PayPal Surcharge Ban in Germany: What Sellers Should Know
Payments News

Germany Says PayPal's Surcharge Ban May Be Illegal: Seller Takeaways

Germany's cartel office says PayPal's surcharge ban in Germany may break competition law. What it means and how U.S. sellers can manage PayPal costs now.

Grid of twenty copper euro one-cent coins showing different national designs from across Europe on a white background

Photo: Pixabay

On this page 7 sections
  1. What Germany's Competition Regulator Found About PayPal's Surcharge Ban
  2. The Bundeskartellamt's PayPal Case Is Not Decided Yet
  3. Why Regulators Say PayPal Merchant Fees Run Higher
  4. Can Merchants Surcharge PayPal in the U.S.? Read the User Agreement First
  5. Legal Ways to Steer Shoppers to Cheaper Payment Methods
  6. What German and EU Shoppers Could See at Checkout If the Ban Falls
  7. Action Checklist: Audit Your Wallet Costs and Checkout Order

Key takeaways

  • Germany's preliminary finding changes no contracts yet. PayPal disputes it, and the regulator has not set a decision date.
  • PayPal's U.S. user agreement still bans surcharges. A "handling fee" that applies only to PayPal orders counts as a surcharge under those terms.
  • Card surcharging falls under network rules and state law. Neither one overrides PayPal's contract.
  • The tools U.S. sellers can use today are cost per payment method, checkout order and payment-method mix. Each one needs a contract check first.

Germany's Federal Cartel Office, the Bundeskartellamt, told PayPal on Wednesday, Nov. 11, 2026, that its rule barring merchants from charging extra for PayPal payments may break German and EU competition law. The finding is preliminary, PayPal disputes it, and no merchant contract has changed. For U.S. sellers, the fight over the PayPal surcharge ban in Germany is worth following, but PayPal's U.S. user agreement still prohibits surcharges, so the tools you control today are your cost data, your checkout order and your payment-method mix.

What Germany's Competition Regulator Found About PayPal's Surcharge Ban

The Bundeskartellamt sent its preliminary assessment to PayPal Holdings, Inc., PayPal (Europe) S.à r.l. et Cie, S.C.A. and PayPal Limited, according to Investing.com and Electronic Payments International. The target is PayPal's "Rules about surcharging," the contract terms that stop online shops in Germany from charging customers a separate fee for choosing PayPal. PayPal has prohibited those surcharges since 2018, heise online reports, and the authority found that PayPal enforces the rule and reserves the right to end its relationship with merchants who break it, per GRC Report.

The regulator's case rests on a gap between the law and the contract. German law generally lets a merchant charge customers for using PayPal as long as the fee doesn't exceed the merchant's actual cost. PayPal's terms take that option away. So merchants bake PayPal's cost into their product prices, and every shopper pays it, including people who check out with a cheaper method. A cheaper payment provider can't win on price at checkout if the shopper never sees a price difference.

Andreas Mundt, the authority's president, framed the problem in two parts: "For many people, PayPal is a natural way to pay for their online purchases." He added that PayPal is comparatively expensive for merchants, which makes dropping it hard and paying for it painful.

On the law, the Bundeskartellamt pointed to Section 1 of the German Competition Act (GWB) and Article 101(1) of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union, which prohibit anticompetitive agreements. It also cited the abuse-of-market-power provisions in German and European competition law. And it is weighing disgorgement, meaning it could seek to recover the economic benefit PayPal gained from any infringement.

The Bundeskartellamt's PayPal Case Is Not Decided Yet

A preliminary assessment is the authority's way of telling a company what it thinks the company did wrong before deciding anything. PayPal now gets to respond. A PayPal spokesperson told the German news agency dpa that the company does not share the authority's preliminary view and will keep engaging constructively with the proceeding, according to heise.

The case has been running for almost four years. The Bundeskartellamt opened the proceeding on Jan. 23, 2023, and it originally covered two clauses in PayPal's German user agreement: the surcharge rules and the "Presentation of PayPal" rules. The new assessment deals with the surcharge ban. In that 2023 announcement, the authority also noted that Germany's Federal Court of Justice ruled on March 25, 2021 (I ZR 203/19) that PayPal falls outside the statutory surcharge provision at issue. That ruling is why a PayPal fee is legal in Germany in principle, and why PayPal's contract is what blocks it.

German trade press has sketched two possible endings if the authority holds its view: PayPal offers binding commitments to change the clause, or the authority formally prohibits it. Either one would come later. As of Nov. 12, 2026, no decision date has been announced.

Why Regulators Say PayPal Merchant Fees Run Higher

The authority's preliminary finding is that PayPal's merchant fees are, on average, higher than those of other payment methods, and that shoppers who pay with PayPal see none of that cost. That combination is what turns a pricing question into a competition question.

Here is what "spread across all customers" looks like in numbers. The figures below are illustrative assumptions, not PayPal's or any processor's actual rates.

Illustrative assumptionValue
Monthly online sales$40,000
Share paid with PayPal30% ($12,000)
Assumed effective PayPal cost3.5%
Assumed effective card cost2.6%

On those assumptions, PayPal orders cost $420 a month ($12,000 × 3.5%) and card orders cost $728 ($28,000 × 2.6%). Total payment cost is $1,148, or 2.87% of sales. If PayPal cost the same as cards, the total would be $1,040, or 2.6%. The $108 difference is 0.27% of every dollar you sell, and with one price for everyone, card buyers, who bring in 70% of sales, cover part of it. That is the Bundeskartellamt's argument in miniature.

