OCC Preemption: Illinois Interchange Fee Lawsuit Explained
Payments News

Merchants Sue the OCC Over Illinois Swipe Fee Preemption

Nine merchant groups filed an OCC preemption lawsuit over Illinois' interchange fee law. See how it differs from the appeal and how to prep tax and tip data.

Iced cocktail on a bar counter beside a cocktail shaker, strainer and empty glass, with blurred liquor bottles behind

Photo: Pixabay

On this page 6 sections
  1. What Happened in the OCC Preemption Lawsuit Over Illinois Interchange Fees
  2. The NRF Lawsuit Against the OCC and NCUA: Process and Power
  3. How the Illinois Interchange Fee Prohibition Act Federal Lawsuit Fits With the Seventh Circuit Appeal
  4. What Illinois Merchants Pay in Interchange on Sales Tax and Tips
  5. What to Do Now: Separate Tax and Tip Amounts in Your POS Data
  6. What Merchants in Other States Can Learn From This

Key takeaways

  • Nothing changes at checkout yet. The IFPA now takes effect July 1, 2027, and the current injunction covers national banks, out-of-state banks, card networks and federal credit unions.
  • The D.C. suits go after the OCC and NCUA rules themselves. The Seventh Circuit appeal reviews an injunction that rests on those rules, so a merchant win in D.C. could weaken it.
  • In the illustrative restaurant example, tax and tips make up about 22% of card volume, so a restaurant would gain far more from the law than a store that collects no tips.
  • Making sure each transaction record carries separate tax and tip amounts costs little now, and no carve-out can work without that data.

Nine merchant trade groups went to federal court in Washington, D.C., on Nov. 12, 2026, to overturn the OCC preemption that has kept Illinois' interchange fee law from reaching national banks. Their two suits ask the court to throw out the rules the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC) and the National Credit Union Administration (NCUA) used to shield federally chartered banks and credit unions from the Illinois Interchange Fee Prohibition Act (IFPA). Nothing changes at your terminal yet. The law's effective date is now July 1, 2027, and a federal injunction still blocks it for most of the card industry.

The IFPA would bar interchange, the fee the card-issuing bank earns on each sale, on the sales tax and tip portions of a card transaction. For a full-service restaurant, that can be a large slice of every ticket. That's why restaurant and grocery groups have backed the law since Gov. JB Pritzker signed it in June 2024.

What Happened in the OCC Preemption Lawsuit Over Illinois Interchange Fees

Payments Dive reported the filings on Nov. 12. The nine plaintiffs are:

  • National Retail Federation (NRF)
  • National Grocers Association
  • FMI (The Food Industry Association)
  • National Association of Convenience Stores
  • Retail Industry Leaders Association's Retail Litigation Center
  • National Restaurant Association's Restaurant Law Center
  • Illinois Retail Merchants Association
  • Illinois Fuel and Retail Association
  • Illinois Restaurant Association

Both cases are in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia, according to the NRF's announcement.

The merchant groups estimate the law would save Illinois merchants and their customers about $500 million a year. That figure comes from the law's backers, not from an independent study. On the other side, an OCC spokesperson declined to comment. A payments trade association whose members include Visa and PayPal told Payments Dive it expects to beat the suit. The Illinois Credit Union League called the lawsuits an effort to preserve a "fundamentally flawed" law.

The NRF Lawsuit Against the OCC and NCUA: Process and Power

The first argument is about procedure. The OCC announced its interim final order preempting the IFPA on April 24, 2026, and published it in the Federal Register on April 29 (91 Fed. Reg. 23150). Comments were due May 29, and the order took effect June 30, so the public could comment only after it was issued.

That timing is the problem, according to the merchants. Section 43 of Title 12 of the U.S. Code generally requires the OCC to give notice and at least 30 days for comment before it issues an interpretive rule or opinion letter saying federal law preempts certain state laws. The OCC's own order acknowledges that requirement and argues it doesn't apply here. The merchants disagree. Their complaint says the OCC "skipped over the notice-and-comment procedures required by the Administrative Procedure Act and the National Bank Act," as Grocery Dive reported.

