Stripe vs. PayPal: Fees, Disputes, Payout Holds and Checkout Conversion
Stripe vs PayPal compared on current U.S. rates, dispute fees, currency conversion and payout holds, plus a break-even test for adding a PayPal button.

Photo: Pixabay
On this page 7 sections
- Stripe vs. PayPal Fees on a U.S. Online Sale
- Cross-Border Cards and Currency Conversion
- Dispute Fees Work Differently on Each Platform
- Payout Holds and Account Reviews
- What a PayPal Button Has to Earn at Checkout
- Subscriptions and Developer Tools: Where Stripe Pulls Ahead
- PayPal or Stripe for Small Business, or a Merchant Account
Key takeaways
- On an $80 order, standard pricing costs $2.62 at Stripe, $2.88 on PayPal's card rate and $3.28 through PayPal Checkout. On a $10 sale, the fixed fee pushes PayPal Checkout to 8.4%.
- Both charge about 1.5% extra for foreign cards, but currency conversion costs 1% at Stripe against a 4.00% spread at PayPal.
- Stripe keeps its $15 dispute fee even when you win. PayPal doesn't charge its standard dispute fee when a dispute on a PayPal-account payment goes your way.
- In the example store, a PayPal button pays for itself at a 1.4% lift in total orders. Test it before you assume it does.
On standard U.S. pricing, Stripe charges less per online card sale than PayPal. Stripe takes 2.9% + 30¢. PayPal takes 3.49% plus a $0.49 fixed fee when the buyer pays through PayPal Checkout. PayPal's own card product, at 2.99% + fixed fee, narrows the gap, but its fixed fee is still 19 cents higher. The bigger differences in Stripe vs. PayPal are elsewhere: currency conversion, dispute fees, payout holds, and whether a PayPal button brings in enough extra orders to cover its higher rate.
Every rate below is the company's own published pricing, not a Visa or Mastercard rule. PayPal figures come from its U.S. merchant fees page, updated October 1, 2026. Stripe figures come from Stripe's U.S. pricing page. Both companies change these schedules, so check them before you commit.
Stripe vs. PayPal Fees on a U.S. Online Sale
| U.S. standard pricing | Stripe | PayPal |
|---|---|---|
| Online card payment | 2.9% + $0.30 | 2.99% + $0.49 (Standard Credit and Debit Card Payments) |
| Buyer pays with a PayPal account, Venmo or PayPal Guest Checkout | Not applicable | 3.49% + $0.49 |
| PayPal Pay Later | Not applicable | 4.99% + $0.49 |
| Card issued outside the U.S. | Add 1.5% | Add 1.50% |
| Currency conversion | Add 1% | 4.00% spread on converted payments |
| Dispute | $15 received, plus $15 if you counter (returned if you win) | $15 standard or $30 high-volume dispute fee; $20 card chargeback fee |
Both companies use an aggregated model. You process under their master relationship instead of getting your own individually underwritten merchant account. That's why you can take payments the same afternoon you sign up, and it's also why the pricing is flat. Underneath every sale is interchange, the fee the bank that issued the card collects. Visa and Mastercard set interchange in published tables, and it varies by card type and by whether the card was present. A flat rate averages all of that into one number. If your customers mostly pay with low-cost debit cards, you overpay. If they carry premium rewards cards, the flat rate works in your favor.
The fixed fee matters most on small tickets. On an illustrative $10 digital download, Stripe's fee is $0.59, or 5.9% of the sale. PayPal Checkout takes $0.84 (8.4%), and PayPal's standard card rate takes $0.79 (7.9%). On an $80 order the gap shrinks: $2.62 at Stripe, $2.88 on PayPal's card rate, $3.28 through PayPal Checkout and $4.48 through Pay Later. PayPal also lists a separate Advanced Credit and Debit Card product for merchants who put card fields directly in their own checkout. FeeProbe's tracker shows it at 2.89% + $0.29, which makes it the closer like-for-like comparison with Stripe.
