Visa-Mastercard Settlement Approval Hearing: What to Do
Payments News

Visa and Mastercard Defend Their $38B Fee Deal in Court: What to Do

The Visa-Mastercard settlement approval hearing ended without a ruling. Estimate your savings from the 0.1-point cut and 1.25% cap, and what to ask now.

Inside an independent record store with rows of CD bins, yellow genre signs overhead and staff at the counter

Photo: Pixabay

On this page 7 sections
  1. What Happened at the Visa-Mastercard Settlement Approval Hearing
  2. The Terms: A 0.1-Point Cut for Five Years and a 1.25% Cap for Eight
  3. Who Backs the Deal and Why Swipe Fee Settlement Objections Keep Coming
  4. Estimate the Interchange Settlement's Impact on Your Card Mix
  5. Will Your Processor Pass the Savings on? Questions for Your Rep
  6. What the Judge's Decision Could Mean, and How Long Appeals Take
  7. Merchant Checklist While You Wait for the Judge

Key takeaways

  • The 0.1-point cut is an average across each network's credit volume. Your own cut depends on your card mix, and debit, American Express and Discover sales don't change.
  • In an illustrative $80,000-a-month restaurant, the deal is worth about $48 to $60 a month. That works out to 0.06% to 0.075% of total card sales, not 0.1%.
  • On flat-rate or tiered pricing, a lower interchange rate doesn't reach you unless your processor lowers your rate. Ask now and get the answer in writing.
  • Don't refuse card categories or change surcharges until a final order sets an effective date. If the deal is approved, analysts expect objectors to appeal, which could delay the effective date.

At Monday's Visa-Mastercard settlement approval hearing in Brooklyn, the card networks asked U.S. District Judge Brian Cogan to grant final approval to their $38 billion deal with merchants. He did not rule from the bench. So as of Nov. 16, 2026, nothing on your processing statement changes yet. What you can do now is measure how much of your volume the deal would actually touch, find out whether your pricing plan would pass a cut through to you, and hold off on refusing card types or adding new surcharges until there is a final order.

The fee terms are small in percentage points but long in duration. Reuters reported that the deal requires Visa and Mastercard to lower swipe fees by 0.1 percentage point for five years and to cap fees on standard consumer cards at 1.25% for eight years.

What Happened at the Visa-Mastercard Settlement Approval Hearing

Lawyers for the networks told Cogan the settlement is a fair compromise that fundamentally changes Visa's and Mastercard's decades-old relationships with merchants, according to Reuters' account published by GV Wire. Visa's lawyer, Michael Shuster, called the relief "potent" and said the network isn't thrilled with the changes. Cogan made no decision, but he said rejecting the deal could lead to a "protracted process" if the 21-year-old case went to trial.

History explains the caution. In June, Cogan granted preliminary approval, called the settlement "fair, reasonable, and adequate" and said he was likely to grant final approval, Reuters reported at the time. Before him, Judge Margo Brodie rejected a $30 billion version in June 2024, finding fees would remain above where they'd be without the alleged antitrust violations and that merchants would still be bound by the Honor All Cards rule. A federal appeals court also threw out an earlier settlement in 2016, according to Payments Dive.

The class covers more than 12 million merchants. For background, see our preview of what's at stake in final approval.

The Terms: A 0.1-Point Cut for Five Years and a 1.25% Cap for Eight

These are terms of a proposed class-action settlement that would change Visa and Mastercard network rules. None of it is law, and none of it takes effect without court approval.

The 0.1-Point Cut Is a Network Average

Interchange is the fee the card-issuing bank collects on each sale, and it is usually the largest piece of what you pay to accept a card. The settlement would trim credit interchange by 10 basis points (0.1 percentage point) for five years. Here is the part most coverage skips: as Retail Dive reported, the networks committed to lower the "combined average effective credit interchange rate" by ten basis points. That is an average across credit volume on each network. It does not promise that each of your transactions drops by exactly 0.10%; your cut depends on which rate categories move and how much of your volume runs through them.

Two other limits matter. The deal is about credit cards, so your debit volume is untouched; debit fees run under a separate federal rule covered in our explainer on the Fed debit fee cap and Regulation II. And it covers Visa and Mastercard only, not American Express or Discover.

The 1.25% Cap Applies to Standard Cards Only

Standard consumer cards would be capped at 1.25% for eight years. Premium rewards cards and commercial cards are outside that cap. Doug Kantor of the National Association of Convenience Stores argued that many standard, non-premium cards already carry interchange rates below 1.25%, per Retail Dive. If that holds on your statement, the cap works more as a ceiling against future increases than as a cut today. Retail Dive also reported that posted credit rates would be capped for five years and that the eight-year term starts with the court's approval.

Honor All Cards Loosens by Category

The settlement would end the Honor All Cards rule in its current form, which requires merchants to take every Visa or Mastercard card or none. Merchants could instead choose among three categories: commercial cards, premium consumer cards (including rewards cards), and standard consumer cards. You could not, however, accept one bank's cards and refuse another's. Merchants would also get more room to surcharge.

Whether to use that choice depends on your customers. A restaurant near office parks that refuses commercial cards turns away expense-account lunches and catering orders. A grocery market lives on repeat weekly baskets from shoppers who may carry one rewards card for everything. An online store that blocks a card category at checkout risks an abandoned cart, so ask your gateway whether it can identify the card category at checkout before you write any rule around it.

Who Backs the Deal and Why Swipe Fee Settlement Objections Keep Coming

Supporters include the Electronic Payments Coalition, whose members include Visa, Mastercard and large issuers such as Bank of America, Capital One, Chase and Citibank. In an October filing, the networks told the court that Walmart and several large trade associations were "no more than a vocal minority" given the size of the class, Payments Dive reported.

