Fraudsters Reuse the Same Fake Bank Accounts: Merchant Defenses
Fake bank accounts fraud often reuses one account against many victims. Learn to screen refund, payout and vendor accounts so repeat offenders get caught.

Photo: Pixabay
On this page 6 sections
- What the Report Found, and Where the Numbers Come From
- Where Fake Bank Accounts Fraud Touches Your Business
- Why Reuse Gives Defenders an Edge
- Bank Account Verification Tools and What Each One Proves
- Red Flags in Bank-Change and Refund Requests
- Changes to Make in Your Refund and Payout Workflows This Quarter
Key takeaways
- Sis ID's network data shows one fraudulent account used against an average of 34 companies. That figure comes from a single vendor and mostly covers international B2B payments, so it isn't an industry-wide statistic.
- Validating a bank account shows that the account works. It doesn't show the account is clean, because a money mule account passes micro-deposits and login checks.
- A hashed account fingerprint checked across customers, sellers and vendors is a cheap way to catch an account the second time it shows up.
- Send refunds back to the original payment method by default, and hold the first payment to any new or changed bank account until someone verifies it.
Criminals who open or rent bank accounts for fraud don't use them once. PaymentsJournal's Nov. 11, 2026 analysis by Wesley Grant, "Criminals Often Use the Same Fake Bank Accounts in Multiple Schemes," makes that point, and the figures circulating with it come from French payment-security firm Sis ID: one fraudulent account is used against an average of 34 companies in its network. That repetition is the weak spot in fake bank accounts fraud. If you check every account that receives your money against the accounts you've already seen, a reused account can get caught on its second attempt instead of its thirty-fourth.
What the Report Found, and Where the Numbers Come From
The data first surfaced in a Reuters report on Nov. 10. Patrice Bouexel, president of Sis ID, told Reuters that criminals repeatedly use the same fraudulent bank accounts to target multiple businesses. According to the company's internal data:
- A single fraudulent account was used against an average of 34 companies in Sis ID's network.
- As of late October, the firm had identified and blocked more than 14,000 fraudulent International Bank Account Numbers (IBANs) in 2026.
- 36% of its automated verification decisions relied on information contributed by other businesses in the network.
Bouexel said the scale points to organized criminal networks, not lone fraudsters. He told Reuters that many fraudulent traces originate in the Asia-Pacific region or Russia, and that large scam operations in countries such as Myanmar use people forced to work under coercive conditions.
Two caveats before you act on the numbers. First, these are observations from one vendor's network, not an industry-wide statistic, a point the Payments:Unpacked newsletter also flagged. Second, an IBAN is the international account format used in Europe and many other regions. U.S. domestic payments use a routing number plus an account number, so the data mainly describes cross-border, business-to-business payment redirection. The pattern still carries over to U.S. merchants. Each account a criminal opens, buys or recruits takes effort, so it gets used until someone blocks it.
Where Fake Bank Accounts Fraud Touches Your Business
Most merchants think about fraud at checkout. Fake and mule accounts show up on the other side of the ledger, wherever money leaves your business or where a bank account is the payment method. A money mule account is a real, open account controlled by someone who moves criminal proceeds, whether they know it or not. Four places matter most:
- Refunds sent to a bank account. Refund fraud often starts with a purchase on a stolen card, then a request to send the refund by bank transfer "because the card was closed." The card owner disputes the original charge, and you've paid twice.
- Seller, affiliate and creator payouts. Online marketplaces and platforms that pay out earnings face payout fraud from fake seller profiles and from takeovers of real ones, where the first move is changing the payout account. Our piece on how deepfakes fuel account takeovers covers that front door.
- Vendor bank-change requests. B2B and wholesale businesses, and anyone who pays suppliers, get emails asking to send future invoices to "our new bank." This is the scheme Sis ID's data describes most directly.
- ACH debits you accept. Subscription businesses and B2B sellers that take bank payments can receive an account number that belongs to someone else. The goods ship, the real owner reports the debit as unauthorized, and the money comes back out of your account.
Why Reuse Gives Defenders an Edge
A fraudster can generate a new email address, device and shipping name in minutes. A working bank account is harder to replace. That makes the destination account one of the most stable identifiers in a fraud ring, and the cheapest one for you to track.
The practical tool is an account fingerprint: a hashed or tokenized version of the routing and account number, stored so you can compare accounts without keeping raw numbers in every system. Check that fingerprint whenever an account is added or changed, across customer profiles, seller profiles and your vendor master file. Matches across unrelated records are the signal.
Here's what that does to exposure, using illustrative numbers. Assume a marketplace pays sellers weekly. A fraud ring opens five seller profiles over six weeks, each built on sales paid with stolen cards, and all five send payouts to the same bank account. Each profile reaches $1,800 in pending payouts before the chargebacks arrive.
| Scenario | Payouts released | Amount exposed |
|---|---|---|
| No account linking | 5 profiles × $1,800 | $9,000 |
| Hold payouts when an account is already attached to another profile | First profile only | $1,800 |
The linking rule keeps $7,200 inside the business in this example, and the chargebacks on the first profile still need handling. One business will rarely see the same account 34 times, because Sis ID's average counts reuse across different companies. Catching the cross-company pattern requires shared data, which is why fraud data sharing between businesses is getting renewed attention.
