through it, so products on Stripe's restricted list never go through Stripe. Second, routing decides which processor handles a whole transaction. Splitting one sale across accounts to stay under limits breaks card network rules. Once both processors are live, compare their authorization rates side by side. That data tells you more than any sales pitch.
Start with your effective rate: three months of Stripe fees, including Billing and dispute fees, divided by your card volume. Bring that number to every conversation with a new provider. You can request a free quote from MannyPay for online payment processing, and a MannyPay specialist will respond within one business day.
Sources
- Stripe Pricing & Fees
- Stripe Prohibited and Restricted Businesses
- Stripe Docs: Data Migrations Overview
- Stripe Docs: Import Payment Method Data
- Payment Review: Switching Processors and Moving Stored Cards
- Argent Payments: How to Move Stored Card Tokens When You Switch Processors
- Signifyd: Stripe and Visa Chargeback Fees Are Changing
- Lilach Bullock: Stripe Billing Pricing, Plans and How Subscriptions Work
- OneCart: Shopify Fees 2026
- Paycove: Credit Card Processing Fees and Rates, Explained
- Stripe Restricted & Prohibited Businesses: Full List for 2026 (DirectPayNet)
This article is for general educational purposes and is not legal, tax or financial advice. Card network rules and state laws change; confirm current requirements for your business.