Two lessons for a U.S. store. First, the premium is real but rarely enormous at the order level: on a $60 order, a 0.9-point gap is about 54 cents. Second, dropping PayPal to save that 54 cents only works if the shopper finishes the purchase another way. Our breakdown of PayPal's fee and conversion tradeoffs walks through how to test that before you cut anything.

Can Merchants Surcharge PayPal in the U.S.? Read the User Agreement First

No. PayPal's U.S. user agreement, which governs U.S. PayPal accounts and businesses organized or operating in the United States, says: "You agree that you will not impose a surcharge or any other fee for accepting PayPal as a payment method."

The agreement does allow a handling fee, with two conditions: it can't operate as a surcharge, and it can't be higher than the handling fee you charge on non-PayPal orders. A "handling fee" that appears only when the shopper picks PayPal fails both tests. Renaming a surcharge doesn't make it something else, and doing it puts your PayPal account at risk.

The German case doesn't touch this. Even a final German decision would address PayPal's terms for the German market, not the U.S. contract. A U.S. business selling to German shoppers through a U.S. PayPal account is still bound by the U.S. agreement.

Card surcharging is a separate set of rules. Visa and Mastercard each publish their own surcharge requirements, and some states limit or prohibit surcharges by law. Those are network rules and state law, and they don't override a private contract like PayPal's. If you want to recover card costs, a compliant card surcharging program has to satisfy both layers. Confirm current network rules and your state's law with your processor and a qualified attorney before you start.

You can't penalize PayPal in the U.S., but you can shape which methods shoppers see and use. Each option below has a contract check attached, because the original German case also targeted how merchants present PayPal, and your U.S. integration terms may contain display requirements of their own.

  • Checkout order and defaults. Shoppers tend to pick what they see first. Putting card entry or a lower-cost wallet in the default position changes behavior without adding a fee. Compare the options in our guide to express checkout buttons like Shop Pay, Apple Pay and PayPal.
  • Payment-method mix. Offer the methods your customers actually use and drop the ones that add cost without adding sales. Our guide on which payment methods your online store should accept covers how to decide.
  • Discounts for other methods. A discount for paying another way is different from a PayPal surcharge in form, but read your PayPal terms before you offer one, and make sure the discount is real and applies to everyone who qualifies.
  • Lower your card cost. If PayPal's premium bothers you, the cheaper side of the comparison matters just as much. A review of your online payment processing statement shows what your card checkout actually costs per order.

What you should never do is disguise a payment fee, split it into another line item to dodge a contract, or misdescribe transactions to your processor. Those moves get accounts terminated.

What German and EU Shoppers Could See at Checkout If the Ban Falls

If PayPal drops or loses the clause, German merchants could add a PayPal fee capped at their actual cost. Germany's e-commerce trade association, bevh, welcomed the preliminary finding and called for price differences to be visible to shoppers, retail-news.de reports. German coverage has also pointed to European alternatives such as Wero as possible beneficiaries.

Many merchants would probably still absorb the cost to avoid friction at checkout. But some large German retailers could start showing a small PayPal fee next to a fee-free bank or card option, and shoppers would learn to compare. For a U.S. store that ships to Germany, that changes the competitive picture: local rivals might show a lower total for non-PayPal methods while your price stays flat. If you sell into Europe, review your international payment processing setup and how you show local prices without losing margin.

Action Checklist: Audit Your Wallet Costs and Checkout Order

  1. Pull 90 days of transactions and calculate your effective cost per method: total fees divided by total volume, for PayPal, cards and each other wallet.
  2. Rerun the illustrative table above with your real numbers to see what your PayPal premium costs as a share of all sales.
  3. Read the surcharge, handling-fee and display sections of every wallet agreement you've accepted, including PayPal's current U.S. version.
  4. Check your checkout order on mobile, where wallet buttons often stack above card entry, and decide on purpose which method sits first.
  5. Test one change at a time, such as button order, and measure completed orders, not just fee savings.
  6. If card costs are the bigger line, request a free processing quote from MannyPay and compare it against your current statement.

The next thing to watch is PayPal's formal response and whether the Bundeskartellamt moves to a decision or accepts commitments. If the clause falls in Germany, the question for U.S. sellers is whether other regulators start asking the same thing about wallet surcharge bans.

Sources

  1. PayPal faces German antitrust probe over merchant fee rules (Investing.com)
  2. Germany raises competition concerns over PayPal surcharging ban (Electronic Payments International)
  3. PayPal-Vorgaben: Kartellamt sieht Wettbewerb gefährdet (heise online)
  4. Germany Warns PayPal Its Payment Restrictions May Violate Competition Law (GRC Report)
  5. Bundeskartellamt initiates proceeding against PayPal (Bundeskartellamt press release, Jan. 23, 2023)
  6. The German Competition Authority preliminarily finds that a payment service provider's ban on surcharges may restrict competition (Concurrences)
  7. PayPal User Agreement, U.S. (PayPal, Inc.)
  8. Bundeskartellamt sieht in PayPals Aufschlagverbot ein Wettbewerbsrisiko (retail-news.de)
  9. PayPal-Gebühren: Kartellamt stellt Aufschlagverbot infrage (wortfilter.de)
  10. PayPal-Aufschlagsverbot: Bundeskartellamt sieht Wettbewerb in Deutschland gefährdet (netz-trends.de)

About the author

Adrian Reyes

Adrian Reyes is Senior Payments & Fintech Editor for Beyond the Swipe, covering credit card processing, merchant accounts, payment technology and processing fees.

This article is for general educational purposes and is not legal, tax or financial advice. Card network rules and state laws change; confirm current requirements for your business.

Related reading