The second argument is about whether the National Bank Act preempts a state limit on swipe fees at all. Under the Supreme Court's Barnett Bank standard, a state law is preempted if it prevents or significantly interferes with a national bank's federally granted powers. In her Feb. 10, 2026 ruling, U.S. District Judge Virginia Kendall found that Illinois' interchange limit passed that test, largely because card networks, not banks, set interchange rates.

The OCC responded with a companion interim final rule (OCC Bulletin 2026-18). It says national banks may charge non-interest fees, including interchange, whether the bank sets the fee or a third party does. The merchants counter that the IFPA regulates the card networks' business rather than the business of banking. They also argue that merchants pay these fees to banks they have no banking relationship with.

The NCUA suit makes the same case against the credit union regulator. It argues that the Federal Credit Union Act doesn't preempt the Illinois law, that the Act's preemption language differs from the National Bank Act's, and that the NCUA also skipped required notice and comment.

How the Illinois Interchange Fee Prohibition Act Federal Lawsuit Fits With the Seventh Circuit Appeal

The case history explains why merchants opened a second front:

DateEvent
June 2024Gov. Pritzker signs the IFPA
August 2024Bank and credit union trade groups sue Illinois Attorney General Kwame Raoul
Feb. 10, 2026Judge Kendall upholds the interchange limit and blocks the law's data-use limit
April 24–29, 2026OCC issues its interim final rule and preemption order
May 2026Seventh Circuit vacates the ruling and sends the case back so the district court can consider the OCC's action
June 2026Judge Kendall rules the law preempted, citing the OCC rule
September 2026Injunction expanded to federal credit unions after the NCUA issues a similar rule
October 2026Raoul appeals to the Seventh Circuit; bank groups cross-appeal
Nov. 12, 2026Merchant groups sue the OCC and NCUA in D.C.

The Seventh Circuit case, Illinois Bankers Association v. Raoul, pits bank and credit union groups against the state. Merchant groups have filed friend-of-the-court briefs there but aren't parties to the case. The appeals court decides whether Judge Kendall got preemption right, and her June and September rulings rest on the agencies' rules.

The D.C. suits go after those rules directly. The merchants are suing the agencies themselves. They want the court to set the rules aside and declare that federal law doesn't preempt the Illinois statute.

If the merchants win, the current injunction loses much of its legal footing, and Illinois could press that point in its appeal. If they lose, the appeal still goes on. Illinois officials have separately told the Seventh Circuit that the OCC made no effort to comply with the Administrative Procedure Act. Two courts are now looking at overlapping questions, and either could rule first.

What Illinois Merchants Pay in Interchange on Sales Tax and Tips

Today you pay interchange on the full amount of every card sale, tax and tip included. That won't change on July 1, 2027, unless a court changes the picture. Judge Kendall's injunction now covers national banks, state banks chartered outside Illinois, payment card networks and federal credit unions. Because the networks set interchange, the law has little left to apply to.

Here is roughly what the law would be worth, using illustrative numbers only:

  • Restaurant (illustrative): $50,000 a month in pre-tax food and drink sales paid by card. Assume a 10% combined sales tax rate (a round number for easy math; use your actual rate) and an 18% average tip on the pre-tax amount. Tax is $5,000 and tips are $9,000, so card volume is $64,000, and $14,000 of it is tax and tip. At an assumed average interchange cost of 2.0%, that's $280 a month, or $3,360 a year, in interchange on money that goes to the state and your staff.
  • Grocery, liquor or retail store (illustrative): The same $50,000 in pre-tax card sales and the same assumed 10% tax, with no tips. Interchange on the $5,000 of tax at 2.0% is $100 a month, or $1,200 a year.

The 2.0% is an assumption, not a network rate. Real interchange varies by card type, by how the card is accepted and by merchant category. The example also leaves out per-transaction fees and your processor's markup. Redo the math with the effective interchange rate on your own statement.

Grocers have one more thing to check. A mixed basket can carry different tax rates on different items, so the tax total on each transaction matters more than a single store-wide rate.

What to Do Now: Separate Tax and Tip Amounts in Your POS Data

However the cases end, interchange can only be taken off tax and tips if someone can show the tax and tip amount on each transaction. Getting ready costs little and helps your bookkeeping either way.