The opposition is still large. Reuters reported the court received slightly more than 1,000 objections, including from Walmart and the National Retail Federation. At the hearing, Mithun Mansinghani, representing the National Association of Convenience Stores and Circle K, argued the deal creates no structural reforms that would make banks compete on fees, and that rates stay too high on commercial and premium cards, which he said make up more than 90% of the card market.

The Merchants Payments Coalition's objection, summarized by Credit Union Daily, put the average Visa and Mastercard credit swipe fee at 2.36% in 2025 and said the cut would only return the average to roughly its 2023 level. The group also objected to the scope and duration of the release of legal claims. A release is what class members give up in exchange for the relief: the right to sue the networks and banks over the covered conduct for the period the release lasts. This is general information, not legal advice; talk to an attorney about your own position.

Estimate the Interchange Settlement's Impact on Your Card Mix

Here is an illustrative example. Every number is assumed, not drawn from a real merchant.

Assumptions: a full-service restaurant processes $80,000 a month in card sales. Visa and Mastercard credit is 60% ($48,000), debit is 30% ($24,000), and American Express and Discover are 10% ($8,000). Of the credit volume, $6,000 a month is standard consumer cards at an assumed average interchange of 1.45%. The merchant is on interchange-plus pricing, and the restaurant's mix moves exactly in line with the network average.

Piece of the mixMonthly volumeSettlement effectMonthly savings
Visa/Mastercard credit$48,0000.10-point average cut$48
Standard consumer cards (within credit)$6,0001.45% capped at 1.25%up to $12
Debit$24,000Not covered$0
American Express and Discover$8,000Not covered$0

The cut alone is worth $48 a month, $576 a year, or $2,880 over five years. The cap could add up to $12 a month, but it overlaps with the average cut, so treat $48 to $60 a month as the range. On total card sales, that is 0.06% to 0.075%, which is smaller than the 0.1-point headline because debit and other brands don't move.

The decision this gives you: compare that $48 to $60 with what you control today. If your processor's markup, a monthly fee or an inflated network fee line costs more than that, fixing your pricing is worth more than the settlement. Our guide to card brand fees, assessments and FANF shows where those lines sit. Online and keyed sales deserve their own check: public reports don't say how the average cut will be spread between card-present and card-not-present rate categories, so an e-commerce store should not assume it gets exactly 0.10%.

Will Your Processor Pass the Savings on? Questions for Your Rep

Visa and Mastercard set interchange. Your processor's price sits on top of it, and your pricing model decides who keeps a cut. On interchange-plus (also called pass-through) pricing, lower interchange shows up as lower cost as long as the markup stays the same. On flat-rate or tiered pricing, you pay the same rate regardless, so a cut widens the processor's margin unless it reprices. If you run a surcharging program or dual pricing, a lower cost of acceptance may mean recalculating what you charge card customers.

Ask your rep, and get the answers in writing:

  1. Which pricing model am I on, and does my agreement pass interchange changes through at cost?
  2. If the settlement is approved, when would new rates appear on my statement?
  3. If I'm on flat-rate or tiered pricing, will you lower my rate to reflect the cut?
  4. Are any fee increases scheduled for the same period that would offset it?
  5. Can my terminal, POS or gateway identify commercial, premium and standard cards if I later choose to decline or surcharge one category?

What the Judge's Decision Could Mean, and How Long Appeals Take

Final approval. Objectors have signaled further challenges, and analysts expect an appeal. American Banker reported that analysts predict the settlement may not be fully final until 2029. Watch for the implementation schedule in any final order, because that tells you when rates actually change.

Rejection. The case heads back toward trial, which is the "protracted process" Cogan warned about.

Legislation is a separate track; see where the Credit Card Competition Act stands.

Merchant Checklist While You Wait for the Judge

  1. Pull your last three statements and split volume into Visa/Mastercard credit, debit and other brands.
  2. Run the math from the example above on your own numbers.
  3. Confirm your pricing model and ask the five questions above.
  4. Don't refuse card categories or change surcharges until a final order sets the effective date, and check your state's surcharge rules with a qualified professional first.
  5. Note which customers pay with commercial or premium cards, so you can decide quickly if the rules change.

If your statement math shows your current pricing costs more than the settlement would save, start there. You can request a free quote from MannyPay, and a specialist responds within one business day. The open question to watch is the timing of Cogan's ruling, and whether an appeal delays the effective date.

Sources

  1. Visa, Mastercard Urge Approval of $38 Billion Swipe Fee Settlement (Reuters via GV Wire, Nov. 16, 2026)
  2. Visa, Mastercard urge approval of $38 billion swipe fee settlement (Reuters via The Spokesman-Review, Nov. 16, 2026)
  3. Visa, Mastercard urge approval of $38 billion swipe fee settlement (Reuters via Lufkin Daily News, Nov. 16, 2026)
  4. Visa, Mastercard $38B swipe fee settlement wins judge's approval (Reuters via The Daily Record, June 10, 2026)
  5. Visa, Mastercard urge court to approve fee settlement (Payments Dive, Oct. 2026)
  6. How the Visa-Mastercard card fee case may end (Payments Dive)
  7. Visa, Mastercard reach legal pact with merchants (Retail Dive)
  8. Merchants' Trade Groups, Businesses Tell Judge to Reject Settlement in Visa/MC Swipe Fee Case (Credit Union Daily)
  9. Why there's no end to Visa and Mastercard's fee battles with merchants (American Banker, June 2026)

About the author

Adrian Reyes

Adrian Reyes is Senior Payments & Fintech Editor for Beyond the Swipe, covering credit card processing, merchant accounts, payment technology and processing fees.

This article is for general educational purposes and is not legal, tax or financial advice. Card network rules and state laws change; confirm current requirements for your business.

Related reading