Two smaller lines deserve a look. PayPal does not return its original transaction fees when you refund a commercial payment, so a refunded $80 PayPal Checkout sale still costs you $3.28. Check Stripe's current refund terms on its pricing page rather than assuming they're different. Faster payouts cost extra on both platforms. PayPal's instant transfer for business accounts is 1.50% with a $0.50 minimum. Our breakdown of Stripe fees beyond the headline rate covers the rest of Stripe's add-ons.
Cross-Border Cards and Currency Conversion
Selling abroad adds two separate charges. The cross-border fee applies when the card was issued outside the U.S., and here the two companies match: Stripe adds 1.5% and PayPal adds 1.50%.
Currency conversion is where they split. It applies only when money changes currency, for example when you price in euros and get paid in dollars. Stripe adds 1% to the conversion. PayPal's fee schedule applies a 4.00% spread above the base exchange rate on payment conversions, according to FeeFigure's check against PayPal's July 2026 page. On $5,000 a month of converted sales, that's about $50 at Stripe and $200 at PayPal, before the cross-border fee.
So if a meaningful share of your revenue comes from foreign customers, run the comparison on those sales alone. A business with real international volume may do better with an account built for multi-currency and cross-border acceptance. There, the settlement currency and conversion terms are reviewed for your business instead of taken from a public price list.
Dispute Fees Work Differently on Each Platform
Stripe treats a dispute as a card network chargeback, or the equivalent for other payment methods. It charges a $15 dispute received fee on every dispute and keeps it even if you win. Responding manually adds a $15 dispute countered fee, which Stripe returns if you win. Appealing costs another $15 that you don't get back. Stripe's page also says network fees apply in rare cases.
PayPal runs two tracks. For payments made through a buyer's PayPal account or Guest Checkout, claims and chargebacks carry a $15 standard dispute fee. That rises to a $30 high-volume fee when your dispute ratio reaches 1.5% and you had more than 100 sales in the prior three full calendar months, according to Chargeflow's reading of PayPal's fee page. Card payments processed outside a PayPal account carry a separate $20 chargeback fee. PayPal's User Agreement says the standard dispute fee isn't charged on disputes decided in your favor.
That clears up a common assumption. On Stripe, every dispute costs at least $15, win or lose. On a PayPal Checkout payment at the standard rate, a dispute you win costs nothing in fees.
Stripe's countered fee also turns each response into a small bet. Here's an illustrative way to decide. Take a $25 order with a 30% chance of winning. Countering puts $15 at risk with a 70% chance of losing it, an expected cost of $10.50, to recover an expected $7.50. On dollars alone, that one isn't worth fighting. Raise the order to $100 and the expected recovery becomes $30, so you respond. The number to track is your own win rate by reason code.
One more point gets confused often. A processor's dispute fee is not a Visa or Mastercard penalty. Network monitoring programs are separate and apply only when dispute and fraud levels stay high (how Visa's VAMP thresholds work). Either platform can act long before you reach a network threshold, so the steps that cut disputes early pay off on both.
Payout Holds and Account Reviews
Signup is easy on both platforms because the close look at your business comes later, after money is already moving. Each company keeps reviewing accounts after approval. Either one can delay payouts or hold a reserve, which is a share of your sales kept back to cover future refunds and disputes. PayPal is known for holding payments to newer sellers until delivery is confirmed or a set period passes. Stripe generally pays out on a rolling schedule but can lengthen it or add a reserve after a risk review. Both user agreements give the provider wide discretion, and the triggers look alike:
- a sudden jump in volume or ticket size
- rising refund or dispute rates
- preorders or long fulfillment windows
- business details that differ from what you described at signup
- products in restricted categories
You can get ahead of most of these. Describe your business accurately when you apply, and tell the provider before a launch or seasonal spike, not after. Keep tracking and delivery records for every order so you have something to send when a review starts. If you sell in a category either company restricts, apply for a high-risk merchant account from the start. An account closed in the middle of your busy season costs far more than an underwriting review up front. If it has already happened, read what to do after Stripe closes your account.
What a PayPal Button Has to Earn at Checkout
Some buyers would rather not type a card number into a store they don't know. Others are on a phone where PayPal already has their address. On the other side, every extra button adds a decision, and the PayPal pop-up gives the buyer one more place to abandon the order. We don't know of an independent, current figure that predicts your lift, so measure it on your own traffic.