  1. Confirm tax is captured per transaction. Pull a transaction-level report, not a daily summary, and check that sales tax appears as its own field on each sale.
  2. Record tips as tips. In bars and full-service dining rooms, tips are often added after the card is authorized. Confirm the adjusted tip amount reaches the settled transaction record. Keep mandatory service charges and auto-gratuities in a separate category from voluntary tips, because a rule might treat them differently.
  3. Ask what your terminal sends. If a cashier keys a single total into a standalone terminal, the terminal has no tax or tip figure to pass along. An integrated POS system that sends itemized amounts is in a better position. Ask your processor, in writing, which fields reach them.
  4. Check online checkout. E-commerce platforms calculate tax as a separate line. Confirm your gateway passes that amount with the authorization rather than just the order total.
  5. Don't change prices or receipts yet. The law isn't in effect, and the injunction still stands.

Earlier rounds are covered in our pieces on the Illinois interchange law's delays and the original bank lawsuit and what merchants should do during the Illinois swipe fee law appeal. If you want to lower card costs without waiting on the courts, compliant programs such as dual pricing for restaurants and stores are available today, subject to card network rules and state law. See also our options for restaurant and bar payments and grocery market processing.

What Merchants in Other States Can Learn From This

The trade groups told the court the OCC's action would "chill other States" from passing similar laws. That's what's at stake for merchants outside Illinois. If the OCC rule survives, a federal regulator could declare a state interchange law preempted for national banks within weeks, before the law takes effect, and take public comment only afterward.

The practical lesson is that a state swipe-fee law passing doesn't mean a lower statement soon. Illinois signed its law in June 2024, and nearly two and a half years later it still hasn't applied to a single transaction. Federal proposals such as the Credit Card Competition Act are a separate fight on their own timeline. Budget around your actual processing contract, not pending legislation.

This article is general information, not legal advice. Talk to a qualified attorney about how these cases affect your business.

Next, watch for the OCC's and NCUA's responses in D.C. and the briefing schedule in Raoul's Seventh Circuit appeal. This week, pull one day of transactions and check whether tax and tips show up as separate amounts. If they don't, request a free quote, and a MannyPay specialist will respond within one business day to review your setup.

Sources

  1. Payments Dive: Merchants sue feds over Illinois card fee law (Nov. 12, 2026)
  2. National Retail Federation: Merchants File Lawsuits Challenging 'Slapdash' OCC and NCUA Rules
  3. Grocery Dive: Merchants sue feds over Illinois card fee law
  4. Federal Register: Order Preempting the Illinois Interchange Fee Prohibition Act, 91 Fed. Reg. 23150 (Apr. 29, 2026)
  5. OCC Bulletin 2026-17: Preemption of Illinois Interchange Fee Prohibition Act, Interim Final Order
  6. VitalLaw: Merchant groups challenge OCC, NCUA actions to thwart Illinois swipe fee law (cites OCC Bulletin 2026-18)
  7. Digital Transactions: Merchants File Two Lawsuits Over OCC and NCUA Handling of Illinois Interchange Law
  8. Credit Union Daily: Illinois League Calls New Lawsuits an Effort to Preserve 'Fundamentally Flawed' Law
  9. Chain Drug Review: FMI joins retailers challenging federal swipe fee rules
  10. Chicago City Wire: Illinois merchant groups sue federal regulators over swipe fee rules
  11. CU Today: Illinois AG Appeals Ruling Shielding Federal Credit Unions From Interchange Law
  12. Payments Dive via Yahoo Finance: Appeals court remands Illinois card fee case (May 2026)
  13. Payments Dive: OCC aims to derail state card law
  14. Hinshaw & Culbertson: The OCC Weighs in on Seventh Circuit Appeal of Illinois' Swipe-Fee Law (Feb. 10, 2026 ruling)
  15. Latham & Watkins: OCC Preempts Illinois Interchange Fee Law
  16. Ballard Spahr Consumer Finance Monitor: OCC Doubles Down on Interchange Fee Preemption (comment and effective dates)

About the author

Adrian Reyes

Adrian Reyes is Senior Payments & Fintech Editor for Beyond the Swipe, covering credit card processing, merchant accounts, payment technology and processing fees.

This article is for general educational purposes and is not legal, tax or financial advice. Card network rules and state laws change; confirm current requirements for your business.

Related reading