Bank Account Verification Tools and What Each One Proves
Bank account verification is a stack of checks that answer different questions. The table below compares the common methods. Availability, speed and pricing depend on your bank, processor or verification vendor, so confirm current terms with them.
| Method | What it confirms | What it doesn't confirm |
|---|---|---|
| Routing number check | The routing number belongs to a real institution | Anything about the account itself |
| Account status check through a data network | The account exists and is open | Who controls it or why |
| Ownership or name match | The name on the account matches the payee you expect | Legitimacy, if the mule is the named payee |
| Micro-deposits | The payee can see activity in the account | Legitimacy; they take days, not seconds |
| Bank login (pay by bank) | The person can sign in to the account | Whether the account is a mule |
| Shared negative databases | Others have reported the account in fraud | New accounts nobody has flagged yet |
The rule merchants most often misunderstand is that account validation proves an account works, not that it's clean. A money mule account is real and open, and the mule can confirm micro-deposits or log in without trouble. The name match only catches fraud when the name should belong to someone else, such as your vendor's legal entity or the customer who originally paid. That gap is why validation and reuse linking need to run together.
If you originate ACH debits, the ACH network's operating rules set fraud-screening expectations, and your bank or processor can tell you what applies to you. Open banking also affects how bank logins get used for verification; see where the Section 1033 open banking rule stands. If you're weighing it at checkout, our guide to when pay by bank for ecommerce cuts fees covers ACH return rules and Nacha limits. This is general information, not legal advice, so confirm your obligations with your bank and a qualified professional.
Red Flags in Bank-Change and Refund Requests
Vendor Bank-Change Requests
- The request arrives by email only, often with a reply-to address that differs slightly from the vendor's domain.
- It lands just before a large invoice is due, with pressure to pay quickly.
- The new account sits at a bank in a different country or state from the vendor's operations.
- The account name doesn't match the vendor's legal name, or comes back as an individual.
- The sender pushes back on a callback or offers a new phone number to "confirm."
Refund-to-New-Account Requests
- A customer who paid by card asks for the refund by bank transfer, wire or a payment app.
- An "accidental overpayment" is followed by a request to refund the difference to a different account.
- The refund request comes soon after a first-time purchase, especially a high-value one.
- The same destination account appears on refund requests from customers with different names.
- The account holder name doesn't match the name on the original order.
None of these proves fraud alone. Two or more on the same request should stop it until someone verifies through a channel you already trust.
Changes to Make in Your Refund and Payout Workflows This Quarter
- Map every outbound flow. List refunds, seller payouts, affiliate commissions and vendor payments, plus everyone who can change a destination account in each one.
- Refund to the original payment method by default. Card refunds go back to the card. Exceptions need a second approver and a documented reason; your merchant agreement likely addresses this too.
- Fingerprint and compare. Store a hashed account fingerprint and check it at every add or change event across customers, sellers and vendors.
- Validate before the first payment. Use ownership or name matching for payouts and vendors, with micro-deposits as a fallback when instant checks aren't available.
- Hold the first payment after any change. Set a review period, measured in days, for the first payout or vendor payment to a new account.
- Call back on a known number. Verify vendor changes using the contact on file, never the one in the request, and require two people to approve the change.
- Screen the ACH debits you accept. Validate accounts at enrollment and watch returns marked unauthorized, which often trace back to a stolen account number.
- Feed confirmed fraud back in. Add bad accounts to a block list and decide whether a shared-data network is worth joining.
The card side matters too, because stolen-card purchases are often what create the refunds and seller balances fraudsters cash out. 3-D Secure authentication for online card payments adds a cardholder check before a stolen card can fund those balances, and international payout recipients should go through OFAC sanctions screening for online sellers.
Start with your vendor master file and your refund exception log. Pull every bank account changed or added in the last 90 days and run the fingerprint comparison once by hand. If the same account shows up twice under different names, you've found your first rule. To review how your online payment processing setup handles refunds, ACH and authentication, request a free quote; a MannyPay specialist responds within one business day.
Sources
- PaymentsJournal, Wesley Grant author page: "Criminals Often Use the Same Fake Bank Accounts in Multiple Schemes" (Nov. 11, 2026)
- Reuters via SRN News: "Criminals reuse fake bank accounts to scam dozens of businesses, payment security firm says" (Nov. 10, 2026)
- Reuters via 104.9 The Wolf (same Reuters report, includes the 36% figure)
- AML Intelligence: "Criminals reuse fake bank accounts to scam dozens of businesses, payment security firm says"
- Payments:Unpacked: "Who Holds The Keys?"
This article is for general educational purposes and is not legal, tax or financial advice. Card network rules and state laws change; confirm current requirements for your business.