A Worked Break-Even Example at Current Rates
Illustrative store. The fees use the published U.S. rates above. Sales, margin, the share that moves to PayPal and staff cost are assumptions.
Assume $40,000 a month in online sales at an $80 average order (500 orders) and a 40% gross margin. Cards run through Stripe at 2.9% + $0.30. You add a PayPal button, and 150 orders (30%) move to PayPal Checkout at 3.49% + $0.49.
Each order that moves costs $3.28 instead of $2.62, or $0.66 more. Across 150 orders, that's $99.30 a month. A new order brings in $32 of margin, or $28.72 after PayPal's fee, so it takes four new orders to cover $99.30. Add an assumed $80 a month of staff time to reconcile a second payout source, and the monthly cost becomes $179.30. Now you need seven new orders on top of 500 to break even, a 1.4% lift.
The bar is low, which is why many stores keep the button. It still has to be cleared. Switch the button on and off in alternating weeks, or split traffic if your platform supports it. Then compare total orders, not the share that went through PayPal. If PayPal mostly picks up buyers who would have paid by card anyway, you're paying more for the same sales. Placement matters too (hosted vs. embedded checkout conversion).
Subscriptions and Developer Tools: Where Stripe Pulls Ahead
For recurring revenue, Stripe's billing product is the fuller toolkit. It handles plans, proration, payment retries and customer portals through an API built for developers. Renewals on stored cards also benefit from network tokens that cut failed renewals, and a solid dunning process for failed payments recovers more of the rest.
PayPal subscriptions run on billing agreements that the buyer approves and manages inside their PayPal account. Buyers can cancel there without ever visiting your site. The bigger issue is portability. Stripe has a process for exporting stored card data to another PCI DSS-compliant processor, so ask about it before you need it. PayPal billing agreements stay in PayPal, so if you leave, expect to ask those subscribers to sign up again. On either platform, your renewal disclosures have to meet state law (automatic renewal law requirements). Treat that as general information and confirm the details with your attorney.
PayPal or Stripe for Small Business, or a Merchant Account
| Your situation | Reasonable starting point |
|---|---|
| New store, low volume, launching this week | One aggregator for cards, plus a PayPal button if testing shows lift |
| Small tickets such as digital downloads | Compare the fixed fee first; it outweighs the percentage |
| Subscriptions or a custom app | API-based card billing; avoid putting most subscribers on wallet billing agreements |
| Large international buyer base | Compare conversion costs on those sales alone |
| Steady volume, tired of surprise holds | Individually underwritten merchant account with a gateway |
| Restricted or high-risk category | Underwritten high-risk account from day one |
A merchant account is underwritten before you go live, so reserve terms and pricing are set out up front. Your processor can still change terms if your risk changes, but surprises are less likely than with a provider that underwrites after signup. The account connects to a gateway such as Authorize.Net or NMI, and from there to carts like Shopify or WooCommerce (how to choose a payment gateway provider). MannyPay offers online payment processing and merchant accounts for low- and high-risk businesses, with pricing and approval subject to underwriting. If you're leaving PayPal, our guide to PayPal alternatives with fewer holds covers the options.
Before you choose, pull last quarter's statements from each platform. Work out three numbers: your effective rate by payment type, the share of volume that came from foreign cards or needed currency conversion, and your dispute count and win rate. Then request a free processing quote and compare it line by line. A MannyPay specialist responds within one business day.
Sources
- PayPal Merchant Fees (U.S.)
- PayPal U.S. Merchant Fees, effective October 1, 2026 (PDF)
- Stripe Pricing & Fees
- Checkout Page: Stripe Fees 2026, Every Rate and What a $100 Sale Nets You
- Chargeflow: PayPal Fee Calculator (U.S. dispute, chargeback and refund fees)
- Tagada: PayPal Chargebacks (dispute fee rules from PayPal's User Agreement)
- FeeFigure: PayPal Fees, With Source and Check Date for Each Figure
- FeeProbe: PayPal Fees Calculator (US)
This article is for general educational purposes and is not legal, tax or financial advice. Card network rules and state laws change; confirm current requirements for your business.


